- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes ProCon, a training-free method for industrial anomaly detection using frozen DINOv2 features. Instead of scoring a query by its distance to the nearest normal reference, it reconstructs the query from several distance-weighted normal neighbors and uses the reconstruction residual as the anomaly score. Separate memories are maintained at different encoder layers, with residuals aggregated across memory banks and layers. Experiments on MVTec-AD and VisA include comparisons with Dinomaly and INP-Former, same-memory scoring ablations, matched-storage comparisons, and inference-cost measurements.
Critical strengths
The same-memory comparison provides clear evidence for the proposed readout. Holding the encoder and stored references fixed, replacing nearest-neighbor distance with reconstruction residual improves pixel AP by 1.4 and 2.5 percentage points on MVTec-AD and VisA, respectively (Table 3). This isolates the benefit of scoring from changes in memory content.
The matched-storage comparison supports independent retrieval across layers. In the reported seed-0 experiment, independent reconstruction improves pixel AP and AUPRO over feature concatenation in all 27 categories (Table 4 and Appendix F). This is useful evidence that memory organization matters beyond its storage budget.
Critical weaknesses
The methodological novelty appears limited. The main design combines local neighbor reconstruction with layer-wise score aggregation. Tables 10–11 show that uniform and distance-weighted five-neighbor reconstruction differ by less than 0.1 percentage point in pixel AP on both datasets. Thus, the distinctive weighting rule contributes little to the reported gain, and the advance over existing reconstruction-based approaches needs a clearer justification.
The external comparisons do not adequately establish the contribution against the closest alternatives. PatchCore and FastRecon are discussed but not directly evaluated under comparable settings. In addition, the layers and aggregation rule were selected using MVTec-AD results without clearly specifying a separate selection split. These gaps limit confidence in the comparative advantage and in the MVTec-AD performance estimate.
Questions for authors
-
Can the authors provide comparisons with PatchCore and FastRecon using comparable backbone features, normal training data, and storage budgets where applicable? These comparisons would help distinguish the benefit of the proposed readout from improvements due to the feature extractor and implementation choices.
-
Which data and labels were used to select the layers and aggregation rule on MVTec-AD? Was selection independent of the reported evaluation set? If not, can the authors provide an evaluation with a separate selection split or held-out categories?
2 comments
I've seen the author's response regarding the contribution writing and the additional baseline experiments. First of all, thank you very much for providing those extra baseline comparisons.
However, I believe that if this manuscript is to be accepted, the writing still needs considerably more polish. The contributions and the methodology need to be explained much more clearly. Because of this, I am maintaining my original score.
I think the authors should take the time to thoroughly refine the writing and experiment before submitting it elsewhere. Therefore, I suggest that they use the reviewers' feedback from this round to put together a stronger version and make the logical flow of the writing much tighter.
Response to Reviewer V9SJ
We thank the reviewer for recognizing the same-memory and matched-storage comparisons. We clarify the contribution beyond distance weighting, add the requested external baselines, and make configuration selection explicit.
Q1. Contribution and comparisons with PatchCore and FastRecon
Our question is how normal-memory readout and layer-wise retrieval affect localization with frozen features. The revision separates these choices rather than attributing the complete detector's improvement to its weighting rule.
With identical memory, mean k-NN improves P-AP over 1-NN by 1.15 points on MVTec-AD and 1.92 on VisA after four-layer aggregation. Both centroid readouts achieve higher mean P-AP than mean k-NN, while mean k-NN has the highest AUPRO. Uniform and weighted centroids have similar aggregated P-AP; weighting helps most at layer −3 (Tables 3, 11, and 13).
Memory organization addresses a separate question. At exactly matched stored feature bytes in every category, independent reference selection and retrieval at each layer outperform selection and retrieval in a concatenated feature space in P-AP in all 27 categories for each of five seeds (Table 5, Figure 2, Table 14).
The contribution is controlled evidence about which retrieval and scoring choices matter and when they help. We compare the resulting detector with the requested baselines:
DINOv2-PatchCore and ProCon use the same four encoder blocks and exactly matched stored feature bytes per category: 111.1 MiB across MVTec-AD and 265.2 MiB across VisA. ProCon's category-paired P-AP gains are 8.41 and 11.81 points, with 95% CIs of [+4.03,+13.52] and [+4.55,+19.17]. Feature aggregation and storage precision differ, so this evaluates the complete detectors. Readout effects are assessed separately with identical memory tensors.
We evaluated FastRecon's public WRN50 configurations at 1/2/4/8 shots and a DINOv2 adaptation. The adaptation uses the same four DINOv2 layers, applies 3×3 average pooling, concatenates them into 2048 dimensions, and uses all normal training images as candidates. With public parser defaults ρ=0.001 and λ=2.0, it stores approximately one-tenth as many feature values as ProCon B=1. Appendix F.1 states this storage difference and the differences between the public-code and original-paper settings.
Q2. Configuration selection and presentation
The default layers and aggregation rule were selected using MVTec-AD test images and their image labels and pixel masks, without a separate validation split. The configuration was applied unchanged to VisA and Real-IAD.
We assessed sensitivity through retrospective reselection among 170 candidates under image half-split, category-held-out, and cross-dataset protocols. Each selection split excludes the images, category, or dataset used for its corresponding evaluation. MVTec-AD P-AP ranges from 73.91% to 74.84%. Selection on MVTec-AD before VisA evaluation recovers the default for all three seeds (Table 8).
These retrospective comparisons measure selection sensitivity; they do not make the original MVTec-AD evaluation independent of the initial configuration choice.
Real-IAD was excluded from development and configuration selection. The fixed B=5 configuration achieves 51.72±0.02% P-AP and 95.05±0.02% AUPRO across three seed groups, covering all 30 categories and five camera views. Aggregate and category-wise results appear in Tables 1 and 9.
We reorganized the introduction and experiments around readout and memory organization and consolidated external comparisons in Table 2. Both B=1 and B=5 combine four layers; B=5 additionally aggregates five banks within each layer.