- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
LATF-AD combines four complementary time-frequency views: short-window STFT, long-window STFT, continuous wavelet transform, smoothed pseudo Wigner–Ville distribution through a local content-dependent router, learns reconstruction and prediction heads, and incorporates raw-patch prototype evidence through a calibrated multiplicative-additive score. Experiments on TSB-AD-U/M report promising improvements and include component ablations.
Critical strengths
- The heterogeneous-view motivation is reasonable, and content-dependent fusion is relevant to anomalies with different temporal and spectral structures.
- The paper covers both univariate and multivariate settings and several metrics. Tables 2 and 6 provide useful view, branch, and head ablations.
Critical weaknesses
1.The prediction head is not causal as claimed in Eq. (5). Its GroupNorm aggregates across time, allowing future inputs to affect earlier predictions, as confirmed by a suffix-perturbation test. This is acceptable for offline detection, but conflicts with the stated forecasting mechanism. Please clarify the intended information flow and revise the formulation accordingly.
2. The central benefit of local adaptation needs a more direct control. Uniform fusion and view removal are useful, but a learned globally static router with the same encoders and heads would better isolate the value of locality. A raw-only result and simple additive fusion would clarify the benefit of the proposed score. Figure 5 already includes individual zero-coefficient cases; my request is for focused attribution, not an entirely new evaluation suite. The existing ablation scripts should also be supplied so these comparisons can be checked.
3. The uncertainty reported in Table 4 remains unexplained. The paper states that experiments are repeated ten times but does not define “±”. Genesis contains one series and has VUS-ROC 0.9991 ± 0.0179. For ten observations in [0,1] with mean m, their sample standard deviation cannot exceed sqrt(10)(1−m): approximately 0.00285 here, thus 0.0179 cannot be that standard deviation. The supplied reproduce.py runs a single configured seed and aggregates file means; it contains neither the ten-run results nor the uncertainty/table-generation procedure. This does not establish that the experiments were not performed, but the raw values, meaning of the error term, and aggregation procedure are necessary to assess the evidence.
Questions for authors
-
How is the causal prediction claim in Eq. (5) consistent with GroupNorm aggregating across time and allowing future information to affect earlier predictions?
-
Does local routing outperform learned static weights under the same backbone? How does the proposed fusion compare with raw-only scoring and simple additive fusion?
-
What does Table 4's “±” denote? Can you provide the ten Genesis scores and the table-generation procedure?
-
Since when , what evidence supports the claimed false-alarm control? How does patch normalization affect the raw branch’s ability to detect level and scale changes?
3 comments
Q4: False-alarm control and normalization of level and scale changes.
A4:
For score fusion, the submitted nonnegative evidence gives . Raw therefore cannot cancel a TF alert at the same numerical threshold. Its contribution is complementary evidence enhancement. In the submitted Table 2, removing Raw reduces VUS-PR from 0.60 to 0.56 on U and from 0.46 to 0.44 on M. We will revise the artifact-rejection explanation to match this scoring behavior.
For each channel within a patch, Raw computes . Thus, for a constant offset . For positive scaling, , where . Whole-patch offsets are removed, and positive scaling is approximately removed when the variance dominates the stabilizer.
Patches crossing the onset or end of a level or scale change can retain a within-patch shape difference because they contain both regimes. Patches wholly inside a sustained change lose the offset or much of the scale evidence. The TF branch uses prefix-fitted normalization, so it does not share Raw's per-patch invariance. We will clarify these normalization properties and the distinction between anomaly boundaries and interiors.
Follow-up on Our Responses
Dear Reviewer,
Thank you for your time and constructive feedback, which have helped improve the paper.
We would greatly appreciate it if you could review our responses and share any remaining concerns when you have a chance. We would be happy to provide further clarification or answer any additional questions.
We look forward to your further feedback. Thanks again!
Thank you for the insightful comments!
Q1: GroupNorm and the causal prediction claim in Eq. (5).
A1:
GroupNorm computes statistics across time, including in evaluation mode. Consequently, the one-frame input shift and left-padded convolutions do not make the submitted temporal branch strictly causal. The symmetric encoders and centered routing operations also introduce future dependence.
We tested 36 trained checkpoints from 12 series selected in advance using input metadata and three seeds. We zeroed either the latent suffix zℓ:L before the one-frame shift or the complete TF network's input suffix M:,:,ℓ:L, then compared the prediction at frame ℓ with its unmodified value. Model parameters and fitted preprocessing statistics were fixed. The maximum absolute changes on CPU in evaluation mode were as follows.
These results confirm the submitted implementation's future dependence. We will describe LATF-AD as an offline anomaly detector and revise Eq. (5) to Mℓpred=[Pψpred(S(z1:L))]ℓ, where S(z1:L)=(0,z1,…,zL−1). The temporal branch learns temporal consistency from shifted latent representations. Fitting and calibration use the benchmark-designated training prefix, while inference uses the complete observed sequence. These clarifications retain the submitted implementation.
Q2: Learned static routing, Raw-only scoring, additive fusion, and implementation details.
A2:
The submitted Table 2 reports the following ablation results.
These comparisons support the contribution of learned fusion relative to equal weighting and the contribution of Raw evidence to the complete detector.
The submitted score is St=TFt(1+αgt)+βgt, with α=0.25 and β=20. It contains TF evidence, a joint term αTFtgt, and an additive Raw term βgt. The joint term increases Raw's contribution when TF evidence is also strong, while the additive term allows Raw evidence to contribute when TF is weak. Algebraically, α=0 yields additive fusion, β=0 retains multiplicative modulation, and α=β=0 gives TF-only scoring. These identities explain the score's components. The empirical claims above are based on the reported uniform-fusion and Raw-removal ablations.
Q3: Meaning of Table 4's uncertainty and the ten Genesis scores.
A3:
The reported Genesis entry, 0.9991 ± 0.0179, is incorrect. We completed a new ten-seed evaluation using the submitted implementation and fixed benchmark JSON configurations. It covers all 350 U and 180 M evaluation files, with seeds 20260805 through 20260814, totaling 5,300 file-seed runs. Both TF and Raw were retrained for every run.
Here, ± denotes the sample standard deviation across ten seed-level means. For each subset or benchmark, Qs=N1∑i=1Nqi,s, Qˉ=101∑s=110Qs, and SD=91∑s=110(Qs−Qˉ)2. Files have equal weight within each seed. Genesis contains one file, so its ten seed-level values are the individual run scores.
These runs give Genesis VUS-ROC of 0.999533 ± 0.000157 and VUS-PR of 0.828734 ± 0.049034. For SED's two files, the same aggregation gives VUS-ROC of 0.999215 ± 0.000057 and VUS-PR of 0.977010 ± 0.002599.
The complete new benchmark results are as follows.
These are newly measured results. We will use them to correct the LATF-AD row in Table 1, Table 4's means and uncertainty values, and the corresponding performance statements. An independent recomputation matched all 504 mean and SD entries across 40 dataset subsets and two benchmark rows within an absolute difference below 10−12.