- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies rhythmic multi-omics dynamics involving feedback between molecular layers that operate on different timescales. The authors propose a Hierarchical Cyclic Neural ODE that combines a closed-loop topology, a Stuart–Landau oscillatory prior, and orbit-centered neural residuals. They use cyclic small-gain analysis to study the boundedness and regional orbital stability of the latent dynamics and to guide the design of a stability regularizer for training. Experiments evaluate on two datasets: a mouse liver dataset with four omics layers and a Neurospora crassa dataset with two layers. The method achieves the lowest mean MSE for each of the three evaluated omics layers in Table 1 and the lowest average MSE across the two layers in Table 2.
Critical strengths
- The architecture combines explicit feedback between omics layers, a Stuart–Landau oscillatory prior, and orbit-centered neural residuals. This provides a structured latent dynamical model for rhythmic multi-omics time series.
- The cyclic small-gain analysis provides theoretical support for trajectory boundedness and exponential orbital attraction, offering a stability perspective on the proposed architecture.
Critical weaknesses
- The exponential attraction result in item 2 of Theorem 1 requires the initial state to satisfy z0∈B ={z:V(e)≤c⋆}. However, the paper does not clarify how this regional guarantee applies to the initial states used for forecasting or the perturbed states in the phase response experiments. Figure 4 and Appendix F provide loop gain monitoring and local stability diagnostics, but do not establish whether these experimental states satisfy the required regional condition.
- The ablations change multiple components simultaneously, making it difficult to attribute performance gains to individual design choices. Cyclic No-Prior removes both the oscillatory prior and the stability penalty, while Acyclic Cascade replaces the oscillatory prior with linear damping and removes the return edge. These comparisons do not fully isolate the individual contributions of the oscillatory prior and the feedback topology to forecasting performance.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors verify whether the initial latent states used for forecasting and the perturbed states in the phase response experiments satisfy the certified regional condition V(e)≤c⋆?
- How does removing only the return edge, while retaining the Stuart–Landau prior, affect forecasting performance?
- How does replacing the Stuart–Landau prior with linear damping affect forecasting performance when the closed-loop topology is retained under comparable training settings?
3 comments
Thanks for the responses, which have solved my major concerns. I will maintain my positive rating.
Thank you for following up. The isolated ablations you suggested, namely, removing only the return edge and replacing only the prior, now more clearly separate the contributions of the prior and the topology in both Tables 1 and 2. We have also added a third dataset, the yeast metabolic cycle, to test forecasting over two unseen cycles (Appendix H).
Response to Reviewer Z7sQ
We thank the reviewer for feedback regarding stability guarantees and ablations.
1. Initial States, Perturbations, and the Certified Region (W1, Q1)
By retraining the mouse liver model with the stability penalty evaluated at the inner radius δk=0.75rk∗ rather than in the δk→rk∗ limit, the loop gain at that radius is ρ = 0.991, 0.990 and 0.974 on the three seeds (mean 0.985), each below one, which certifies the invariant region B={V(e)≤c∗} with c∗=minkpk(rk∗−δk). The reported half-width of 5.2% (mean over the three seeds, ranging from 4.6% to 5.6%) is the largest radial deviation a single layer can carry inside B, c∗/pk, expressed as a fraction of rk∗ and taken at the most restrictive layer. The encoded initial state z(0) starts outside this region, but its trajectory enters it within 2.5 h on every seed and remains inside through the forecast window, at no cost in forecasting accuracy (Section 3.4, lines 298 to 305). The impulses of 0.30rk∗ used in the phase response experiments place the perturbed states outside this certified region, so their return to Γ is an empirical observation rather than a consequence of Theorem 1, and in every perturbed run the trajectory contracts back to the limit cycle.
2. Isolated Ablations (W2, Q2, Q3)
We evaluated targeted ablations across 6 seeds (for van der Pol, 5 on Neurospora and 4 on mouse, as it diverged on the remaining seeds) by testing alternative geometries (Cyclic + van der Pol) against an unpenalized control (Cyclic + SL Prior (No Penalty)), replacing the Stuart-Landau prior with linear damping (Cyclic + Linear Damping), and retaining the Stuart-Landau prior while severing the return edge (Acyclic + SL Prior). As detailed in the General Response, Tables 1 and 2, Section 4.3 (lines 430 to 472), and Table 5 (Appendix F):
Together, the limit-cycle prior provides orbital stability while the closed-loop topology enables causal cross-layer feedback and achieves the strongest forecasting accuracy.