- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes TMF, a framework for 3D object detection using LiDAR and 4D radar in adverse weather conditions. It employs TRD to suppress noise across multiple radar frames, utilizes RGTC to retrieve historical LiDAR features based on radar priors, and incorporates DGPF to perform degradation-aware gating for temporal compensation. Performance improvements in adverse weather conditions are demonstrated on the K-Radar dataset.
Critical strengths
(1) Adverse weather conditions can lead to sparse foreground data and a loss of structural information in LiDAR point clouds, whereas 4D radar remains relatively stable in rain, snow, and fog. Leveraging historical observations to compensate for the degradation of the current frame is a compelling area of research within the context of LiDAR–4D radar fusion.
(2) The paper reports results across two protocols (K-Radar V1.0 and V2.0), two IoU thresholds (0.5 and 0.3), and seven weather conditions. It also includes analyses of temporal length, Top-K ratios, component contributions, and computational overhead.
Critical weaknesses
(1) The core performance gains shrink significantly when compared against a strictly matched baseline. In Table 4, the L4DR baseline used for the component ablation study achieves an overall AP3D of 56.64, while the full TMF model reaches 57.77, representing an actual net gain of only +1.13. The 6.49% AP3D gain highlighted in the abstract and the contributions section actually corresponds to the comparison involving the original L4DR or L4DR-MF (as shown in Table 1), rather than the temporally-matched baseline presented in the appendix.
(2) The mechanism for the spatiotemporal alignment of historical LiDAR features remains unclear. In Figure 2, "ego-motion alignment" is explicitly depicted only for the 4D radar branch; for the LiDAR branch, the data proceeds directly from voxelization into the BEV encoder and memory bank. Neither the main text nor the appendix explains how historical LiDAR point clouds or BEV features are transformed into the current coordinate system using ego-pose information, nor is there any description of how dynamic objects are handled.
(3) The temporal baselines are too weak, and the inclusion of additional supervision in DGPF compromises fairness. InterFusion-MF and L4DR-MF merely concatenate multi-frame point clouds, representing the most rudimentary type of temporal baseline. Furthermore, the paper fails to provide comparisons with other temporal approaches (e.g., QTNet [1], MSF [2]).
(4) The claim of "consistent improvements" is not supported by the experimental results. In Table 4, performance under "Fog" and "Rain" conditions shows a decline relative to the matched baseline. Similarly, in Table 1, the TMF results are lower than those of REL for the "Overcast" (71.1 vs. 71.5), "Rain" (53.8 vs. 55.4), and "Light Snow" (67.2 vs. 67.4) categories. Furthermore, at IoU=0.5 on V2.0, performance for "Sedan" under "Sleet" conditions, as well as for "Bus/Truck" under "Overcast" and "Light Snow" conditions, also shows a decline. While the paper may claim advantages overall or under certain challenging weather conditions, it cannot claim consistent improvements across all weather types and evaluation protocols.
(5) The object gate in DGPF utilizes a binary cross-entropy (BCE) loss and a foreground-background contrastive loss, both derived from ground-truth (GT) bounding boxes; however, the primary baseline lacks equivalent additional supervision. Consequently, some of the performance gains observed in the full model may stem from this extra GT-based gate supervision rather than from the reliability-aware temporal fusion mechanism itself. This appears to be a general module, seemingly tangential to the core problem addressed in the paper: object detection under adverse weather conditions.
[1] Query-based Temporal Fusion with Explicit Motion for 3D Object Detection
[2] MSF: Motion-guided Sequential Fusion for Efficient 3D Object Detection from Point Cloud Sequences
Questions for authors
(1) The method proposed in the paper is based on the fusion of LiDAR and radar modality. Why is the visualization presented from the camera's perspective?
3 comments
Thanks for the authors' response. My concerns have been addressed. I decide to raise my score to 3.
Thank you, Reviewer TEvq, for your insightful comments and positive reassessment of our work. We have incorporated most of the revisions and clarifications addressed in our rebuttal into the manuscript and appendix. We will further refine their presentation to make the final version more concise and consistent.
We thank the reviewer for the thoughtful comments and feedback. Our point-to-point responses are as follows.
W1: The performance gains are modest.
We acknowledge that the overall gain is modest and varies across weather conditions. Compared with adapted L4DR, TMF improves overall AP3D from 56.64% to 57.77% (+1.13 points). Gains occur under Normal (54.49% vs. 60.04%), Overcast (68.42% vs. 71.05%), Sleet (50.58% vs. 51.22%), Light Snow (62.82% vs. 67.24%), and Heavy Snow (40.33% vs. 46.84%) conditions, while decreases occur under Fog (77.33% vs. 75.99%) and Rain (54.01% vs. 53.75%). The results show benefits across several conditions, although decreases in others offset some gains. We attribute this partly to variations in data distributions across weather conditions. The 6.49% AP3D gain in the Abstract and Contributions is relative to original L4DR. We have clarified the statements.
W2: Insufficient clarification of ego-motion alignment in the LiDAR branch and the handling of dynamic objects.
Historical LiDAR features retrieved from Memory Bank are aligned with current frame using ego-pose information before temporal fusion. We have clarified the process in the manuscript. TMF uses reliable historical cues to compensate for missing target information in current frame. For dynamic objects, TMF implicitly learns to reduce contribution of unreliable historical cues caused by residual motion misalignment, mitigating the interference with current frame predictions.
W3: Lack of comparisons with other temporal approaches.
We added QTNet [1] and MSF [2] baselines by using MTM and BiFA blocks into L4DR's LiDAR branch, respectively, with concatenated multi-frame Radar inputs. All methods use identical inputs and backbones. Results on K-Radar V1.0 at IoU=0.5 are shown below. Additional results are provided in the manuscript.
W4: The claim of "consistent improvements" is not supported by the experimental results.
We acknowledge that the results do not show consistent gains across all weather conditions. Thus, we have revised relevant statements throughout the Abstract, Contributions, experimental analysis, and Conclusion to avoid overstatement.
W5: Potential performance gains from additional GT-based gate supervision and unclear relevance of DGPF to adverse-weather object detection.
First, we conducted an ablation study by only removing GT-based gate loss (Appendix). AP3D decreases from 57.77% to 57.62% at IoU=0.5 and from 79.37% to 79.06% at IoU=0.3, indicating a marginal contribution from the supervision. Second, DGPF is designed to mitigate weakened target responses in adverse weather. It assesses local information reliability based on current and historical responses, inter-frame discrepancies, and historical temporal variability. The gates learn the reliability cues to regulate temporal compensation.
Q1: Lack of justification for using camera-view visualizations in a LiDAR–Radar fusion method.
Following REL [3], we use the camera view solely to provide a more intuitive visualization of detection results.
[1] Hou J, Liu Z, Zou Z, et al. Query-based temporal fusion with explicit motion for 3d object detection[J]. Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, 2023, 36: 75782-75797.
[2] He C, Li R, Zhang Y, et al. Msf: Motion-guided sequential fusion for efficient 3d object detection from point cloud sequences[C]//2023 IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR). IEEE, 2023: 5196-5205.
[3] Tong T, Liu X, Liu H, et al. Towards accurate 3D object detection in adverse weather by leveraging 4D radar for LiDAR geometry enhancement[C]//Proceedings of the AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence. 2026, 40(12): 9548-9556.