- Rating
- 4
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies parametric surrogates for systems with Hopf bifurcations. The authors argue that weak growth or decay near the boundary is poorly resolved by derivative-based identification, and that jointly training a neural vector field lets nonlinear learning move the equilibrium Jacobian and hence the stability boundaries. The authors propose two-stage model. In Stage 1, a matrix polynomial is fitted jointly across training conditions to early pre-saturation trajectories by a normalised multi-step trajectory loss, with a stability hinge on stable records, and is then frozen. In Stage 2, a neural coefficient matrix is trained on free rollouts. The method is evaluated on a Rijke tube, a cylinder wake and a flexible wing. The reported results show that it is the only model recovering the correct crossing count on all three systems, with crossing errors of at most 1.26% and the lowest neural test nRMSE.
Critical strengths
-
Well-motivated two-stage design. The key property holds by construction and is isolated by targeted ablations.
- The motivation is stated quantitatively: the sensitivity ratio scales as for trajectory versus derivative fitting.
- Gating, freezing and staged training are each shown to matter. Removing or releasing them shifts the crossings (Fig. 24, Table 17), and the objective and window comparisons support trajectory fitting (Table 5, Fig. 21, Table 13).
- This identifies a real failure mode, nonlinear training silently moving stability boundaries, and offers a simple remedy with an explicit, inspectable spectrum at unseen parameters (Fig. 22).
-
Thorough evaluation.
- Crossing counts are reported next to locations, so that spurious crossings are not hidden behind small location errors.
- Constant-predictor reference levels (App. F.2), regime-split errors (Table 9), boundedness, first-stage robustness (App. G.1), stable-only extrapolation (F.8) and a cropped-record comparison (F.7) are all included.
- The authors also qualify their own reference quantities (App. B.5). This breadth makes the paper informative well beyond the headline numbers.
Critical weaknesses
- Spectrally narrow test bed, and missing examinations on numerical effects.
- All three systems are single-pair Hopf crossings with clean oscillations. Tests on real-eigenvalue crossing, mode coalescence or multi-frequency interaction would make the manuscript even better.
- Stage 1 uses the exact matrix exponential, while the deployed model is integrated with RK4 at the record step. On the wake this is only about 14--19 steps per period. Expanding on numerical artifacts and/or further clarifying the choice on the wake reference (which seems discretization-specific; vs 46--47, following line 941) would be nicer.
Questions for authors
- Stage 1 seems noise-sensitive: enters when given per-record normalisation up-weights low-SNR records, and the equilibrium is assumed exact. Perhaps, would fitting jointly be helpful?
- How sensitive are crossings and nRMSE to the RK4 step per period, especially on the wake? Would an exponential integrator that treats the frozen exactly change the results? Are the reported crossings roots of the explicit or linear interpolation on the grid?
- Why was degree 1 not selected on the wake, given that App. F.5 (line 2425) says it's competitive (lower error on 4/5 seeds)?
- Section 4.1 mentions “two cells slightly favouring ablations” in Table 9, but I cannot find which cells it means. I find only the ungated model on the wing (inside the unstable interval) as an ablation favoured. In addition, the plain and jointly trained free-operator rows are slightly lower on the tube (inside, Table 10), but those are not ablations.
- In App. A.3: "Records are stored every 0.4 convective times, while the model step is ." why does it have to be like this?
Minor comments.
- Appendix F. 8 says the error “grows with the distance”, but the wing rows decrease ().
- Typos: “52.21and82.55” (line 962), Table 8 caption “held out the same statistic...” is ungrammatical (maybe missed "is" after "held out".)
- Missing explanation and citation for “SINDy-CP” (App. B.4 line 1079).
2 comments
Response to Reviewer C3tE - Part 2/2
Q2. Integration and crossing computation
Crossings are independent of the rollout integrator. They are sign changes of the largest real part of the eigenvalues of , located by linear interpolation on a dense parameter scan separate from the record grid (Appendix C). Refining the roots by bisection shifts each by about 0.001 percent of its normaliser or less, changing no reported digit.
Without retraining, we re-rolled the reported models with finer RK4 steps and an exponential scheme treating exactly. Values are means over five seeds. Wing values cover the 14 angles inside the unstable interval in Appendix C, pooling training, development and test conditions as in Table 9.
| Scheme | Tube test nRMSE | Wake test nRMSE | Wing nRMSE |
|---|---|---|---|
| RK4, record step (reported) | 0.108 | 0.169 | 0.524 |
| RK4, 2 sub-steps | 0.108 | 0.175 | 0.522 |
| RK4, 4 sub-steps | 0.108 | 0.176 | 0.522 |
| Exponential, exact | 0.108 | 0.172 | 0.522 |
The wake has 14–19 steps per limit-cycle period, as you noted, versus 71–90 on the tube and about 34 on the wing. The largest aggregate error change is 0.007 on the wake, about a tenth of the gap to the next architecture in Table 3. The exponential scheme changes aggregate error by approximately 0.003 or less. Finer RK4 steps do not improve the wake’s aggregate error for these fixed models, trained through the original RK4 map (Appendix B.3). The largest condition-level differences occur just above the wake crossing, where slow growth makes saturation time sensitive to small growth-rate changes (Appendix E.2). At individual test conditions, nRMSE against the reference changes by up to 0.25 in either direction. The wing test median in Table 3 is unchanged under every scheme, and all rollouts remain bounded.
As Appendix A.3 states, is the critical value of this discretisation, not the continuum. It is the appropriate reference because the surrogate learns from that simulator’s records. We did not perform a resolution study and will state this in the revision.
Q3. Degree 1 on the wake
We selected the degree using the operator’s development trajectory error. The continuation started at degree 2 and proceeded to higher degrees. Degree 4 gave the lowest error (Appendix B.1). Degree 1 was below that starting point and was fitted afterwards as a check (Appendix F.5). Including it would not change the choice, as its first-stage development error is 0.145 versus 0.122 for degree 4.
After stage two, degree 1 offers similar accuracy with 128 operator coefficients versus 320. We retain the reported model to avoid selection after seeing test results and will clarify these points in the revision.
Q4. Section 4.1 and Table 9
The sentence in Section 4.1 will be corrected to match the tables. The only Table 9 cell favouring an ablation is the ungated wing model inside the unstable interval, at 0.52 versus 0.54. In Table 10, the plain and jointly trained free-operator models are marginally better on tube test conditions inside the interval, at 0.12 versus 0.13, but these are architectures, not ablations.
Our claim of lowest test error among neural architectures refers to the median over all test conditions (Table 3). On the tube, the advantage comes from the stable regime, where those two models score 0.69 and 0.41 versus 0.10. We will correct Section 4.1.
Q5. Wake sampling interval and model step
There is no mismatch. The model step equals the stored interval, while 0.4 is nominal. Snapshots are stored on whole lattice steps. With 20 nodes per diameter and inlet speed 0.07 in lattice units, one convective time is 285.7 lattice steps. Thus 0.4 convective times would require 114.29 steps. Storing every 114 gives 0.399. Appendix A.3 will state the actual interval, 0.399 convective times.
Minor comments
- Appendix F.8. The wing rows show error decreasing from 2.72 to 0.61 percent as distance increases from 2.78 to 8.33 percent (Table 16). Both errors lie within the 2.78% reference resolution, which limits conclusions about accuracy but does not change their order. The statement that error grows with distance holds only for the tube and wake. We will correct it.
- Both typos will be corrected.
- Appendix B.4 will define SINDy-CP as Nicolaou et al.’s (2023) sparse-regression formulation with control parameters, using products of state and parameter monomials, and add the citation.
Response to Reviewer C3tE - Part 1/2
Thank you for the careful reading and constructive questions. The submission is scoped to Hopf bifurcations, as stated in Section 5. In all three applications, each stability transition involves a single complex-conjugate eigenvalue pair. We will clarify in that section that real-eigenvalue crossings, a second unstable pair and quasi-periodic motion were outside the experimental scope and were not tested. Your questions required new fits, training runs and rollouts, which we conducted and report below.
Q1. Noise sensitivity and fitting the initial state
Identification from noisy measurements is outside the stated scope of the submitted paper. Section 5 explicitly restricts the experiments to noise-free simulations with a supplied equilibrium and states that noise robustness remains untested. We added this study in response to your question to examine this additional setting.
We added Gaussian noise with standard deviation 1% of each coordinate’s standard deviation to the wake records and refitted stage one on five independent draws. We score against the clean reference. Crossing error is the distance from the reference to the nearest predicted crossing, in percent of the critical Reynolds number. Every draw has at least one crossing, so all five enter each statistic.
The last two columns count draws with exactly one crossing and with correct signs at every condition, respectively.
On clean records, the first two configurations give 0.15 percent (the Table 5 control fit) and 0.09 percent, each with one crossing.
Under this additional noisy-data test, the reported recipe produces incorrect crossing counts in two of the five draws. One of these has no crossing near the reference, with the nearest at Re=56.7. Jointly fitting initial states and the operator, as you suggested, returns a single crossing in all five draws and lowers the median error. One draw places the crossing 9 percent above the reference. On clean records, fitting the initial states improves the crossing estimate. Subcritical rollout error increases from 0.12 to 0.26 when rollouts are initialised at the measured initial states. Degree 2 has the most consistent locations, all within 0.21 percent, although two draws have spurious crossings.
An exploratory single-draw test with equal absolute noise across records, giving small records low signal-to-noise ratios, yields one crossing and errors at most 0.14 percent for all three configurations. Stability labels and the supplied equilibrium were fixed, isolating noise in the trajectory term. Equilibrium uncertainty remains untested. We will report these results, include fitted initial states as an option in stage one, and document the observed sensitivity to noise in Section 5.