- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a data assimilation method that regards the observation as a diffusion state in the forward process. By doing so, it can simply reverse the diffusion from that observation without using DPS style gradient or guidance. The experiments in turbulence and surface quasi-geostrophic reconstruction task show it outperform other baseline including EnKF, IR Diffusion, FNO and other baselines.
Critical strengths
The method proposed in this paper provides a conditioned diffusion method that can using observation directly in data assimilation or super resolution task in inference level rather than previous work such as Score-based Data Assimilation. Which could be a new way for diffusion based data assimilation task.
Critical weaknesses
Firstly, some parts in this paper are not well organized. In particular, Figure 1, which is the main figure of this paper, have many issues. This figure contains patches with different font styles and different resolutions. Some parts are blurry and visually inconsistent, which makes the figure look like it was not carefully prepared. The writing has similar presentation issues and make the paper difficult to follow.
Secondly, there have already been several works on conditioned diffusion for PDE solving and data assimilation, for example, On Conditional Diffusion Models for PDE Simulations [1]. Therefore, the actual novelty of this work should be discussed more clearly in relation to these existing approaches.
Lastly, the baselines and experimental evaluations are relatively simple and limited the author should using more recent data assimilation methods such as SDA [2] to compare with it own method. And test it on more experiment with different physical domain to avoid conclusions that may be specific to the selected test cases
[1] Shysheya, Aliaksandra, et al. "On conditional diffusion models for PDE simulations." Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems 37 (2024): 23246-23300.
[2] Rozet, François, and Gilles Louppe. "Score-based data assimilation." Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems 36 (2023): 40521-40541.
Questions for authors
Could the authors clarify how Figure 1 was prepared?
Could the authors explain why recent score-based data assimilation methods, such as SDA, are not included as baselines?
Could the authors compare the proposed method with other conditional diffusion methods for data assimilation?