acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Context-fNODE: Context-aware Fractional Neural Ordinary Differential Equation

Abstract

While standard Neural Ordinary Differential Equations (ODEs) excel at modeling continuous dynamics, their strictly Markovian nature limits their capacity to capture the macroscopic long-tail memory inherent in physical kinematics. Existing fractional neural models address this historical inertia but restrictively assume isotropic scalar operators and fully autonomous, closed environments. To overcome these limitations, we propose the Context-aware Fractional Neural ODE (Context-fNODE), a unified mixed-order architecture. Context-fNODE replaces commensurate scalar operators with an incommensurate, vectorized Grünwald-Letnikov derivative to natively capture direction-specific anisotropic inertia. This framework is mathematically coupled with a co-evolving first-order latent environment to absorb unobservable exogenous perturbations. Theoretically, we prove this formulation bounds the spatial error manifold, strictly suppresses chaotic Lyapunov divergence, and preserves a linear numerical convergence rate. Extensive evaluations on chaotic dynamic systems and complex 3D kinematics demonstrate that Context-fNODE significantly outperforms state-of-the-art baselines, establishing superior long-horizon forecasting endurance in non-autonomous, anisotropic environments.

Primary area:
neurosymbolic & hybrid AI systems (physics-informed, logic & formal reasoning, etc.)
Keywords:
Neural ODE, fractional calculus, Grünwald-Letnikov derivative, anisotropic inertia, non-autonomous dynamical systems, long-horizon forecasting

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_darmOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes Context-fNODE, a fractional Neural ODE for 3D trajectory forecasting. It is motivated by the claim that first-order Neural ODEs, "constrained by a Markovian assumption," predict future states from the present alone and so fail to capture inertia and long-tail memory. The authors also identify an isotropic limitation in existing fractional models, which use a single scalar fractional order across all spatial axes,

To address these issues, the method uses a vectorized Grünwald–Letnikov derivative with a separate fractional order per axis for asymmetric systems, where the infinite memory sum is truncated to a finite window. It also adds a latent context, extracted from the observed history, that co-evolves with the spatial trajectory as a first-order system. This is intended to account for unobservable exogenous forces.

The paper also gives theoretical results: well-posedness, a Mittag-Leffler error bound, a claimed suppression of chaotic divergence, and linear convergence of the discretized solver.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper provides an intuitive vectorized extension of prior scalar fractional order neural ODE models.
  2. Broad evaluation. It covers three chaotic systems plus two real or realistic 3D domains, against about 12 baselines spanning recurrent, Transformer, linear, ODE, trajectory-specific, and fractional models.
  3. The paper provides theoretical results to make the cost of memory truncation explicit.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The empirical advantage depends on one window size. The window-size study (Table 8) contradicts the text's claim that larger windows "slightly" degrade accuracy:

    • On Lorenz63, MSE rises roughly 5× from W=64 to W=72 (1.7e-5 → 8.3e-5).
    • On Thomas, W=72 is worse than W=32 in both MSE (5.8e-5 vs. 4.5e-5) and T_v (4439 vs. 4506).

    At any W≠64W \neq 64, the model loses much of its edge over baselines:

    • On Rössler, every other window has higher MSE than the plain NeuralODE (2.4e-5, Table 1).
    • On Thomas, every other window has higher MSE than ESN, FADE and NeuralODE.
    • On Lorenz63, W∈{32,56}W \in \{32, 56\} is roughly on par with LSTM.

    W does not appear in the Bayesian-optimization search space (Table 5,), yet Table 8 is presented as validating that search. It is also unclear whether W was selected on validation or test data. The study is limited to the chaotic systems: UAV (W=50) and UUV (W=8) have no sensitivity analysis. With W=8W=8, the "long-tail memory" motivation is hard to reconcile with the power-law argument of Prop. 1.

  2. The motivation conflates Markovianity with state choice. The paper argues that first-order ODEs "predict future states based solely on the present" and therefore cannot capture inertia (L33–35; restated on L64–65). Whether inertia is captured depends on what the state contains, not on Markovianity per se.

Questions for authors
  1. What was the window-size sensitivity for UAV and UUV, and how does W=8W=8 on UUV supports the long-memory motivation?

  2. Does the advantage over NeuralODE, ESN and FADE in Table 1 persist for any W≠64W \neq 64?

  3. In Table 7, the full UAV/UUV models already use λprior=0\lambda_{\text{prior}}=0 (and γ=0\gamma=0 for UAV). What do the "w/o Structural Prior" and "w/o Time-Weight" rows change for those datasets? Relatedly, the full UAV model enforces αx=αy=αz\alpha_x=\alpha_y=\alpha_z via SS (App. C.3.3). How then does it differ from Context-fNODE-scalar in Table 2 (1.52 vs. 1.58 ADE)?

  4. You frame the isotropic limitation as specific to 3D (L42). Isn't direction-dependent memory also present in 2D planar tracking, perhaps less severely? Wondering how the vectorized operator performs in 2D.

  5. Is it possible to model both physical inertia and external forces with latent context? Why the proposed method was not directly tested against methods such as ANODEs?

Reviewer_4SDiOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
3
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Context-FNODE, which is an extension of fractional neural ordinary differential equations (NODEs) that supports heterogeneous fractional derivative order across state channels, and also aims model unmodeled degrees of freedom by introducing an augmented state vector (or latent context) governed by a first order differential equation. The initial condition of this augmented state is inferred from a supplied history window using a separate neural network, in the style of [1]. Solutions of the Context-FNODE is updated using a first-order accurate discretization scheme that uses Euler steps for the augmented state and a simple discretized and truncated form (since history dependence extends infinitely backwards in time with exponentially decaying contribution) for the fractional ODE part. The model performance is compared against three chaotic systems, a UAV flight trajectories dataset, and 3D UUV trajectory dataset against various time series models and demonstrates strong trajectory prediction performance.

  • [1] C. Yildiz et al. ODE2VAE: Deep generative second order ODEs with Bayesian neural networks. NeurIPS (2019).
Critical strengths
  1. Using independent fractional orders per channel and augmented state to account for unobserved degrees of freedom are both reasonable additions to fractional NODEs. Demonstrating that this additions can result in improved model performance will inform design decisions of the researchers in the field.
Critical weaknesses

1. Weak novelty of the added components & Lack of validation as to what the model learns

The two key contributions of the paper are per-axis learnable fractional order and augmented ODE state. Merely proposing these additions lack significance - the fractional derivative can trivially be extended to support independent fractional orders even using the widely used Caputo definition (the authors' construction is also a vectorization over the channel axis), and augmenting the state vector of NODEs / RNNs is also a well-known trick in the literature (see [1], for example).

The authors claim that the per-axis fractional derivatives account for the anisotropic memory effects of the dynamics, and augmented state accounts for unobserved degrees of freedom. However, whether the new mechanisms actually learn these effects is unverified as the authors only measure model performance with respect to trajectory error. I think additional experiments with a known ground truth (simulated trajectories from some per-channel fractional order system; ODE system with partially observed states, etc) needs to be performed to properly assess the efficacy of the proposed additions.

I believe such confirmations are particularly important due to the following reasons:

  1. Fractional order and unobserved degrees of freedom can serve an overlapping role. This because even for Markovian systems with no memory effect, the presence of unobserved degrees of freedom present leads to memory effect in the observed degrees of freedom [2]. Therefore, it is nontrivial whether the fractional orders and augmented state will cleanly decouple the data memory effects into system intrinsic and unobserved degrees of freedom.

  2. Per-axis fractional orders may not be uniquely identifiable. Previous literature on fractional NODEs show that the fractional order is not determined uniquely from data [3, 4]. I would imagine per-axis freedom and the incorporation of latent state to exacerbate this issue, which may be the reason authors incorporate additional optimization machinery such as structural prior regularization or synchronized parameter update. Therefore, it is of interest whether the proposed model can recover ground truth fractional derivative orders from test systems.

  • [2] T. Monsel et al. Neural delay differential equations: learning non-Markovian closures for partially known dynamical systems. Data-Centric Engineering 7 (2026).
  • [3] C. Coelho et al. Neural fractional differential equations: optimizing the order of the fractional derivative. Fractal and Fractional 8, 9 (2024).
  • [4] C. Coelho et al. Methodologies for improved optimization of the derivative order and neural network parameters in neural FDE models. Fractal and Fractional 9, 7 (2025).

2. Inadequacy of chaotic dynamical systems as a benchmark

In their first sets of experiments, the authors test their model on long time trajectories from chaotic systems and report improved trajectory prediction errors. This does not seem to be an adequate benchmark as these systems are Markovian (no memory effect) and have no unobserved degrees of freedom. Indeed the authors also impose a structural prior of α=1\alpha=1 in their experiments reflecting this fact. Without diagnostics as to what has been learned by the model (learned fractional orders, temporal behavior of the latent state), it is unclear why the proposed model is adequate for these systems.

Furthermore, the sensitivity of the long term trajectories to state and parameter error is an intrinsic property of chaotic systems, not deficiencies of the training method or the model. In fact, ground truth equations with very small parameter errors incur O(1) error in finite time, making trajectory-based metrics a bad choice for these systems [5]. To validate whether their models accurately represent the underlying dynamical system, the authors should provide invariant-measure based diagnostics or Lyapunov exponents, as in the style of [6, 7].

Based on the above points, I think the paper needs substantial new experiments and diagnostics from its current form.

Questions for authors

Q1.

Related to the weaknesses section above, can the authors provide diagnostics on whether their model is able to identify ground truth fractional derivatives or unobserved degrees of freedom from data? What are the learned fractional derivative orders for each dataset, and how do the latent variables evolve in time?

Q2.

Regarding the ablation studies in Appendix D, can the authors provide an interpretation of model behavior based on the result? Ex. which components of their algorithms are more important than others; the nature of the dataset leading to differing contributions of the components (ex. for Markovian chaotic systems, fractional derivative order is not that important, etc.)

Q3.

The authors do not provide details for the baseline models. How were their hyperparameters selected and trained? What are the number of parameters and training wall times / memory usage like for each baseline model?

Reviewer_yxMoOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

Context-fNODE is proposed as a new model combining axis-specific Grünwald–Letnikov fractional dynamics for observed trajectories with a co-evolving first-order latent context initialized from the observation history. The implementation uses finite-window autoregressive updates and jointly learns the neural dynamics and fractional orders. The paper presents theoretical analyses of well-posedness, error growth, and numerical convergence, and evaluates forecasting on three chaotic systems and UAV/UUV trajectories.

Critical strengths

The model combines a low-dimensional parameterization of history weights with a dynamically evolving latent state. The reported forecasting improvements across chaotic systems and UAV/UUV trajectories provide empirical evidence that this combination can be useful.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The benefit of the continuous-time formulation is unclear. The implementation is a fixed-step, finite-history autoregressive update, and an advantage over an otherwise comparable discrete model is not demonstrated. The paper also does not establish whether the adjoint method, a central technique for memory-efficient Neural ODE training, is applicable to this mixed-order model.

  2. The novelty is limited. The combination of a GL-based history structure and a latent context does not sufficiently demonstrate a methodological or theoretical contribution beyond existing models that use history.

  3. The reasons for the gains on chaotic systems are insufficiently explained. The ablations establish that history, regularization, and temporal loss weighting work well together on Lorenz, but the mechanisms behind the gains remain insufficiently explained. For example, regularization toward one is effective, but the discussion and analysis do not adequately explain the large performance difference from fixing the orders at one. Comparisons with alternative history kernels are also missing, leaving unclear whether the gains arise from the specific GL coefficient structure or from using history more generally.

Questions for authors
  1. What concrete benefit does the continuous-time formulation provide beyond the implemented finite-history recurrence?

  2. Please explain the gradient computation method currently used and its training-memory complexity. If the applicability of an adjoint method has been investigated, please clarify the findings.

  3. Which theoretical results provide additional guarantees over fixed-step, finite-history autoregressive models or standard Neural ODEs? Please clarify which specific structural features of the proposed model yield these additional guarantees.

  4. Please explain the mechanisms behind the gains on chaotic systems. For example, report the learned orders and regularization strengths and discuss why regularization toward one is effective. Please also explain the performance difference from fixing the orders at one and the differences across systems.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.