- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
PhysMark addresses watermark recovery from medical 3DGS assets after digital dissemination and print-and-capture. It constructs local candidate carriers in a registered canonical space, ranks their reliability using response statistics across multiple subjects under digital and simulated physical channels, and guides learnable carriers through structured support masks and initialization. Watermarks are embedded in Gaussian log-scales, with training incorporating a differentiable print-and-capture channel, EOT, and several regularization terms. At the receiver, decoding follows corner-based rectification and extraction of the low-frequency Haar subband.
Critical strengths
-
The proposed combination of a population prior and learnable residuals is clearly motivated. Separating spatial support, initial carriers, and subsequent learning avoids repeating carrier search for every new asset.
-
The method directly optimizes recovery after propagation and achieves a favorable fidelity–recovery trade-off on unseen subjects. The authors also use the same physical channel for scene-specific baselines and allow them to be trained separately on each test subject, making the comparison more convincing than one against unadapted digital-domain baselines.
Critical weaknesses
-
Section 3 assumes stable Gaussian correspondences across instances, and Equation (4) depends on the row-alignment operator Πᵢ. However, the paper does not sufficiently explain how Conditional3DGS establishes these consistent correspondences from T2 MRI, how registration is performed, which subjects are used to construct the population prior, or which quantities remain fixed versus require optimization at test time.
-
The evidence for real physical-channel performance and practical ownership verification is too limited. Section 4.4 explicitly reports only one unseen subject and a single real photograph. The method recovers 14 of 16 bits, while the best baseline recovers 13. This one-bit difference is insufficient to establish a statistically reliable advantage under real physical-channel conditions.
-
The paper reports only average Bitacc, without complete-message recovery rates, effective capacity after error correction, false-positive rates on unwatermarked assets or incorrect messages, or detection rates at a fixed false-positive rate.
Questions for authors
- Are the prior statistics computed exclusively from training subjects? For test subjects, are B, ρ, the decoder, or any registration parameters updated, and what are the associated costs?
- Are results available for multiple unseen subjects and repeated printing/capture? Please report per-sample detection results or results with uncertainty intervals, and specify the devices, paper, capture conditions, and corner-based rectification requirements.
Response to Reviewer nqk8
Thank you for your detailed review.
W1. Gaussian correspondence and application to new subjects. The pretrained Conditional3DGS model takes an MNI-aligned T2 volume and predicts subject-specific offsets from a shared, ordered Gaussian template. Each reconstructed Gaussian retains its template index, which identifies the corresponding row of the learned carrier in Eq. (4). Given an aligned volume, PhysMark reuses this carrier and completes reconstruction and watermark embedding through forward passes.
W2. Real print-and-capture evaluation. Figure 3 shows one real print-and-capture example from a subject held out from watermark training. PhysMark recovered 14 of 16 bits (87.50%), and the best-performing baseline in that example recovered 13 of 16 bits (81.25%). This example demonstrates partial payload recovery after physical print-and-capture. Table 1 quantifies recovery under simulated print-and-capture conditions. Assessing variability across subjects and capture conditions would require repeated physical captures.
W3. Bit recovery and provenance verification. Bit accuracy measures the fraction of embedded bits recovered correctly, and payload length refers to the number of raw embedded bits. A provenance verifier could compare the decoded sequence with a registered payload using a calibrated Hamming-distance threshold. Evaluating this decision rule would require measuring false accepts on unwatermarked samples and on watermarked samples checked against an incorrect registered payload, then reporting the detection rate at a specified false-positive rate. Exact-message recovery and effective payload capacity after error correction are separate metrics.
Q1. Prior construction and test-time procedure. We compute the population response statistics using subjects from the watermark training split. Final carrier-group selection also uses a brain mask. The source volume for that mask remains unverified. At test time, we load the reconstruction model, carrier B, and decoder from their checkpoints and set the embedding strength ρ from the evaluation configuration. MNI alignment is a separate preprocessing step. Once the volume is aligned, reconstruction and embedding are forward-pass operations that use these fixed parameters.
Q2. Printing, capture, and rectification. The physical setup uses a standard printer, A4 paper, and artificial lighting. We define the capture angle as the angle between the camera’s optical axis and the paper plane. The tested angles range from 45∘ (oblique) to 90∘ (front-on). Before decoding, we use the four printed corner markers to estimate a perspective transform and rectify the image. Figure 3 reports the bit accuracy for one capture from this setup.