- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 1
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper investigates whether, in discrete diffusion robot policies, determining the token submission order based on the probabilities of already-sampled candidate values suppresses the coverage of effective behavior modes.
Critical strengths
The paper is difficult to read and follow, which makes it hard to assess its strengths. The writing is often unclear and does not meet the standard of clarity expected for a conference submission. I encourage the authors to revise the manuscript substantially, particularly its motivation and presentation.
Critical weaknesses
The paper is very difficult to read and follow. The figures do not clearly convey the paper’s central motivation, and their design makes the main message hard to understand. The research question and the motivation for the proposed method also need clearer explanations. The connection between the theoretical analysis and the proposed method is unclear. The paper does not include a table of experimental results, please don't use figure. In addition, there is no real-robot demo.
Questions for authors
I recommend that the authors substantially improve the paper’s readability.
Response to Reviewer
Thank you for pointing out how hard the main result was to find. Take the instruction “put either can in the basket.” A robot that always picks soup could succeed every time. If we start it from the same state ten times, does it ever pick tomato?
We changed one decision in the decoder. It predicts several action tokens at once and must choose which positions to fill first. With Coupled, a position gets its score from the very token the decoder will write there. With Split, a separate draw from the same predictions supplies that score. The theorem shows how the first rule can favor some sampled values. The table shows what happened when we switched rules in the same trained policy.
We prepared a revision that opens with this example and places the numerical comparison at the start of Results. All of the Choice rollouts were closed-loop simulations. We have no physical-robot demonstration.