- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a "consolidate-then-refine" framework for 3D target detection using LiDAR-4D Radar in adverse weather conditions, which includes independent modality encoding, center candidate voting, and two-stage geometric condition decoding. The method achieved high detection results on K-Radar v2.1. However, the current paper has serious problems in writing, innovative argumentation, and experimental design. The main text fails to clearly convey the core problem solved by the paper; the main mechanism is not established in comparison with existing 3D detection methods; and the experiments are insufficient to support the main conclusion of the paper regarding robustness in adverse weather conditions.
Overall, the quality of this paper is really poor, I therefore suggest rejection.
Critical strengths
- The research topic has practical significance, and the complementarity between LiDAR and 4D Radar is also quite clear.
- The numerical results on K-Radar v2.1 are relatively competitive.
- The paper provides some supplementary experiments, failure cases, and mechanism visualizations.
Critical weaknesses
-
The readability of the paper is seriously lacking. The abstract is too short, containing only a brief background, the name of the framework, and a general result, without clearly explaining the core challenges, why the methods can solve these challenges, the main experimental findings, and the scope of application of the methods. The introduction is more like a list of related works, lacking a clear "problem - related work - challenge - motivation - method" logic. What's worse, the length of the main text and the information it carries are significantly insufficient. Much key content is compressed into supplementary materials, resulting in insufficient space for the main text. Moreover, the main text only has one framework diagram and one qualitative result diagram, lacking explanatory diagrams for central voting, the Radar encoder, two-stage sampling, and failure modes. The existing Figure 1 is generated directly by the Agent, which is too abstract. Figure 2 is a result puzzle and cannot fulfill the function of method explanation.
-
The innovative argument is not sufficiently supported. The generation of candidate center heatmaps, initialization of candidate objects, object queries with deformable attention, and secondary feature sampling based on initial boxes all belong to relatively mature designs in 3D detection. CenterFormer has already used center candidate initialization for Transformer queries and combined it with multi-scale deformable attention. Therefore, this paper needs to clearly explain the substantial technical differences between center voting and box-conditioned refinement compared to existing methods. The current paper more presents a combination of several existing mechanisms, without demonstrating that this combination has a unique necessity for adverse weather conditions.
-
The experimental quality is insufficient to support the main conclusion. The experiment only used one dataset, K-Radar. Although the paper acknowledged this, it is an issue that cannot be bypassed in the experimental part. The comparison method is obviously incomplete. The main text only compared PointPillars, BEVFusion, L4DR, and ASF, without including many of the latest published works. Without these methods, the paper cannot fully claim that the current results represent the state of the art.
Questions for authors
See all of Critical Weaknesses
3 comments
Thank you for your detailed response. However, I believe the quality of the initial draft is still far from meeting the standards required for acceptance at a top-tier machine learning conference, and this gap cannot be bridged through rebuttal alone.
The authors should take time to study what constitutes a good paper and thoroughly refine their work before submission, rather than submitting an AI-generated report that suffers from poor readability.
Therefore, I maintain my original score.
Thank you for your follow-up. We acknowledge that our manuscript has room for improvement in presentation, but we disagree with your overall assessment of its quality. We do not believe the paper deserves such a sweeping dismissal. We have carefully addressed the concerns raised in your original review, yet your latest comment does not engage with our response. Combined with the generic and formulaic nature of some criticisms in the original review, this leaves us questioning whether our work has received a careful and independent reading.
We thank the reviewer for the constructive comments. Alongside the improved drawing of Figure 1, we provide a direct technical comparison with CenterFormer, present evidence of radar's contribution under different weather and LiDAR visibility conditions, and clarify the evaluation protocol and comparison scope.
W1. Readability
Abstract. The abstract identifies the sensing challenge, the fusion strategy, and the main findings.
Introduction and main text. The introduction follows a problem–related work–challenge–motivation–method progression. Paragraphs 1–2 establish weather-induced LiDAR degradation and radar's complementary but coarse observations. Paragraphs 3–4 review local, BEV, and query-based fusion, identifying displaced evidence, coupled representations, and duplicate candidates as challenges. These motivate independent modality features and unified object hypotheses, leading to the consolidate-then-refine design in paragraph 5. Sections 3.2–3.4 detail the radar encoder, voting, and two-stage sampling.
Explanatory diagrams. The redrawn Figure 1 preserves the content and structure of our hand-drawn original. Candidate paths meet at center voting to form shared hypotheses. D1 samples around each center and predicts a preliminary box, whose geometry guides refinement in D2. Arrows from the two feature streams show that both stages read each modality's features, while the insets illustrate their sampling references. Figures C2–C3 show voting and sampling on actual scenes, and Appendix D.2 illustrates failure modes.
Figure 2 provides a qualitative comparison of detection results. Within each weather group, the rows compare methods on the same frame, and the image, radar BEV, and LiDAR BEV views show corresponding targets. The caption identifies the methods, weather groups, and prediction/annotation markers.
W2. Technical differences from prior methods
Center voting and box-conditioned refinement. CenterFormer's released single-frame model also uses two decoder layers. The differences concern candidate consolidation, feature sources, and sampling geometry.
Adverse weather conditions. When LiDAR evidence is weak, radar candidates can still support object hypotheses. Sedan AP is similar in Normal at 64.83 for LiDAR-only and 64.53 for fusion, while Heavy snow shows a gain from 53.18 to 60.78 (+7.60 points; Table 5). Among 334 Heavy-snow Sedan objects with no LiDAR points inside their ground-truth boxes, LiDAR-only, radar-only, and the full model detect 0, 97, and 104, respectively (confidence > 0.3, 3D IoU > 0.5). These results support radar's complementary role under degraded LiDAR observations (Appendices B.2–B.3).
W3. Dataset coverage and recent comparisons
K-Radar provides synchronized LiDAR, the radar power inputs required by our encoder, and seven weather categories. Evaluation on another dataset requires adapting the radar-input pipeline and establishing new training and evaluation settings. This additional work could not be completed within the revision period.
Further comparisons were limited by access to implementations and weights. Pretrained 3D-LRF weights were unavailable to us, and our attempt with the released code did not reproduce its reported results. Official REL code and weights could not be obtained, and DLR-Fusion's linked repository was unavailable during our checks. We appreciate the reviewer's understanding of these constraints.
Published AP cannot be directly reused under our protocol. The original K-Radar heading export rotates boxes by 90° relative to their physical orientation, changing IoUs and detection matches. Correcting this requires re-evaluating predictions (Appendix A.3). Under the common protocol, L4DR and ASF (NeurIPS 2025) checkpoints yield 56.47 and 52.61 mAP, versus our 65.96. The 9.49-point gain refers to this evaluated set.