- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
SGDet3D++ advances 4D radar-camera fusion from scene-level BEV alignment to object-level integration conditioned on dynamic 3D hypotheses. It employs AGR, GCR, and DVC to constrain semantic retrieval, geometric refinement, and temporal memory inheritance, respectively, yielding performance gains on the OmniHD-Scenes, ManTruckScenes, and TJ4DRadSet datasets.
Critical strengths
(1) Advancing 4D radar-camera fusion from scene-level BEV alignment to object-level fusion conditioned on dynamic 3D hypotheses.
(2) Achieving strong performance on the OmniHD-Scenes, ManTruckScenes, and TJ4DRadSet datasets.
Critical weaknesses
(1) The proposed components have already been widely used in camera-LiDAR fusion methods. For example, OPEN [1] projects LiDAR points to generate sparse GT depth map for camera backbone and uses 3D object queries to detect 3D objects. SparseFusion [2] adopts bi-directional LiDAR and camera modality fusion strategy. Sparse4D [3] adopts 3D deformable attention to aggregate local features. I don not think the proposed method is novel compared to previous methods.
(2) The paper lacks some implementation details. For example, there is not the description of image and radar backbones. This makes a fair comparison with previous methods impossible, as it is unclear whether the backbone scale and the models are the same.
(3) The authors identify RaCFormer and CVFusion as the most relevant methods for object-level fusion. However, RaCFormer is absent from all primary tables, ablation studies, and robustness experiments for both OmniHD-Scenes and ManTruckScenes, while CVFusion is evaluated only on the TJ4DRadSet dataset. Given that the paper’s core argument is that existing query/proposal-based methods fail to explicitly verify evidence–hypothesis compatibility, the omission of these two architecturally similar baselines is a significant gap. The authors should include results for these two methods on the two primary datasets.
(4) Table 5 presents the mean and standard deviation derived from three independent runs. However, for the results in Tables 1–3 and those concerning TJ4DRadSet, it is not explicitly stated whether each method’s results represent a single run, a specific checkpoint, or the mean across multiple random seeds.
[1] OPEN: Object-wise Position Embedding for Multi-view 3D Object Detection
[2] Sparse4D v3: Advancing End-to-End 3D Detection and Tracking
[3] SparseFusion: Fusing Multi-Modal Sparse Representations for Multi-Sensor 3D Object Detection
Questions for authors
(1) What are the differences between this method and existing camera-LiDAR fusion-based 3D object detection methods?