- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper develops non-asymptotic guarantees for SMC-based conditional sampling with pretrained diffusion models. The analysis separates the final error into a finite-particle term and approximation errors due to initialization, score estimation, numerical discretization, and approximate guidance potentials. These local errors are propagated through forward-smoothing kernels using a Harris-type forgetting argument on a noncompact state space. The framework is illustrated on Gaussian-mixture conditional sampling problems and connected to several existing diffusion-SMC methods.
Critical strengths
The main results provide a unified error decomposition, which separates finite-particle error from approximation errors due to the score matching error, discretization error, initialization error, and imperfect guidance potentials.
Critical weaknesses
First, the reviewer finds that the main bound presented in the paper turns out to be a bit difficult to be interpreted quantitatively. Although the result is non-asymptotic, the forgetting factors depend on Harris minorization constants that can become very small in high dimension, while the prefactor can correspondingly become large. The paper does not quantify the resulting dependence on dimension, number of SMC steps, or guidance strength, even in the simple case of Gaussian mixtures. Relatedly, Assumptions D.1--D.2 impose moment and normalization conditions directly on the particle system. The results can be further strengthened to clarify when these follow from more primitive conditions on the terms like inaccurate potentials.
Furthermore, to the best of the reviewer's knowledge, SMC-guided diffusion sampling with pretrained score functions have been studied extensively in a lot of previous work under the "inference-time scaling" framework, such as [1-6], but the current version of the manuscript's literature review section is missing almost all of them. Moreover, a few recent work like [7-9] have also devoted to study the theoretical aspects of SMC-based inference-time scaling under the setting of both diffusion models and large language models (LLMs). The authors are strongly encouraged to revise the manuscript by including a comprehensive discussion on these related work to clarify the main novelty and contribution of this paper.
Questions for authors
-
Would it be possible for the authors to provide a quantitative characterization of or the underlying contraction constants as a function of dimension and guidance strength in the Gaussian-mixture setting? This would help determine whether the forgetting bound is informative beyond establishing finiteness.
-
Can Assumption D.2 be possibly verified from Assumptions 3.1, 3.3, and 3.5 for a common class of potentials, such as Gaussian likelihoods? If not, please make it clear in the article that the particle bound is conditional on such additional non-degeneracy assumption.
-
How does Theorem 3.6 compare with the theoretical guarantee in existing work like [6,7,8]? The authors are strongly encouraged to cite these related work and discuss the main differences to further enhance quality of the current manuscript.
References:
[1] Skreta, M., Akhound-Sadegh, T., Ohanesian, V., Bondesan, R., Aspuru-Guzik, A., Doucet, A., ... & Neklyudov, K. (2025). Feynman-kac correctors in diffusion: Annealing, guidance, and product of experts. arXiv preprint arXiv:2503.02819.
[2] Uehara, M., Zhao, Y., Wang, C., Li, X., Regev, A., Levine, S., & Biancalani, T. (2025). Inference-time alignment in diffusion models with reward-guided generation: Tutorial and review. arXiv preprint arXiv:2501.09685.
[3] He, J., Hernández-Lobato, J. M., Du, Y., & Vargas, F. (2025). Rne: a plug-and-play framework for diffusion density estimation and inference-time control. arXiv e-prints, arXiv-2506.
[4] Wang, C., Wang, W., Ren, Y., Blanchet, J., & Lu, Y. (2026, May). Simple Approximation and Derivative Free Inference-Time Scaling for Diffusion Models via Sequential Monte Carlo on Path Measures. In Forty-third International Conference on Machine Learning.
[5] Ren, Y., Gao, W., Ying, L., Rotskoff, G., & Han, J. (2026, April). Driftlite: Lightweight drift control for inference-time scaling of diffusion models. In International Conference on Learning Representations (Vol. 2026, pp. 76664-76702).
[6] Chen, H., Ren, Y., Min, M. R., Ying, L., & Izzo, Z. (2025). Solving inverse problems via diffusion-based priors: An approximation-free ensemble sampling approach. arXiv preprint arXiv:2506.03979.
[7] Howard, S., & Nüsken, N. (2026). A Mean-Field Framework for Inference-Time Distributional Control of Diffusion Models. arXiv preprint arXiv:2608.08770.
[8] Delgadino, M. G., Motsch, S., Parulekar, A., Porteous, W., & Shakkottai, S. (2026). Diffusion-Based Posterior Sampling: A Feynman-Kac Analysis of Bias and Stability. arXiv preprint arXiv:2605.06538.
[9] Zhu, Y., & Lu, Y. On the Power of (Approximate) Reward Models for Inference-Time Scaling: Sequential Monte Carlo and Beyond. In Forty-third International Conference on Machine Learning.
3 comments
On the various references
Regarding the theoretical contributions of references [6-9], we believe that their guarantees are different. Despite some overlap, the settings, distances considered, proof techniques, errors tackled are genuinely different. To our knowledge, none of the cited works propagates both particle fluctuations and model approximation errors through the same unified perturbation analysis on noncompact state spaces and with potentials that are not bounded away from zero. None of the cited works provides a joint non-asymptotic terminal sampling error bound explicitly accounting for the time discretization of the underlying backward SDE. Moreover, our approximation criteria reflect the conditioning problem: score error is evaluated along exact reverse trajectories initialized from ideal selected distributions and potential mismatch is measured under the ideal filtering distribution. Thus, small average score error under unconditional diffusion marginals need not guarantee comparable accuracy in regions emphasized by conditioning. We detail the differences below.
[6] Chen et al. establish approximation guarantees and particle consistency for their specific AFDPS construction based on PDE evolution, whereas our framework provides a joint non-asymptotic error analysis for general Feynman–Kac selection–mutation schemes, without prescribing a particular guidance mechanism. They establish separate approximation bounds (Theorem 4.1) and particle consistency (Theorem 4.2) for their continuous-time algorithm. These guarantees cannot be directly combined into a joint non-asymptotic terminal error bound as Theorem 4.1 and Theorem 4.2 do not use the same metrics. Moreover, the particle result provides no explicit convergence rate in the particle count. Compared to our approach they do not have a common unifying forward-smoothing stability mechanism governing both particle and approximation errors. Moreover, their theoretical guarantees do not account for numerical discretization or resampling errors. Regarding potentially large controls we highlight that their constant can be exponentially large (see def equation C.41). Similarly, they define . For a standard Gaussian prior and likelihood proportional to , this coefficient equals . Thus, their posterior approximation bound is not uniformly dimension-free either.
[7] Howard and Nüsken. Their contribution is distribution-level reward steering: the reward depends on the evolving measure, and weighted McKean–Vlasov dynamics track an implicitly defined tilted distribution. Theorem 3.4 establishes particle consistency for bounded smooth observables. Our setting instead uses prescribed state potentials and gives a non-asymptotic bound separating finite-particle fluctuations from initialization, score, discretization and potential errors. We do not claim to subsume their measure-dependent reward framework.
[8] Delgadino et al. This work specifically analyzes the DPS construction rather than a finite-particle SMC approximation. Its Theorem 1 gives a Feynman–Kac formula relating the DPS output density to the target posterior, characterizing bias that can persist even with an exact prior score. It also studies numerical instability of DPS updates and bias from early guidance stopping. Our result addresses a different question: how finite-particle fluctuations and model approximation errors propagate through SMC selection–mutation steps. Our stability estimates concern forgetting through forward-smoothing kernels, rather than numerical stability of DPS updates.
[9] Zhu and Lu study sampling from a reward-tilted pretrained model. Under uniform reward-ratio and multiplicative Bellman-error bounds, they quantify the particle and computational complexity needed to attain a prescribed total-variation accuracy. Importantly, their intermediate twists telescope to the specified terminal reward, so imperfect intermediate guidance need not introduce a persistent target bias.
Our analysis additionally distinguishes the implemented diffusion model from the ideal reverse diffusion associated with the data distribution. We therefore control both particle fluctuations around the implemented flow and its discrepancy from the desired target, including initialization, learned-score, numerical-discretization and potential errors. These latter errors can persist as the particle count increases.
Their SMC complexity theorem controls the total-variation distance of the averaged output law , whereas we bound the error of random empirical estimates, allowing unbounded observables controlled by a Lyapunov function. This provides a complementary perspective to their explicit complexity analysis under Bellman-error assumptions; we do not claim that our assumptions subsume theirs or that our theorem supplies comparable horizon-complexity guarantees.
Response
The reviewer would like to thank the authors for the detailed response and clarifications. The reviewer would double check the responses and let the authors know in case there is any further question. If there will be an updated version of the manuscript, the reviewer would make sure to read it as well and revise the review accordingly if needed.
Main response
We thank the reviewer for these questions and the references.
Q1. We agree that Harris bounds can be conservative in high dimension. However, dimension and guidance strength alone do not determine the constants: score dissipativity, choice of the Lyapunov function and observation structure also matter. That said, Lyapunov drift and local minorization are classical tools for establishing stability of Feynman–Kac semigroups on noncompact state spaces (Whiteley, 2012; Douc et al., 2014). Our approach builds on this theory, adapting the quantitative Harris argument of Hairer and Mattingly (2008) to guided forward-smoothing kernels.
The dependence on these parameters is partly explicit in our results. Proposition 3.2 shows how stronger dissipativity improves the proposal drift coefficient. Equation (43) expresses the guided contraction factors in terms of drift and minorization constants. In particular, smaller contraction factors lead to stronger attenuation of earlier errors, whereas the prefactor bN−1 arises from converting the terminal weighted norm into the V-weighted norm. Guidance also affects these coefficients through the continuation weights.
We will clarify that the dimension enters the constants through Lyapunov moments, score regularity and minorization coefficients, and consider adding a Gaussian or Gaussian-mixture example to make these dependencies more concrete. We acknowledge that our results do not establish dimension-efficient guarantees in general. Obtaining sharper dimension-dependent estimates remains an important direction for future research, particularly for Harris-type analyses on noncompact state spaces. Finally, to our knowledge, references [6–9] do not provide polynomial-in-dimension guarantees jointly controlling particle fluctuations and initialization, score, discretization and guidance-potential errors in diffusion-SMC. We discuss their distinct targets and error criteria in our separate comment.
Q2. We agree that D.2 does not follow from Assumptions 3.1, 3.3 and 3.5 alone. D.1 and D.2 are explicitly stated among the hypotheses of Theorem 3.6. Their detailed formulations were placed in Appendix D for space reasons. The finite-particle bound is explicitly conditional on these additional integrability requirements.
We have, nevertheless, provided concrete sufficient conditions in our responses to reviewer prsc. First, Assumption 3.1, a uniform positive lower bound on the implemented potentials suffices at a fixed horizon (see our main response). More generally, a uniform positive lower bound is not necessary: D.1–D.2 can also be verified for potentials satisfying a Gaussian lower envelope under compatible exponential-moment conditions (see our comment “Technical details for D.1–D.2 under a Gaussian lower envelope”). This includes certain untruncated Gaussian likelihoods. The Gaussian-envelope criterion makes explicit a trade-off between guidance concentration, proposal contraction, the moment order p, and the Gaussian initialization variance.
We will make the role of these assumptions more prominent in the main text and incorporate the sufficient conditions and their proof into the revised manuscript.
Q3 We thank the reviewer for highlighting this recent and relevant literature, which will undoubtedly strengthen the contextualization of our work. While we acknowledge that these references deserve a more thorough discussion, we believe that our theoretical contributions are complementary and address questions not covered by these works. We therefore view this as an opportunity to improve the literature review rather than a limitation of the theoretical contribution itself.
Recent inference-time scaling methods exploit additional computational resources at generation time to improve the quality of samples produced by pretrained generative models. We acknowledge the relevance of these contributions and we will discuss them in the revised manuscript. Our objective is complementary. Rather than proposing a new inference-time scaling strategy, we investigate the mathematical guarantees of SMC-guided diffusion sampling, establishing how accurately the resulting particle system approximates the conditional distribution.
This distinction is important because, even with an infinite number of particles, the implemented algorithm may fail to recover the desired conditional distribution due to initialization, score approximation, numerical discretization or guidance-potential errors. Conversely, even when these components are individually accurate, a finite number of interacting particles introduces an additional Monte Carlo approximation error.
We provide a detailed comparison with references [6–9] in a separate comment, highlighting the differences in theoretical guarantees, error criteria, assumptions and proof techniques. We will incorporate this discussion into the revised manuscript.