- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes ForcingDAS, a unified data assimilation framework built on Diffusion Forcing. By introducing observation guidance and different denoising schedules, the method supports filtering, fixed-lag smoothing, and full-sequence smoothing using a single trained model. The authors also propose causality-aware training (CAT) and noise-level-aware observation guidance to improve performance. Experiments on Navier–Stokes, SEVIR, and ERA5 show competitive results against existing DA methods.
Critical strengths
The motivation of unifying filtering and smoothing within a single model is meaningful. Adapting Diffusion Forcing to DA is a natural and promising direction, and the proposed framework makes sense. The experiments across three datasets also demonstrate its potential for different DA tasks.
Critical weaknesses
CAT biases training toward temporally ordered noise levels, which seems more suitable for autoregressive filtering and pyramid schedules. However, full-sequence smoothing uses synchronous denoising, and it is unclear whether CAT is equally beneficial in this setting. This raises a concern about how well CAT supports the paper's central claim of a unified DA framework. Moreover, the CAT ablation only evaluates three-step autoregressive forecasting without observation guidance, rather than the actual DA tasks. Even in these forecasting experiments, CAT does not consistently improve performance: the gains are substantial on ERA5, relatively small on SEVIR, and almost absent on Navier–Stokes.
Noise-level-aware observation guidance is another key component of ForcingDAS. However, the paper does not provide a direct ablation comparing it with standard constant-weight guidance. Therefore, it is unclear how much this design contributes to the final DA performance.
Questions for authors
-
How does CAT benefit different DA regimes? Since full-sequence smoothing uses synchronous denoising rather than a staggered schedule, why should sorted-noise training also benefit this regime?
-
Could the authors provide CAT ablations on the actual DA tasks? Comparisons with and without CAT across filtering, fixed-lag smoothing, and full-sequence smoothing would help clarify its contribution. It would also be useful to explain why CAT improves ERA5 substantially but has little effect on Navier–Stokes.
-
How much does noise-level-aware observation guidance contribute? Could the authors compare it with standard constant-weight guidance under the same model and inference schedules?
My current rating is 2 (Weak Reject), although I lean toward 2.5. I find the overall framework promising, and the experimental results are encouraging. However, the contributions of CAT and noise-level-aware observation guidance are not sufficiently supported by the current ablations. If the authors can convincingly address these concerns, I would consider raising my rating.