- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes MPP-GS, a watermarking method for 3D Gaussian Splatting. It uses Multi-Projection Packing (MPP) to distribute Gaussians more evenly across a UV grid and reduce overflow. Complementary Pair Modulation (CPM) then embeds watermarks using parent–auxiliary Gaussian pairs while trying to minimize rendering distortion. Experiments on three datasets show improved rendering quality and bit accuracy compared to existing methods.
Critical strengths
-
Clear evaluation of carrier construction. The paper compares SPP and MPP under the same carrier budget, showing a large reduction in overflow (32.0% to 0.14% on LLFF) and better coverage across all 23 scenes (Fig. 4b). Table 4 also provides a fair comparison of allocation strategies under the same carrier and pair budget.
-
Simple design with consistent results. The pair parameterization (Eq. 9) preserves the original opacity under alpha composition, and the resulting model remains compatible with standard 3DGS renderers. The method also shows consistent improvements in bit accuracy and rendering fidelity across three datasets and multiple payload sizes.
Critical weaknesses
-
The main improvement may come from fixing a problem introduced by UV packing. SPP already loses many Gaussians before watermarking (32% overflow on LLFF), resulting in poor reconstruction quality. Thus, much of the PSNR gain over SPP+CPM may simply come from retaining more Gaussians rather than better watermark allocation. I think an important baseline is missing here: applying balanced spatial quotas directly to native 3DGS using voxel or kNN partitions, without UV packing. Without this comparison, it is hard to tell whether MPP is really necessary.
-
The pair structure may be vulnerable to adaptive attacks. Parent and auxiliary Gaussians share the same center and rotation, making them potentially easy to identify. An attacker could merge these pairs or selectively remove duplicated Gaussians. Since the opacity and DC updates are designed to cancel, and the differential SH component also cancels under weighted averaging (Eq. 13), such attacks may significantly weaken the watermark. The current robustness experiments mainly consider random model modifications and 2D distortions, but do not test attacks targeting this specific structure.
-
Fairness and computational overhead need more discussion. It is unclear whether all baselines were evaluated under the same protocol. For example, W2M uses Scaffold-GS, and the methods use different watermark decoders. The paper also reports results from three seeds without standard deviations. Moreover, the method adds around 45–58% more Gaussians, increasing rendering time by roughly 1.5–1.8×. It is unclear how much of the fidelity improvement comes from the additional primitives. Nullspace modulation also relies on a limited set of representative directions rather than actual rendering views.
-
It would be useful to briefly discuss whether MPP and CPM could extend to dynamic 4D Gaussians. Since MPP relies on Gaussian centers for UV assignment, it is unclear whether packing should be done in canonical space and whether the balanced allocation would still hold after deformation. A short discussion of this limitation would be sufficient.
Questions for authors
-
How robust is the watermark to attacks that merge parent–auxiliary pairs or selectively remove Gaussians with duplicated centers?
-
How would MPP compare with balanced watermark allocation directly on native 3DGS, using voxel or kNN-based spatial partitions without UV packing?
-
In Table 3(b), why does nullspace modulation improve BA from 94.95% to 96.19% despite restricting SH updates? Also, how well do the selected projection directions match the actual training and test views, especially on LLFF? Were the Table 1 baselines rerun under the same evaluation protocol?