- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 1
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies coupled autoregressive decoding, which coordinates multiple generations while preserving each answer’s marginal distribution. It distinguishes two distribution-preservation requirements and analyzes how different sampling constructions affect pass@K. The paper proves that independent path stratification cannot reduce expected pass@K relative to IID sampling under its assumptions, while random-shift lattices and fresh token stratification can either help or hurt. Experiments show no statistically significant gains on the tested open-ended math benchmarks, but a positive effect on multiple-choice Countdown.
Critical strengths
-
The paper studies a meaningful question: whether coordinating multiple samples can improve pass@K without changing the distribution of individual answers.
-
The distinction between sampling constructions is useful. In particular, the protection guarantee for path stratification and the counterexamples for other constructions clarify why more evenly distributed samples do not necessarily provide better correct-answer coverage.
Critical weaknesses
-
My main concern is the limited experimental coverage. The evaluation uses only two Qwen2.5 models, two open-ended math benchmarks, and a synthetic multiple-choice Countdown task. There are no code-generation experiments, although code generation is an important application of pass@K. Evaluation on coding benchmarks and additional challenging math datasets would help establish how broadly the findings apply.
-
The practical benefits remain unclear. The tested methods show no statistically significant gains on GSM8K or MATH-500, including the path-stratified method with a theoretical protection guarantee. The positive result is limited to multiple-choice Countdown. It is therefore unclear when these theoretical insights lead to meaningful improvements in realistic generation tasks.
Questions for authors
Do you have additional results on coding or harder math tasks that support benefits beyond multiple-choice Countdown?
What practical guidance does the theory provide for choosing a sampler without access to correctness labels?
4 comments
Author Response (Continued)
Practical guidance without correctness labels: We appreciate the reviewer's concern about how our theoretical results can guide practical sampler selection. To make this clearer, we now provide a concrete choice rule based on the required guarantees, summarized in Table 1 (p. 3), Section 3.1 (pp. 4–5), and Section 6 (p. 10).
When the goal is to preserve complete-answer distributions while guaranteeing expected coverage at least as good as IID, independent path stratification provides a label-free solution. It draws independent random offsets within fixed strata and uniformly assigns them to individual generations, assuming a common decoder, token ordering, and success rule. Importantly, this method does not require correctness labels during generation.
Theorem 1 guarantees that expected success for any fixed subset of outputs cannot be worse than IID under the ideal assumptions. However, the guarantee allows equal performance and does not imply improvement in every finite batch. Proposition 6, highlighted in Section 3.1, further explains when improvements occur: for any fixed pair of outputs in a K-stratum design, the gain is exactly Var(q_j)/(K−1), where q_j is the success probability within each stratum. Thus, differences in success probabilities across strata determine the benefit.
When the goal instead requires preserving next-token distributions given the completed history of all generations, IID satisfies this stronger requirement. Fresh token stratification also satisfies it, but Proposition 3 (p. 5) shows that it does not guarantee improved pass@K. Similarly, Proposition 2 provides an exact criterion for when lattice sampling helps or hurts, based on the overlap between successful regions. Therefore, marginal preservation alone is insufficient to identify a universally beneficial lattice sampler without correctness information.
These distinctions provide practical guidance based on the specific distribution-preservation and coverage requirements, rather than treating all forms of diversity as equivalent.
Connecting theoretical guarantees to measured improvements: We thank the reviewer for encouraging us to clarify the practical implications of our theoretical findings. Our original held-out Countdown experiment (Section 4.3, Table 3, pp. 7–8) evaluates lattice sampling on 512 reserved prompts, with four batches per prompt and method. Lattice pass@8 improves from 52.2% to 57.3%, a gain of 5.1 percentage points (95% CI [3.8, 6.6]), while satisfying the predefined marginal-accuracy equivalence criterion.
This result demonstrates that lattice sampling can provide meaningful improvements in a particular setting, while our path-stratification theorem establishes a separate, more general expected-coverage guarantee under its assumptions. The additional coding and harder-math experiments described in our first response further investigate practical performance across broader tasks, without assuming that the Countdown improvement generalizes universally.
Additional experiments supporting practical guidance: We also added controlled experiments varying sampling budget and temperature, as requested by another reviewer (Appendix D.2, pp. 27–28, Table 21).
These experiments compare all six sampling methods using freshly generated batches with K=4, 8, and 16 at temperatures 0.7 and 1.0. They cover matched 16-question MATH-500 panels with Qwen-3B and Mistral-7B, as well as a 16-task HumanEval+ panel with Qwen-3B, using one batch per question and setting.
For example, on Qwen-3B/MATH-500, independent path strata solve between two more and two fewer questions than Arithmetic-IID, depending on the decoding configuration. None of the registered method comparisons or K/temperature interaction tests establishes a statistically significant difference after correction.
These results reinforce an important distinction: theoretical protection provides a principled basis for choosing a sampler, even when empirical gains are small or uncertain, but does not establish a universally superior method.
Finally, Section 4.6 and Appendix D include additional analyses that distinguish predictive performance from actual computational savings, and diversity among verified correct solutions from differences in generated text.
Together, these additions provide a clearer connection between our theoretical findings and practical sampler selection, supported by broader experiments across models, tasks, and decoding settings. We hope the complete coding evaluation, additional challenging-task results, and explicit label-free choice rule help address the reviewer's concerns and support a more favorable assessment of the paper.
Thank you for the additional experiments and the detailed response.
Experimental coverage. The full HumanEval+ evaluation and the additional coding and AIME experiments address my concern about coverage. I consider this point resolved.
Practical benefit. This concern remains. None of the new comparisons reaches statistical significance. The only significant positive result is therefore still multiple-choice Countdown.
Choice rule. The rule for choosing a sampler by the required guarantee is clear, thank you. Could you explain why Countdown shows a gain while the open-ended tasks do not? For example, is the variation in success rates across strata small in open-ended tasks?
Overall, I will maintain my original rating in this turn. My confidence on the theoretical part is limited, and I defer to the other reviewers and the AC on the novelty of the theorems.
Author Response and Thank You
We sincerely thank the reviewer for carefully considering our additional experiments and for acknowledging that the expanded coding and harder-math evaluations resolve the concern about experimental coverage. We also appreciate your recognition of the practical choice rule and your continued feedback on the connection between theory and empirical improvements.
Why does Countdown show improvements while open-ended tasks do not? This is an important question, and our theoretical analysis provides some insight, although the current experiments do not establish a complete explanation.
First, the benefit of coupled decoding depends on the distribution of successful outputs in the arithmetic-decoding space, rather than simply on individual model accuracy. Specifically:
- For independent path stratification, Proposition 6 shows that the expected improvement for a fixed pair of outputs is exactly Var(q_j)/(K-1), where q_j is the success probability within each stratum. Therefore, when success probabilities are similar across strata, the expected improvement is small or zero, even though the protection guarantee still holds.
- For lattice sampling, Proposition 2 shows that improvement depends on the overlap between shifted successful regions. The positive Countdown result is consistent with favorable success geometry, whereas the open-ended tasks may have different overlap structures.
Regarding your specific question, we have not directly established that the variance of stratum success probabilities is small on open-ended tasks. This is a plausible explanation for limited gains from independent path stratification, but it would require additional correctness-labeled measurements to verify. Moreover, the variance characterization applies to path stratification, while lattice performance depends on the separate overlap criterion.
Other factors may also contribute to the differences. For example, the Qwen-Math-7B GSM8K evaluation already achieves 98.2% IID pass@8, leaving little room for improvement. The open-ended math evaluations also involve longer generations and truncation, unlike the short multiple-choice Countdown task. Differences in decoding settings and output formats prevent us from attributing the observed contrast to geometry alone.
We agree that the additional experiments do not establish statistically significant improvements on realistic open-ended tasks, and we have been careful to reflect this limitation in the revised paper. Nevertheless, we believe the theoretical results provide a useful contribution independent of these empirical outcomes: they identify when coverage is guaranteed not to degrade, explain why other marginal-preserving methods can fail, and characterize the geometric conditions governing improvements.
Thank you very much again for dedicating your time and effort to review our paper. Your insights and feedback have been invaluable in guiding our revisions, and we are confident that these changes have strengthened the paper. As the rebuttal period closes today, we would be happy to answer any remaining questions or clarify any part of our response. If you feel that our response and revisions have addressed your concerns, we would be grateful if you would consider updating your score to reflect your current assessment.
Author Response
We are grateful for the reviewer's insightful suggestions and feedback. We thank the reviewer for recognizing the importance of our research question and the value of our theoretical guarantees and counterexamples in clarifying the behavior of different sampling methods. If the reviewer takes these points into consideration and finds more value in our study, we would be grateful if you could adjust your score in a positive way.
Results beyond multiple-choice Countdown: We thank the reviewer for highlighting the importance of evaluating our methods on coding and more challenging mathematics tasks. To address this concern, we added a full HumanEval+ evaluation, along with additional coding and AIME experiments across different model families. Below, we report the full-benchmark results separately from the smaller exploratory studies.
Full functional-coding evaluation: We evaluated all six sampling methods on the complete 164-task HumanEval+ benchmark using Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct (Table 4, p. 9; Appendix C.1, p. 24; Table 17, p. 25). All methods use the same temperature (0.7), top-p (0.95), no top-k filtering, batch size (K=8), and EOS-or-2,048-token stopping, with one batch per task and method. A generated program is considered correct only if it passes both the base and expanded functional tests.
Lattice sampling solves four more tasks than Arithmetic-IID, corresponding to a 2.44-percentage-point improvement. However, the pointwise 95% paired confidence interval [0.00, 5.49] and exact paired test (p=0.219; Holm-adjusted p=0.656) do not establish a statistically significant improvement.
These results extend our evaluation to a complete functional-coding benchmark. All methods use the same EvalPlus 0.3.1 evaluator, including the shared oracle-progress and helper-retention fixes described in Appendix C.1.
Additional coding experiments across model families: We further expanded our evaluation to Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct and Mistral-7B-Instruct-v0.3 on fixed 16-task subsets of HumanEval+ and MBPP+ (Appendix D.5, pp. 29–30, Table 24). All methods use the same decoding settings and require generated programs to pass both base and expanded functional tests.
The number of tasks solved (out of 16) is:
Additional experiments on harder mathematics: We also evaluated all six sampling methods on AIME 2024 and AIME 2025, using Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct, Qwen2.5-Math-7B-Instruct, and Mistral-7B-Instruct-v0.3 (Appendix D.5, p. 30, Table 25).
For each year, we use the same fixed subset of 16 questions from the full 30-question benchmark. All methods use K=8, temperature 0.7, top-p 0.95, no top-k filtering, EOS-or-3,072-token stopping, and final-answer grading, with one batch per question and method.
The number of questions solved (out of 16) is:
While some methods show promising numerical differences in individual settings, none of the new coding or harder-math comparisons establishes a statistically significant improvement after multiple-comparison correction. For example, fresh token strata solve two more Mistral/HumanEval+ tasks than Arithmetic-IID, but the exact paired test gives p=0.5 (Holm-adjusted p=1.0).
We emphasize that these additional experiments use fixed subsets and one repetition per setting. They are exploratory evaluations, not full MBPP+ or AIME benchmark results, and are analyzed separately from the complete 164-task HumanEval+ study.
Together, these new experiments directly address the reviewer's concern about missing coding and challenging mathematics evaluations, while also expanding the evidence to additional models and tasks. Although they do not establish consistent practical improvements, they provide a broader assessment of the sampling methods and their performance across different generation settings.