- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces EndoRDH, a watermarking framework for dynamic endoscopic 3DGS. The authors introduce four modules: Clinically Admissible Carrier Projection (CACP), Riemannian Photometric Decoupling (RPD), Optimal-transport-inspired Reversible Flow (ORF), and Dual-Branch Redundant Coding (DBRC).
Critical strengths
- Protecting reusable endoscopic 3DGS assets is clinically relevant, the motivation is reasonable.
- The writing is clear and easy to follow, and the content and figures are easy to read and understand.
- The methods are introduced in detail, with released code in the supplement.
Critical weaknesses
- The limitation is also quite clear: the experiments are mainly done on only two EndoNeRF sequences. There is a lack of sufficient experiments on multiple datasets and also sequence number to support the proposed method. e.g. StereoMIS, SCARED, Hamlyn, D4D, EndoSLAM, C3VD dataset.
- The novelty is also limited. Since the proposed RPD does not recover the real illumination physics and the ORF is “OT-inspired” rather than solving the OT problem.
- The evaluation is also not complete. The recovery evidence has only qualitative results, and no quantitative results are provided in the paper.
- While the paper compares with general domain GS watermarking method, there are only in-domain experiments. It seems a bit unfair since the compared methods are not used in their domain. The comparison can only claim that this paper introduces a method that is better for the Endoscopic-specific domain. However, the authors overclaim their contributions in their introduction and method. I think the correct way is also to compare with in-domain methods or compare general domain methods in the general domain datasets.
Hayoz M, Hahne C, Gallardo M, et al. Learning how to robustly estimate camera pose in endoscopic videos[J]. International journal of computer assisted radiology and surgery, 2023, 18(7): 1185-1192.
Allan M, Mcleod J, Wang C, et al. Stereo correspondence and reconstruction of endoscopic data challenge[J]. arXiv preprint arXiv:2101.01133, 2021.
Recasens D, Lamarca J, Fácil J M, et al. Endo-depth-and-motion: Reconstruction and tracking in endoscopic videos using depth networks and photometric constraints[J]. IEEE Robotics and Automation Letters, 2021, 6(4): 7225-7232.
Docea R, Younis R, Long Y, et al. The Dresden Dataset for 4D Reconstruction of Non-Rigid Abdominal Surgical Scenes[J]. Scientific Data, 2026, 13(1): 1334.
Ozyoruk K B, Gokceler G I, Bobrow T L, et al. EndoSLAM dataset and an unsupervised monocular visual odometry and depth estimation approach for endoscopic videos[J]. Medical image analysis, 2021, 71: 102058.
Bobrow T L, Golhar M, Vijayan R, et al. Colonoscopy 3d video dataset with paired depth from 2d-3d registration[J]. Medical image analysis, 2023, 90: 102956.
Questions for authors
I have mentioned all concerns in the above weaknesses.
2 comments
Thank you for the response. However, my concern is not fully resolved. Since:
-
The newly added StereoMIS experiment contains only two sequences, with no experiment setup details. This is only an incremental experiment that lacks sufficient evidence to support my previous comment, where I mentioned StereoMIS, SCARED, Hamlyn, D4D, EndoSLAM, C3VD a total of 6 datasets.
-
This clarification for comment 4 does not resolve my original concern. The current comparisons remain in-domain only. The experiments can support a claim that the proposed method is better suited to the endoscopic setting under this shared host, but they still do not justify broader claims of superiority over general-domain GS watermarking methods. To address this fairly, the authors should either compare with in-domain methods or evaluate the general-domain baselines on general-domain datasets (or both).
Therefore, I retain my score.
We thank the reviewer for the careful reading, answered below one by one.
Comment 1: Experiments are limited to two EndoNeRF sequences; additional datasets are needed.
The revision adds multiple StereoMIS evaluation sequences, a qualitative comparison in the main text and panels in Appendix F. The StereoMIS sequences enter the shared-protocol quantitative evaluation; the figures are visual complements, while the quantitative claims rest on the aggregate metrics reported in the manuscript. Further datasets and acquisition systems are needed for broader generalization, which we acknowledge.
Revision location: Section 4.1; Appendix F; Section 5 and Appendix G.
Comment 2: Limited novelty; RPD does not recover illumination physics and ORF is OT-inspired but does not solve optimal transport.
RPD does not estimate physical illumination or intrinsic reflectance. It builds a carrier-dependent cost geometry meant to reflect local photometric variation for allocation. ORF uses an optimal-transport-inspired prior without solving a global transport problem. Invertibility comes from the additive-coupling maps; the prior only biases transport toward lower-cost, locally stable carriers. The description now separates feasible-set restriction (CACP), carrier geometry (RPD), allocation prior (ORF) and redundant evidence aggregation (DBRC), and no longer presents them as illumination recovery or an OT solver.
Revision location: Abstract; Sections 1 and 3; Appendices B and C.
Comment 3: Recovery results are qualitative and lack quantitative results.
Float32 SH recovery RMSE is now in Section 4.5 (Table 4, reproduced below as Table 2). EndoRDH gives 5.2×10−6 in the stated no-post-modification setting. The embedding-mechanism comparison is manuscript Table 5, below as Table 3, and the factorized ablation is manuscript Table 3. The measured setting is now kept distinct from recovery after quantization or model-domain attacks.
Table 2: Fidelity and authorized recovery. Lower SH RMSE is better.
Table 3: Verification accuracy (%).
Revision location: Section 4.3; Section 4.5, Tables 4–5; Appendix H.
Comment 4: Generic-domain comparisons may be unfair and contributions may be overclaimed.
The controlled-transfer protocol is now spelled out: external methods are migrated to a common endoscopic 3DGS host and evaluated with shared sequences, ROI definitions, rendering interface and metrics. That controls for reconstruction differences, but it does not reproduce each method's original benchmark or establish superiority on generic 3DGS data. The main results are in Table 4 and attack-averaged verification in Table 5, using the manuscript's reported values.
Table 4: Equal-weight averages over the evaluated EndoNeRF and StereoMIS sequences under the shared protocol. Rendering measured against GT; accuracies in %.
Table 5: Verification accuracy (%) clean and under averaged attacks; overall is the mean of the 2D and 3D averages.
The conclusion is narrowed to the stated endoscopic transfer protocol, with no cross-domain superiority claim.
Revision location: Sections 4.1–4.2; Appendix D.