- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes GCSA and SG-GSR for adverse-weather LiDAR–RGB–gated 3D detection. GCSA preserves gated slice identity through shared independent encoding and geometry-conditioned aggregation, while SG-GSR refines same-class scores using gated, LiDAR, and depth evidence without retraining. On SeeingThroughFog, the full model reaches 69.72 Overall 3D AP40, outperforming the pseudo-RGB baseline by 3.60 points and SAMFusion by 2.22–4.50 points across day/night/snow/fog.
Critical strengths
Considering each slice separately is a great insight, and the geometric conditions are also carefully designed. I think this is very good.
1.Clear, physically grounded problem diagnosis: It identifies pseudo-RGB slice conflation and evidence-blind suppression, with a clear problem-to-method mapping.
2.Complementary, low-intrusion design: GCSA preserves slice identity via shared encoding and geometric routing; SG-GSR only refines scores without changing boxes, labels, or requiring detector retraining.
3.Solid experiments and mechanism analysis: It reports consistent gains on SeeingThroughFog (69.72 Overall 3D AP40, +3.60 over baseline), clean ablations, favorable efficiency (66.5% fewer gated parameters, 19.6% lower latency), and supplementary diagnostic checks.
Critical weaknesses
GCSA’s geometric conditions rely on projecting LiDAR into the RGB and gated views. If the sensors are not synchronized, calibration errors are large, or the projected LiDAR is extremely sparse, the geometric conditions can become unreliable, and the router’s slice weights may be misled. The paper itself acknowledges this.I think it would be worth trying to simulate point cloud misalignment to quantify how much performance degradation this causes.
Questions for authors
GCSA’s geometric conditions rely on projecting LiDAR into the RGB and gated views. If the sensors are not synchronized, calibration errors are large, or the projected LiDAR is extremely sparse, the geometric conditions can become unreliable, and the router’s slice weights may be misled. The paper itself acknowledges this.I think it would be worth trying to simulate point cloud misalignment to quantify how much performance degradation this causes. I think this paper is worth a weak accept. But I think it can be more complete if you can add data about misalignment's impact.
4 comments
Response to Reviewer TkeB (2/2)
Projection-error magnitude and sparse geometry
Effect of perturbation magnitude. Table 2 reports all 16 signed RGB projection-path settings. GCSA's AP drop is 0.1728–0.3320 at ±0.1° yaw and reaches 8.8962 at -1°, the largest tested angular magnitude. At that same -1° setting, pseudo-RGB and uniform aggregation drop by 8.4707 and 8.4808 AP, respectively, while GCSA retains the highest AP (60.3861). Thus, the large loss occurs under a specified projection error and is also present in the baselines; it should be interpreted alongside the matched baseline response and the smaller routing-only effects in Table 1A.
Table 2. Overall 3D AP₄₀ for every tested RGB projection-path perturbation, with both signs retained at each magnitude. The unperturbed row gives this study's own reference for each model. Each row uses the same perturbation across models; yaw and lateral translations are applied separately.
| RGB perturbation | Pseudo-RGB | Uniform | GCSA |
|---|---|---|---|
| Unperturbed | 66.0510 | 67.1718 | 69.2823 |
| Yaw -0.1° | 65.8734 | 66.8672 | 69.1095 |
| Yaw +0.1° | 65.8468 | 67.2963 | 68.9503 |
| Yaw -0.25° | 65.2672 | 66.0063 | 68.4528 |
| Yaw +0.25° | 65.2052 | 66.9591 | 68.3469 |
| Yaw -0.5° | 63.3766 | 64.2008 | 66.2247 |
| Yaw +0.5° | 62.3368 | 65.2664 | 66.5549 |
| Yaw -1° | 57.5803 | 58.6910 | 60.3861 |
| Yaw +1° | 57.2059 | 60.0433 | 62.6721 |
| Lateral -2 cm | 66.0610 | 67.0423 | 69.1833 |
| Lateral +2 cm | 66.0879 | 67.2015 | 69.0639 |
| Lateral -5 cm | 66.0753 | 66.8744 | 69.2125 |
| Lateral +5 cm | 65.9668 | 67.3882 | 69.1781 |
| Lateral -10 cm | 65.8324 | 66.5611 | 69.1120 |
| Lateral +10 cm | 65.7375 | 67.2833 | 69.0938 |
| Lateral -20 cm | 65.1193 | 65.9130 | 68.3662 |
| Lateral +20 cm | 65.0520 | 66.7538 | 68.8783 |
Sparse projected geometry. We retain 50%, 25%, or 10% of valid native gated-depth samples before resizing, using identical nested random masks across models. GCSA retains the highest AP at every tested level (Table 3). Its largest drop is 0.1187 AP, at 25% retention. With only 10% retained, it achieves 69.2486 AP, a drop of 0.0658 AP from its unperturbed reference. This supports tolerance to sparse projected geometric conditions under the tested protocol.
Table 3. Overall 3D AP₄₀ under gated projected-depth thinning. The 100% row gives this study's own unperturbed references. Raw LiDAR detector points are retained.
| Native samples retained | Pseudo-RGB | Uniform | GCSA |
|---|---|---|---|
| 100% | 66.0517 | 67.1016 | 69.3144 |
| 50% | 66.1039 | 67.1406 | 69.2679 |
| 25% | 66.1259 | 67.1001 | 69.1957 |
| 10% | 66.0921 | 67.1564 | 69.2486 |
Together, these results quantify limited sensitivity to corrupted routing conditions and a retained accuracy advantage under the tested projection errors and projected-depth sparsity.
Your response is very good and addresses my concern. I am willing to maintain a positive score of 3, but I do not think this paper deserves a 4.
Your response is very good and addresses my concern. I am willing to maintain a positive score of 3, but I do not think this paper deserves a 4.
Thank you for your positive assessment and for confirming that our response addresses your concern. We appreciate your constructive suggestion to evaluate geometric reliability. The resulting perturbation and sparsity analyses have strengthened our experimental evaluation and are included in the revised manuscript.
Response to Reviewer TkeB (1/2)
Projection reliability and sparse geometry (W1 / Q1)
Thank you for the positive assessment and for suggesting a quantitative evaluation of projection reliability. To address whether unreliable geometry compromises GCSA, we distinguish perturbations of its routing conditions from perturbations of the detector's projection path. We evaluate the RGB and gated views separately on all 1,941 test frames, using fixed checkpoints without retraining or additional Gaussian Soft-NMS/SG-GSR.
Controlled perturbations. For each view, we test yaw offsets of ±0.1°, ±0.25°, ±0.5°, and ±1.0°, and lateral translations of ±2, ±5, ±10, and ±20 cm, separately: 16 signed settings. Cached view-specific depth geometry is backprojected, transformed, and reprojected. Router-only perturbations change GCSA's geometric condition, including validity and cross-view discrepancy. Projection-path perturbations additionally change the corresponding extrinsic and projection matrices used by the detector. Images, the other view's geometry, and raw LiDAR detector points remain unchanged.
Sensitivity to unreliable routing conditions. Across all 16 settings, the maximum AP drop is 0.1147 for gated geometry and 0.0588 for RGB geometry (Table 1A). These results directly address the concern about corrupted geometric conditions: detection accuracy exhibits limited sensitivity when the perturbation is confined to GCSA's routing inputs within the tested ranges.
Comparison under projection-path perturbations. Table 1B compares all three methods under the same 16 settings for each view. Perturbing the detector's projection path has a larger effect than perturbing routing conditions alone, particularly for RGB. Nevertheless, GCSA achieves higher absolute AP than both baselines at every tested setting. Minimum margins over uniform aggregation and pseudo-RGB are 1.5918/2.4898 AP for gated perturbations and 1.2885/2.8058 AP for RGB perturbations. This establishes a retained accuracy advantage under the tested projection errors; the comparison distinguishes this advantage from the magnitude of each model's degradation.
Table 1. Overall 3D AP₄₀ drops under controlled perturbations. Each mean includes all 16 signed settings with equal weight; each maximum covers those same settings. Drops subtract perturbed AP from the corresponding model's own unperturbed AP; negative values denote improvements. Uniform denotes shared-slice encoding with uniform aggregation.