- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3(+1)
- Soundness
- 3(+1)
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces scChrono, a neural stochastic differential equation (SDE) framework for learning continuous embryonic developmental dynamics from discrete single-cell transcriptomic snapshots. To address heterogeneous transcriptomic change rates across developmental stages, scChrono decomposes latent dynamics into Persistent Dynamics for sustained developmental progression and Fast-Transition Dynamics for temporally gated corrections, while incorporating stochastic diffusion to model cellular heterogeneity.
The authors evaluate scChrono on the mdCLA dataset across interpolation, long-horizon extrapolation, and temporal completion tasks, demonstrating improvements over representative OT, ODE, SDE, and diffusion-based baselines on most metrics. They further demonstrate the transferability of learned developmental representations through cell fate prediction on the LARRY dataset. The main contribution is a structured multi-rate dynamics framework designed to improve continuous whole-embryo transcriptomic forecasting, particularly over long developmental horizons.
Critical strengths
Well-motivated framework for whole-embryo long-horizon forecasting. The paper tried to addresse an important problem: transcriptomic change rates vary substantially across developmental stages, a biologically meaningful characteristic that should be considered when modeling embryonic development. The authors attempt to address this challenge through an explicit multi-rate dynamics architecture.
Comprehensive experimental evaluation. The authors evaluate the proposed method across multiple forecasting settings and metrics, with comparisons against representative baselines. They also provide component ablations, parameter-matched controls, and analyses of the gating mechanism and forecasting horizon, which help assess the contribution of the proposed architecture.
Critical weaknesses
1. Limited and task-dependent contribution of Fast-Transition Dynamics.
Fast-Transition Dynamics (FTD) is the main methodological novelty of scChrono, but its contribution varies substantially across evaluation settings. Removing FTD slightly improves all six metrics in Inter-Time Interpolation and has little effect on Fetal Completion, while its benefits are mainly observed in Strict Long-Horizon Extrapolation. More notably, removing FTD improves all six metrics in Pre-Fetal Completion (Appendix Table 11). These results suggest that the proposed component has a more limited scope of effectiveness than the paper's broader motivation implies. I suggest emphasizing strict long-horizon extrapolation as the primary contribution and clarifying the settings in which FTD is actually beneficial.
2. Insufficient evidence for the claimed separation of developmental dynamics into distinct temporal roles.
The paper motivates the decomposition into Persistent Dynamics (PD) and Fast-Transition Dynamics (FTD) by the heterogeneous rates of transcriptomic changes across developmental stages. However, the current experiments do not directly demonstrate that PD captures sustained developmental progression or that FTD captures rapid developmental transitions. Both components are jointly optimized under the same forecasting objective, and their intended roles are mainly encouraged through architectural constraints and regularization. In particular, FTD is modulated by a manually specified temporal prior, but the authors do not show whether its learned activation or contribution corresponds to periods of rapid transcriptomic change. The current ablations establish that the two-branch architecture can improve forecasting performance, but provide limited evidence for the claimed multi-rate interpretation.
3. Unclear motivation and evaluation role of the temporal completion tasks.
Fetal Completion and Pre-Fetal Completion are introduced as additional evaluation settings, but their relationship to the central objective of long-horizon forecasting is insufficiently explained. Since 20% of observations within the target developmental period remain visible, these settings differ substantially from forecasting entirely unseen future stages. The authors should better justify what capabilities these tasks are intended to evaluate and how they complement the primary forecasting experiments. If temporal completion is considered a major contribution, its main quantitative results should also be presented in the main text rather than only in the appendix.
4. Limited evidence that the proposed method accurately recovers biologically meaningful developmental changes.
Although scChrono achieves improvements in several reconstruction and distributional metrics, its performance on differential expression recovery remains limited under Strict Long-Horizon Extrapolation. In particular, the Differential Expression Score (DES) remains negative and is worse than that of PRESCIENT. This raises concerns about whether improvements in overall transcriptomic distribution matching translate into accurate predictions of developmentally relevant gene-expression changes. Additional biological analyses would help substantiate the broader claim of constructing a predictive transcriptomic virtual embryo.
Questions for authors
1. Can the authors show whether the learned Fast-Transition Dynamics actually correspond to the rapidly changing developmental periods identified in Figure 1A? For example, analyzing the temporal variation in FTD activation or contribution magnitude and comparing it with the empirical transcriptomic change rates.
2. How can the authors verify that Persistent Dynamics and Fast-Transition Dynamics capture distinct temporal roles? Since both components are jointly optimized under the same forecasting objective, it is unclear whether they genuinely learn sustained and rapid developmental changes, respectively. Could the authors provide additional analyses of the learned dynamics to support this decomposition?
3. Why does removing FTD improve performance across all six metrics in Pre-Fetal Completion (Appendix Table 11), while its contribution is substantial in Strict Long-Horizon Extrapolation? Could the authors clarify the conditions under which FTD is beneficial and explain this discrepancy?
5 comments
Response to Reviewer xwFt (2/3): W2, Q1 & Q2
Response to Reviewer xwFt (Part 2/3)
W2 & Q1 & Q2: Temporal roles of PD and FTD
We thank the reviewer for this important question. Four new analyses show that the two branches play distinct temporal and functional roles.
1. Temporal division: FTD dominates early, PD later (Q1, Q2). As requested, we plotted the gate, prior, and effective FTD against the change rates (Appendix Figure 6). The effective FTD contribution falls from about ten times PD at E7.5 to about 1% at E16.5, consistent with the high early and declining later change rates in Figure 1A:
| Stage | E7.5 | E8.0 | E12.0 | E15.0 | E16.5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Effective FTD/PD | 10.75 | 2.15 | 0.126 | 0.023 | 0.012 |
2. Predictive value: the gain is not explained by capacity (W2). From E7.5, E11, and E13 under Strict Extrapolation, Full beats −FTD and a parameter-matched single drift (221,334 vs. 221,569 parameters) on all six metrics at every source (full results in Appendix Table 13):
| Source | Full DES | −FTD DES | Matched DES | Full wins (vs. −FTD / matched) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| E7.5 | 0.601 ± 0.044 | 0.557 ± 0.013 | 0.534 ± 0.056 | 6/6 · 6/6 |
| E11 | 0.331 ± 0.021 | 0.185 ± 0.046 | 0.159 ± 0.074 | 6/6 · 6/6 |
| E13 | 0.138 ± 0.060 | −0.016 ± 0.024 | −0.031 ± 0.057 | 6/6 · 6/6 |
Removing the gate, the prior, or both also degrades Strict performance (five-seed means; SDs in Appendix Table 14):
| Variant | NMAE-PCA ↓ | Sink-PCA ↓ | NMAE-HVG ↓ | Sink-HVG ↓ | DES ↑ | CSS ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Full | 0.825 | 31.251 | 0.360 | 359.108 | −0.071 | 0.021 |
| Gate only | 0.913 | 34.464 | 0.445 | 378.015 | −0.156 | 0.028 |
| Prior only | 0.964 | 36.666 | 0.433 | 373.690 | −0.261 | 0.021 |
| No gate | 0.939 | 33.678 | 0.457 | 369.671 | −0.253 | 0.026 |
3. Biological relevance: FTD prioritizes known developmental drivers (W2, Q2). As gold driver sets require literature curation, we used 24 curated epithelial driver-TF annotations as a case study (Appendix Table 17), summarizing FTD attribution by maximum (largest absolute attribution in a window) and step-mean (mean absolute attribution to the gated step , Eq. 4; same rule as PD mean). Recall:
| Attribution | Top 5% | Top 10% | Top 20% | Top 30% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FTD (maximum) | 37.50% | 37.50% | 54.17% | 66.67% |
| FTD (step-mean) | 25.00% | 33.33% | 66.67% | 83.33% |
| PD (maximum) | 4.17% | 25.00% | 29.17% | 37.50% |
| PD (mean) | 12.50% | 25.00% | 41.67% | 50.00% |
FTD (maximum) also ranks 17 of 24 above PD (p = 0.027) and stays enriched against expression-matched genes (p = 0.016; PD p = 0.290), and 11/12 step-mean permutation tests survive BH-FDR (Appendix Table 19).
4. Relation to empirical change rates (Q1). At a coarse level, yes: effective FTD peaks early, when empirical change rates are also high. Within lineages, after detrending, the prior-free gate correlates positively with the change rates of all five lineages (Appendix Figure 7); the raw series gives ρ = −0.300:
| Gate vs. change rate | ρ | p |
|---|---|---|
| Linear detrending | 0.261 | 0.018 |
| Quadratic detrending | 0.271 | 0.014 |
| First differences | 0.119 | 0.291 |
Effective FTD magnitude itself is not significantly correlated with the change rate (p = 0.112), which is not contradictory: the Figure 1A rate is a snapshot-derived proxy that also reflects lineage composition, not a direct measure of transition speed. FTD provides gated corrections rather than reproducing that curve.
We therefore position PD/FTD as an empirically supported inductive bias and have revised the Abstract, Introduction, and Conclusion accordingly.
(Continued in Part 3/3.)
Response to Reviewer xwFt (3/3): W3 & W4
Response to Reviewer xwFt (Part 3/3)
W3: Motivation and role of Temporal Completion
We thank the reviewer for noting that the motivation of the two Completion tasks and their relation to forecasting were insufficiently explained. Temporal Completion complements long-horizon forecasting for incomplete developmental time series, while Strict Long-Horizon Extrapolation remains the main contribution.
The two tasks cover two different data gaps in developmental studies. Strict Long-Horizon Extrapolation addresses future stages with no collected data, using observed stages to forecast later transcriptomic states, a key setting for predicting cell states and trajectories [1–4]. Temporal Completion extends the model to stages that were sampled but incompletely observed: owing to limited cell numbers and cost, even a sampled stage rarely represents its full state distribution, so reconstructing unsampled cells helps complete developmental atlases. Prior work evaluates such generation by holding out 20% of cells [5], and we follow this protocol: 80% of target-period cells are visible and 20% are held out (clarified in the revision).
The two tasks lie at two ends of a continuum. As target visibility decreases, Completion increasingly resembles forecasting: raising the held-out fraction from 20% to 80% increases the FTD gain (Part 1/3).
We added this complementary role of the two tasks to Section 4.1 (Task Settings) and Appendix D.3, and Section 4.2.1 now summarizes the Completion results: scChrono achieves the best mean on all six metrics in both settings (Appendix Table 11).
W4: Recovery of developmentally relevant expression changes
We thank the reviewer for raising this point. Pooled DES under Strict Long-Horizon Extrapolation remains a limitation, but scChrono has the best DES in the other three tasks and outperforms PRESCIENT in all five major lineages.
Strict extrapolation: recovering differential expression remains a shared challenge. All evaluated methods have negative pooled DES, and scChrono ranks second:
| Method | PRESCIENT | scChrono | TrajectoryNet | scDiffEq | scNODE |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Strict DES ↑ | −0.008 | −0.071 | −0.097 | −0.136 | −0.179 |
We acknowledge this as a challenge shared by all methods and will improve long-range differential-expression forecasting in future versions of scChrono.
Other tasks: scChrono has the best DES in Inter-Time (0.258), Fetal (0.557), and Pre-Fetal (0.463), recovering expression changes when the target is better constrained.
Lineage level: scChrono outperforms PRESCIENT in DES in all five lineages. In a new lineage-specific analysis under Strict Extrapolation (full results in Appendix D.2, Table 9):
| Lineage | scChrono | PRESCIENT |
|---|---|---|
| Endothelial | 0.016 | −0.066 |
| Epithelial | −0.004 | −0.144 |
| Hematopoietic | 0.023 | −0.179 |
| Mesenchymal | −0.043 | −0.134 |
| Neural | −0.014 | −0.142 |
scChrono leads all applicable methods in DES in four lineages and has the best NMAE, Sinkhorn, and CSS in all five lineages (25/25). Pooled DES ranks genes by population-mean changes, which combine within-lineage expression changes with shifts in lineage composition. A method can therefore lead within every lineage yet trail on pooled DES (a Simpson-type effect). Section 4.2.1 now discusses these results; for gene-level evidence, see the driver-TF analysis in Part 2/3.
References
[1] Chen, Z., King, W. C., Hwang, A., Gerstein, M., & Zhang, J. (2022). DeepVelo: Single-cell transcriptomic deep velocity field learning with neural ordinary differential equations. Science Advances, 8(48), eabq3745.
[2] Zhang, J., Larschan, E., Bigness, J., & Singh, R. (2024). scNODE: Generative model for temporal single cell transcriptomic data prediction. Bioinformatics, 40(Supplement_2), ii146–ii154.
[3] Erbe, R., Stein-O'Brien, G., & Fertig, E. J. (2023). Transcriptomic forecasting with neural ordinary differential equations. Patterns, 4(8), 100793.
[4] Yeo, G. H. T., Saksena, S. D., & Gifford, D. K. (2021). Generative modeling of single-cell time series with PRESCIENT enables prediction of cell trajectories with interventions. Nature Communications, 12(1), 3222.
[5] Turgut Ögme, S. S., Aydin, N., & Kurt, Z. (2025). A mixture of attention experts-embedded flow-based generative model to create synthetic cells in single-cell RNA-Seq datasets. PLOS Computational Biology, 21(10), e1013525.
Response to Reviewer xwFt (1/3): W1 & Q3
Response to Reviewer xwFt (Part 1/3)
W1 & Q3: Task-dependent contribution of FTD
We thank the reviewer for the careful observation and constructive suggestions. FTD is effective overall and most suitable when target visibility is low and the forecast horizon is long, which is the Strict Long-Horizon Extrapolation setting. We adopt the reviewer's suggestion to present this setting as FTD's main empirical contribution, and the manuscript has been updated accordingly (Abstract, Introduction, and Section 4.2.2).
1. Inter-Time, Fetal, and Pre-Fetal: after a minor fix, Full outperforms −FTD in two tasks and is comparable in the other two. In Pre-Fetal, backward rollout used the unsigned step ∣Δt∣ for FTD but the signed Δt for PD (Appendix B.2). After the fix, Full's DES rises from 0.269 to 0.463, and "removing FTD improves all six metrics" no longer holds:
Full versus retrained −FTD across the four tasks (five seeds; full results: Table 1, Appendix Table 22):
FTD improves Strict and Fetal and is comparable in Inter-Time and Pre-Fetal, and with FTD, scChrono outperforms all baselines on 23 of 24 task–metric comparisons, so FTD is effective overall.
2. Conditions under which FTD helps most (Q3): weaker target constraints and longer horizons.
(1) Target visibility: the less target information, the more FTD helps. We held out 20%, 50%, or 80% of target-stage cells in Fetal and Pre-Fetal Completion (single seed; full results in Appendix Table 23):
With many visible cells, PD alone performs comparably. With few, the model relies more on FTD's gated corrections.
(2) Forecast horizon: the farther the forecast, the larger the FTD gain. In Strict Extrapolation, the NMAE-HVG gap grows from about 0.01 at Δt = 0.5 to 0.21 at Δt = 5.0 (Section 4.2.2, Figure 4). Spearman correlation between horizon and the degradation after retraining without FTD (full results in Appendix Table 20):
Errors of a single drift accumulate along the rollout, which is consistent with FTD's larger gains at longer horizons.
(3) Bidirectional constraints: with observed stages on both sides, FTD has little room to help. Although Inter-Time fully withholds the target stage, observed stages before and after it constrain the prediction, so a single drift interpolates well.
Strict Long-Horizon Extrapolation combines all three conditions, which is why FTD is most useful there. Section 3.3.2 now unifies the signed-step update.
(Continued in Part 2/3.)