- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
4D-GSW proposes a kinematics-aware watermarking framework designed to preserve the physical coherence and spatiotemporal consistency of motion trajectories. The method introduces a spatiotemporal consistency (STC) gating strategy to suppress nonphysical perturbations, an HMM–MRF energy-minimization model to synchronize watermark phases.
Critical strengths
- Kinematics-aware STC gating: Incorporating trajectory velocity into the STC mechanism is an interesting approach to maintaining physically coherent motion during watermark embedding.
- Optimal transport for spatiotemporal consistency: The use of optimal transport (OT) to promote consistency across space and time is a promising component of the framework.
Critical weaknesses
- Insufficient baseline and dataset comparisons: The experimental evaluation does not sufficiently establish the method’s advantages and limitations relative to relevant competing approaches. Additional comparisons with recent methods and evaluations on widely used datasets would strengthen the paper.
- Limited ablation studies: The existing ablations do not clearly isolate the contributions of STC gating and OT. More targeted experiments are needed to substantiate the effectiveness of the main proposed components.
Questions for authors
Major:
-
Coverage of related work and baselines (line 118): Additional papers on 4D watermarking and steganography have been published or made available online in 2026, including Mark4D (CVPR 2026) and Guard4D (IJCAI 2026). The authors should consider discussing these methods as related work and including them as experimental baselines where their settings and implementations permit a fair comparison.
-
Dataset coverage: The authors evaluate their method on the Consistent4D dataset, whereas other methods use DyNeRF and D-NeRF. Please consider including these datasets to assess the method’s generalization across different scene types and motion characteristics. If these evaluations are not feasible, please explain why.
-
Alignment between the ablations and the proposed objective: The ablations in Table 4 (removing the temporal, spatial, or STC components) are difficult to map to the joint objective in Section 4, Equation (13). Please explicitly define which terms or mechanisms are removed in each variant. In particular, the following ablations would help clarify the main contributions:
- Removing STC gating: the watermark-embedding confidence weight w from L_conn (keep L_conn, remove w)
- Removing OT (Remove L_conn).
These experiments would give readers a clearer understanding of how each component affects watermark performance, reconstruction quality, and spatiotemporal consistency.
- Message-length ablation: Please evaluate different message lengths, such as 16, 32, and 48 bits, to characterize the trade-off between payload capacity, watermark recovery, and reconstruction quality.
Minor:
-
Citation formatting in Section 1: Several citations appear to be rendered incorrectly, making the text difficult to read. Please check the bibliography and citation formatting, e.g. Missing spaces:
- Page 1, line 037: a space is missing between “scenes” and “Hu & Han.”
- Page 3, line 132: a space is missing in “dynamicsLuiten.”
- Page 4, line 188: a space is missing in “decoderZhu et al.”
-
Table 1 presentation: Please distinguish more clearly between 4DGS methods and results with and without watermark or steganographic embedding, for example by using separate rows or groups.
-
Notation in Figure 2: The formulations is unclear or potentially incorrect. Please explain the notation {k_il ,k_iw } for all K and W.
-
Embedded message length: Section 5, lines 336–350, does not clearly specify how many bits are embedded (48bit is memtioned somewhere later). Please state the payload length explicitly and clarify whether it remains fixed across experiments.