- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes CADENCE, a framework for learning individual continuous-time dynamics from sparse cross-sectional observations, where each individual is observed only once. The method first uses a score-based encoder to map observations into a Gaussian latent space, and then employs a context-conditioned mixture-of-experts to parameterize individual neural ODE dynamics. Training is performed by matching subgroup-level marginal distributions across time without longitudinally paired observations. The authors also provide an identifiability analysis under structural assumptions and evaluate the method on six synthetic or semi-synthetic benchmarks and a real-world single-cell lineage-tracing dataset, reporting improvements over several existing methods.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
-
Line 93. Can the proposed encoder establish a continuous bijection between spaces of different dimensions? What mathematical theory justifies such a construction? I also noticed that in some experimental settings in the appendix, the authors use . If the encoder does not reduce the dimensionality, what exactly is the motivation for introducing it?
-
Lines 161–163. The authors begin discussing what appear to be empirical findings before even reaching the experimental section. This is a rather unusual choice of presentation and feels out of place at this point in the paper.
-
The overall writing is highly disorganized and difficult to follow. The manuscript is overloaded with abbreviations and extensive cross-references to distant sections and appendices. For example, to understand Assumption 2 in Section 3, I had to consult Section 5, Appendix B.3, and Theorem 1 just to piece together what the assumption actually means. Similar cross-references are scattered throughout the entire manuscript. The authors seem to have distributed closely related material across different parts of the paper without a clear organizational logic, making the manuscript extremely difficult to read. I found it nearly impossible to develop a coherent understanding of the work by reading it sequentially. In my opinion, the paper requires a substantial and careful restructuring and rewriting before it can become a useful and accessible research contribution to the community.
-
The mathematical presentation appears unnecessarily and deliberately complicated. This is particularly evident in Section 3. Could the authors explain, in plain language, what this section is actually trying to establish? I have received formal training in mathematics, yet I still find the presentation highly confusing. The extensive formalism and terminology seem to obscure the underlying ideas rather than clarify them.
-
The logical flow of the manuscript is also problematic. One concrete example is Lines 359–366, where the authors introduce a paragraph entitled "Where the advantage comes from." The subsequent discussion lists several experimental results, but seems to lack the essential explanatory statements that would actually clarify where the claimed advantage originates and why these results support that conclusion. This is representative of a broader problem throughout the manuscript: numerical observations and technical statements are presented without sufficient logical connections or interpretation, leaving the reader to infer the intended conclusions.
-
Line 222. The statement "Assume DFA, COA′, BAS, POS, ENR, PRW and FOA, plus SEP under COA′(b)" is a particularly striking example of the poor presentation. This style of writing is extremely difficult to follow. Requiring readers to repeatedly look up a long list of abbreviated assumptions, some of which have multiple variants and are defined in different parts of the paper, creates an unnecessary burden and seriously undermines readability.
-
The presentation of experimental results in Section 8 is particularly unsatisfactory. In my view, this section consists largely of an overwhelming enumeration of numerical results, with little prioritization of the important findings and insufficient intuitive explanations or meaningful insights. Rather than guiding the reader toward an understanding of what has been learned from the experiments, the authors simply present one numerical comparison after another. As a result, the section reads more like an automatically generated compilation of experimental results than a carefully structured scientific analysis. From a reader's perspective, it is very difficult to extract useful scientific insights from such a presentation. I believe the manuscript requires a serious and comprehensive reorganization and rewriting, rather than merely minor language polishing.
Questions for authors
I have no specific question for authors. My major concerns are the clarity and readability of theis paper. See weakness.
No rebuttal has been received, therefore, I maintain my initial assesement.