- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes DAWIS, a generative data assimilation framework that partially inverts and regenerates windows of states using multitask stochastic interpolants. Per-state flow times enable filtering, fixed-lag smoothing, and block smoothing with a shared prior, while DAWIS-Joint eliminates the external forecast model. Experiments on SQG and SEVIR show promising improvements over existing filtering and smoothing methods.
Critical strengths
The windowed inversion mechanism addresses error accumulation by allowing new observations to revise previous state estimates. Filtering and fixed-lag smoothing are obtained from the same assimilation cycle.
The framework provides a useful unification of existing generative DA approaches, including forecast-free assimilation and block smoothing.
The experiments cover challenging nonlinear and multimodal observation settings, with comprehensive evaluations of accuracy, calibration, and spectral fidelity. The SQG improvements are particularly convincing.
Critical weaknesses
Unclear posterior correctness. The filtering and fixed-lag smoothing procedures lack theoretical consistency guarantees. Previously assimilated states are partially inverted and guided again on observations already incorporated in earlier cycles. It is unclear whether this repeated conditioning introduces posterior bias or overconfidence. Proposition 1 establishes invariance only for the block smoother under exact guidance. The implementation, however, uses approximate MMPS guidance and sometimes large guidance strengths (ζ up to 20 for filtering and 150 for block smoothing). A comparison against exact Kalman/RTS posteriors on a linear-Gaussian system would directly address this concern.
Incremental methodological novelty. DAWIS combines inverse sampling from DAISI [1], multitask interpolants [3], and per-state noise schedules [4], which ForcingDAS [2] already uses for unified DA. The block-smoothing invariance result is closely related to concurrent work [5, 6]. DAWIS differs from ForcingDAS in revising the anchor state and in smoothing full trajectories without a full-sequence prior. Still, the main contribution is an effective combination of existing techniques. The benefit of revising previously fixed states is also not isolated, for example by an ablation with τ_min = 1 on all retained slots.
Limited ablations and statistical evidence. Sensitivity to window length, turning-point schedules and guidance strength is not systematically evaluated. Results use only 10 trajectories, and the large SEVIR standard deviations make several improvements difficult to assess; paired per-trajectory comparisons would help. The practical relevance of the block-smoothing guarantee is also unclear, since the Soft Block Smoother, which has no such guarantee, performs comparably or better (Table 17).
References
- Andrae, M., Wikingsson, E., Takao, S., Landelius, T., & Lindsten, F. (2026). DAISI: Data Assimilation with Inverse Sampling using Stochastic Interpolants. ICML 2026.
- Jia, Y., Chen, S., Pan, Y., et al. (2026). ForcingDAS: Unified and Robust Data Assimilation via Diffusion Forcing. arXiv:2605.14285.
- Negrel, H., Coeurdoux, F., Albergo, M. S., & Vanden-Eijnden, E. (2025). Multitask Learning with Stochastic Interpolants. NeurIPS 2025.
- Chen, B., Martí Monsó, D., Du, Y., Simchowitz, M., Tedrake, R., & Sitzmann, V. (2024). Diffusion Forcing: Next-token Prediction Meets Full-Sequence Diffusion. NeurIPS 2024.
- Hill, M. (2026). Exact Global MCMC with Denoising Diffusion. arXiv:2609.00279.
- Kang, H., Levi, N. I., Wegner, C. E., Korchinski, D. J., & Wyart, M. (2026). Sampling Data with Chains of Forward-Backward Diffusion Steps. arXiv:2605.27006.
Questions for authors
-
Can the authors characterize the distribution targeted by sequential windowed inversion, and explain whether repeated observation guidance introduces posterior bias? A linear-Gaussian comparison against exact Kalman/RTS posteriors would help.
-
What improvement comes specifically from revising the previously fixed historical state? Since Joint AR and ForcingDAS-Pyr already share the DAWIS prior, can this be isolated at matched smoothing lags and computational budgets? Currently their effective lag is 5 versus 6 for DAWIS, and ForcingDAS-Pyr uses 20 solver steps per cycle versus 100.
-
How sensitive are the results to window length, turning-point profiles, and guidance strength? For the filter and lagged smoother, would direct SDEdit-style noising, as already used for the block smoother (Eq. 9), perform comparably to stochastic inversion?
-
Can the authors report inference costs and paired statistical comparisons, particularly on SEVIR? Also, Section 5 reports 384×384 resolution, whereas Appendix D.5 specifies 128×128; which was used?
2 comments
Dear Reviewer YwYg,
The discussion period ends in less than 24h. We believe that we have addressed all your concerns. If there are any remaining questions we'd be happy to answer them.
Regards, The authors
We thank the reviewer for their time and detailed review. We appreciate the positive comments about the usefulness of DAWIS and hope to clear out any concerns below. We refer to two common responses: A (the DAWIS target) and B (new experiments).
[W1], [Q1]: Unclear posterior correctness.
We have characterized the DAWIS target in Appendix D.1. The final expression and the interpretation of double counting observations can be found in common response A.
[W1], [Q1]: Linear-Gaussian Comparison.
We thank the reviewer for this suggestion and have performed an experiment on a linear-Gaussian system to illustrate the bias and hyperparameters (A3).
[W1]: Biased guidance methods.
While the paper uses MMPS, this is just one possible choice, and better guidance methods are directly applicable to DAWIS. For
Saturatingwe used ζ=20 for the filter and ζ=150 for the block smoothers. With arctan observations, the observation Jacobian is nearly zero in the saturated region, so the linearised MMPS likelihood gradient is far too weak and the strength compensates for this.[W2]: Incremental methodological novelty.
Kang et al. and Hill et al. are both cited in the paper and should be viewed as concurrent work. Further, these papers concern only the noise-denoise update and not its application to smoothing posteriors which introduces additional challenges such as cycling. To the best of our knowledge, the use of windowed flow priors for block smoothing, including both the Blocked Gibbs Smoother and the DAWIS Block Smoother, has not been considered before.
[Q2]: Matched inference-costs to ForcingDAS-Pyr.
We rerun ForcingDAS-Pyr with 200 solver steps per cycle, which costs more than a DAWIS cycle. A larger budget does not improve ForcingDAS-Pyr relative to DAWIS in any setting (B7).
[Q2]: ForcingDAS-Pyr and Joint AR at Matched Lag.
ForcingDAS-Pyr and Joint AR with W∣1 have an effective smoothing lag of 5, compared with 6 for DAWIS. We additionally evaluate DAWIS and DAWIS-Joint at an effective lag of 5 (B6). Both DAWIS methods retain stronger performance than the corresponding baselines at this matched lag.
[W3], [Q3]: Window size ablation.
We have performed an ablation on the window size w=2,4,6 (B1). Throughout all experiments, DAWIS is the least affected by w, and its w=2-variant still outperforms all other filters using w=6. We can also clearly see the degradation of Joint AR W∣1 at shorter windows.
[W3], [Q3]: Turning point ablation.
In common response B4 we report a grid search over (τminstart,τminend). The sensitivity is moderate, and replacing the rolling schedule with the best static one increases the CRPS by 2–11%.
[W3], [Q3]: SDEdit ablation.
By Proposition 2, SDEdit-style noising is the special case of the windowed inversion with ετ=∣τ˙∣τ1−τ which tends to infinity as τ→0. Our parametrization uses ετ=ε∣τ˙∣(1−τ), so SDEdit corresponds to ε=1/τ. We did not run SDEdit as a separate ablation, but our tuning considered larger values of ε. On SQG, these consistently gave worse results, and the selected ε=0.03 is about two orders of magnitude below the SDEdit value, matching the result with DAISI [1] which also reported worse results for SDEdit. On SEVIR, the selected ε=2.5 coincides with the SDEdit value at the oldest slot (τminstart=0.4), indicating that SDEdit can work in this setting. At the newest slot (τminend=0.1), however, SDEdit corresponds to ε=10, four times the selected value. Unlike the block smoother, which needs SDEdit to avoid inverting under the conditional prior, the windowed inversion lets τmin and ε be chosen separately for each setting.
[1] Andrae, M., Wikingsson, E., Takao, S., Landelius, T., & Lindsten, F. (2026). DAISI: Data Assimilation with Inverse Sampling using Stochastic Interpolants. ICML 2026
[W3], [Q4]: Inconclusive SEVIR results.
We agree that the SEVIR differences are small against the reported standard deviations. These are dominated by the differences between the 10 events, which have very varying norms. To make the difference more clear, we compare them event by event in B5, which shows a consistent CRPS gain for DAWIS across all but 3 events.
[Q4]: Inference Cost Comparison.
We now report wall-clock time, network evaluations and peak memory for every method in Appendix K (B2). DAWIS is among the more expensive methods. However, the increased computational cost is well justified by the improved skill-to-compute ratio shown in Figures 34–36.
[Q4]: SEVIR Resolution.
Thank you for spotting this typo. The SEVIR domain covers 384×384 km at 3 km resolution, giving a 128×128 grid. We have corrected the text.