acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

When Does Sharing a Sampled Reasoning Prefix Pay Off?

Abstract

Generating several reasoning candidates and keeping any correct one raises coverage, the fraction of problems that at least one candidate solves. Continuing one sampled prefix into several candidates makes this cheaper, but every candidate then inherits the prefix's early choices. We ask when sharing a sampled prefix pays off at an equal budget of generated tokens. When continuations keep the decoding settings and generation allowance of independent sampling, sharing the first tokens saves a fraction of a second candidate's generation and removes a fraction of its coverage gain, the share of success variance these tokens explain. On each problem, independent sampling at the same expected budget covers it at least as often as every preset allocation of candidates to sampled prefixes of length if and only if . Measuring both fractions from continuations of stored prefixes, under plans fixed before sampling, on grade-school mathematics of intermediate difficulty with four base models and a thinking model, we find that early tokens resolve success variance faster than they consume generation: the shortest tested prefixes explain 1.8 to 3.5 times their share of generation. At the same expected budget, eight candidates sharing one prefix covered significantly fewer problems than independent sampling for every model and branch position tested. By the time candidates branch, they already share part of their chances of success.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
test-time compute, parallel sampling, pass@k, prefix sharing, reasoning, tree search, conditional success probability

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_4MoDOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This is an analysis paper that studies whether generating several reasoning candidates from one shared sampled prefix solves more problems than sampling them independently from the start, at the same token budget. Sharing a prefix saves tokens, but the candidates inevitably inherit the prefix's early thinking direction. The authors show that the tradeoff comes down to two quantities: i) how much of the problem’s success variance is explained by the prefix (ρ) and ii) how much generation it saves (s). So, independent sampling is at least as good whenever ρ ≥ s, i.e., the savings are greater than the paid variance reduction. Experiments on GSM8K with several open-weight models find that early tokens reduce output variance faster than they consume budget. So, shared-prefix candidates consistently reach fewer solutions than independent sampling. The paper also shows that after a failure, restarting beats continuing the same prefix, and that greedy prefixes can raise single-sample accuracy while lowering overall coverage.

Critical strengths
  • Figures are very visually pleasant and clean.
  • The structure of the paper is easy to follow, as theorems, propositions, tables, and figures are visually well delimited.
  • Clean criterion. The paper turns a vague trade-off into two measurable quantities (ρ and s) with a theorem. The same criterion also covers retries and bounds larger candidate sets.
  • Rigorous methodology. The analysis plans were pre-registered, the estimators are unbiased, and intervals are bootstrapped with Holm correction.
  • Consistent findings. The ordering holds across models, branch positions, and budget definitions. The secondary results (restart beats continue, greedy prefixes raise pass@1 but lower coverage) are useful for anyone designing tree search.
Critical weaknesses
  • Limited theoretical novelty. The core criterion is the classical optimum of two-stage cluster sampling, which the authors do acknowledge (Kish, Cochran). The contribution is the transfer and the measurement, not the maths.

  • Limited experimental breadth.

    • The main experiments use short GSM8K solutions from base models with a 320-token budget. They don't test where shared generation reportedly helps, E.g., long reasoning on hard problems with branches at uncertain tokens.
    • The theory covers entropy-based branching, but the paper never measures it, and the planned competition-problem runs only on 10 qualifying problems.
    • Only 2-9B models are tested, and four of five are Qwen 3.5 variants.
  • The matched-policy premise is not fully explained. Shared continuations have lower pass@1 in all 17 settings, significant when pooled at 48 tokens, and the cause is unexplained. Yet all the theorems rely on that premise.

Questions for authors
  • Theorem 2 mentions entropy-based branch positions, but all experiments branch at fixed positions. Does ρ/s fall below 1 when branching is triggered by entropy or confidence?
  • Shared continuations have lower pass@1 than independent samples in all 17 settings. What causes this, given that the theory assumes the two have the same distribution?
9 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 4MoD (1/4)

Summary, and branch points chosen by entropy or confidence (Q1)

Thank you for a precise and technically deep review. Your questions on branch points chosen by entropy or confidence, on the pass@1 premise and on the breadth of models and tasks pointed exactly where further tests would add the most. We measured each of them: the results support the submission's criterion and extend it to settings the submission did not cover:

Your pointWhat we didResult
Q1: entropy or confidence branchingEPTree's forking tokens (TreeRL's entropy) with a random control, a confidence trigger, Fork-Think; two modelsno main configuration covers significantly more than independent sampling; uncertainty-chosen points gain little over random ones
Q2/W3: lower pass@1 of shared continuationsdecomposition, three boundswithin error in each setting; in the base models it sits mostly in the source draws; changes predicted coverage by at most 1.8 pp, against gaps of 14.9–25.0 pp
W1: novelty over cluster samplingcompared the theory with two-stage cluster samplingthree coverage results beyond Kish's optimum (table under W1 below)
W2: 320 tokens, 10 problemsQwen3-8B, 32K tokens, 63 competition problemsρ\rho matches ss within error; for eight candidates, a sharing gain above 2.4–4.2 pp excluded
W2: "four of five are Qwen 3.5"three non-Qwen thinking models released in 2026 by Google, Zhipu AI and NVIDIA, 26–31B, 32K tokenssame as Qwen3-8B in all three
W2: other tasksMBPP code, 202 problemssame pattern as mathematics from 16 tokens on

Q1. "Does ρ/s fall below 1 when branching is triggered by entropy or confidence?"

Not significantly. An entropy or confidence threshold is a stopping time, which Theorem 2 covers, and at our confidence trigger ρ(τ)/s(τ)\rho(\tau)/s(\tau) is 1.22 [0.97, 1.49] on Qwen3.5-35B-A3B and 0.84 [0.51, 1.22] on Qwen3-8B with 32K tokens. Rules that take the highest-scoring tokens of a whole path, EPTree's −log⁡π-\log\pi (which TreeRL calls entropy) and Fork-Think's top-10 entropy, select the prefix; Corollary 1 prices them as the sharing term plus the gain from the choice, and in their main configurations none covers significantly more than independent sampling at an equal budget.

Independent − rule coverage (pp)Qwen3-8B, 32K, competitionQwen3.5-35B-A3B-Base, GSM8K
Confidence trigger, 1×8+3.2 [−1.4, 8.0]+12.0 [8.8, 15.4]
EPTree, forking tokens, (4,2,1,2) / (4,1,1,8)+0.6 / +2.6+1.4 / +1.4
EPTree, random positions, (4,2,1,2) / (4,1,1,8)+0.3 / +2.6+1.6 / +0.7
EPTree, forking tokens, tree by tree (4,2,1,2) / (4,1,1,8)+0.7 / +4.2+9.2 [6.6, 11.9] / +13.6 [10.4, 16.8]
EPTree, second iteration (4,2,2,2), tree by tree+3.3† [0.1, 7.2]+11.0 [8.3, 13.9]

Positive favors independent sampling; bold: 95% interval excludes zero; †: not significant after Holm's adjustment (Appendix E.2). Tree by tree, independent coverage is 85–95%.

  • The gain from choosing by uncertainty is small. Continuations from the first forking token of each path succeed about as often as independent samples (+0.8 pp on Qwen3-8B, −1.5 pp on Qwen3.5-35B-A3B, both within error); tree by tree, forking tokens cover 2.2–3.1 pp more than random positions on Qwen3.5-35B-A3B (one of four estimates significant before adjustment) and 0.6–2.2 pp less on Qwen3-8B.
  • Independent sampling led all 12 main comparisons and all 4 random controls, and none favors a rule significantly (General Response 1/3; Section 7, Appendix E.2).
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 4MoD (2/4)

The pass@1 of shared continuations (Q2, W3)

Q2. "Shared continuations have lower pass@1 than independent samples in all 17 settings. What causes this?" W3. "The matched-policy premise is not fully explained."

In each of the 17 settings, shared and independent pass@1 agree within error (largest gap 2.1 pp); pooled over the base models at 48 tokens, the 1.7 pp shortfall is significant. Sharing cannot cause it, since a continuation has the same distribution whether its prefix is continued once or eight times, and three bounds show it is far too small to produce the coverage gaps. Most of it, 1.2 pp, sits in the source paths, complete samples drawn before any continuation, which fall below the independent bank within error; continuations track their own source paths (+0.5, +0.4, −0.5 pp). Continuations resume from the exact token IDs with the sampler, settings and remaining allowance of independent sampling (Proposition 4).

Shared minus independent pass@1 (pp)8 tokens16 tokens48 tokens
Continuations − their own source paths (four base models)+0.5+0.4−0.5
Source paths − independent bank (one value for all positions)−1.2 [−3.2, 0.9]−1.2−1.2
Total, pooled−0.7 [−1.7, 0.3]−0.8 [−2.0, 0.4]−1.7 [−3.3, −0.1]

Four base models; every interval of the two parts contains zero. The 17 negative point estimates rest on five banks, because the positions of each model share one bank and one set of source paths.

Thinking models: in the 8K model the source paths fall 5.6 pp below the bank [−9.4, −1.8], and continuations lie 3.9–5.2 pp above their own source paths, each interval excluding zero, which brings them back to within 1.7 pp of the bank. The deficit is one of termination: 57.0% of source paths reach the 8K allowance against 51.5% of bank samples [+1.9, +9.3], while traces that conclude are correct in 100% and 99.9% of cases. The allowance therefore accounts for the whole deficit. The estimators use source-path outcomes only for prefixes that have already ended, so the deficit does not produce the coverage gaps (Appendix C). For Qwen3-8B with 32K tokens the differences are −0.7, +2.0 and +1.6 pp at 5, 20 and 40%, all within error.

In code the sign reverses, with the source draws. In MBPP (Appendix E.5) the source paths drew 1.7 pp above their independent bank, within error, and shared pass@1 is higher at all five positions (+0.2 to +1.7 pp). At 4 and 8 tokens this accounts for 1.2 and 1.4 pp of the 1.7 and 1.9 pp by which two shared candidates beat the Proposition 1 prediction; the curvature of pass@k and program lengths account for the rest. In the base models, the thinking model and MBPP alike, the sign of the difference is that of the source draws, which precede any continuation.

Three bounds attribute the coverage gap to sharing; weaker resumed candidates account for at most 1.8 pp of the eight-candidate gap at 48 tokens:

Bound on the effect on coverageValue
Four prefixes continued once each, against four independent samples (no sharing)−0.6 pp on average (+0.5 to −2.3; 1 of 17 intervals excludes zero)
One prefix continued four times, against those same resumed candidates (sharing)−4.1 to −25.6 pp
Attributing the whole shortfall to μ\mu in the Beta model of eight shared candidatesat most 1.8 pp, against measured gaps of 14.9–25.0 pp at 48 tokens

Section 2 and Appendix C now report this decomposition next to the three bounds.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 4MoD (3/4)

Novelty (W1)

W1. "The core criterion is the classical optimum of two-stage cluster sampling … The contribution is the transfer and the measurement, not the maths."

The two-candidate condition coincides with Kish's optimum, which Section 3 cites; three results go beyond it:

Two-stage cluster sampling (Kish)This paper
Objectivevariance of an estimated meancoverage 1−E[(1−Vm)N]1-\mathbb E[(1-V_m)^N], a nonlinear functional of the whole distribution of VmV_m; Theorem 1 gives its exact loss for every N as an expected Bregman gap
Scope of the resultthe optimal subsample size for a meanTheorem 2: ρq≥sq\rho_q \ge s_q makes independent sampling at least as good as every preset allocation G×bG\times b on that question, for every N (via log-convexity of FbF_b)
Adaptive and selected prefixesnot addressed by the two-stage optimumthe identity stays exact at stopping times (the confidence trigger); Corollary 1 splits a selected prefix into sharing cost and gain from the choice; Proposition 3 gives the continue-or-restart rule

This is how Section 7 reads the branch rules: forking tokens add no measurable inherited success, and Fork-Think's greedy seed leaves 24 of 128 questions without a successful continuation, where independent sampling with the same tokens is expected to solve 22.6 of them. The long-reasoning run follows Proposition 3's ordering (after four failures, restart 21.8% against continue 10.6%).

The criterion also predicts the size of the coverage gain where sharing pays, which a variance optimum for a mean does not give. In a positive control, when worked examples make the first tokens restate the question, ρ\rho at 48 tokens falls from 0.48 to 0.02 against ss of 0.23, and two shared candidates go from 4.5 pp behind independent ones to 3.8 pp ahead; at the end of the restatement they lead by 5.1 [4.2, 6.2] pp, against 5.3 predicted (General Response 2/3).

Section 3 now states, right after the Kish citation, how Theorem 2 turns the variance condition into a coverage statement.

Reviewer_8cu4OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies whether sharing a sampled reasoning prefix across multiple continuations is more effective than independent sampling under the same inference token budget

Critical strengths

The paper is very well written and clearly organized. The motivation, theoretical analysis, and experimental results are presented in a logical and easy-to-follow manner.

Critical weaknesses
  1. My main concern is the motivation behind the experimental setting. Most experiments simply sample a random reasoning prefix and generate multiple continuations from it. However, it is unclear how commonly this strategy is used in practice. Existing methods , such as confidence-based branching and tree decoding. Reusing naturally shared prefixes in tree decoding is quite different from forcing multiple trajectories to share the same randomly sampled prefix. Therefore, I am not sure how much the finding that random-prefix sharing performs worse than independent sampling tells us about practical reasoning systems

  2. The main experiments focus mostly on relatively small models and GSM8K. Although the authors include some additional results with larger models, the evaluation is abit limited, especially for modern thinking models. Stronger reasoning models may behave quite differently. They might identify good reasoning strategies earlier, but they may also be better at correcting mistakes or changing direction during generation.

  3. I am also concerned about the 8K token limit used for the thinking model. As the authors report, around half of the reasoning traces do not finish within this limit, while almost all completed traces are correct. This makes it difficult to tell whether the observed early prediction of success actually reflects reasoning quality,

Questions for authors
  1. I think the paper would be better if it included comparisons with more realistic branching methods.
7 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 8cu4 (1/4)

Summary, and realistic branching methods (W1, Q1)

Thank you for pressing on what matters for practice. Your three requests, the branch rules practical systems use, a thinking model that is not cut off by its allowance and stronger reasoning models, produced the most practically relevant results of the revision. We measured those rules and ran the long-reasoning and model tests you asked for, and in each, sharing gained no significant coverage at an equal budget, whether the prefix was sampled at random or chosen by a practical rule in its main configuration; long reasoning also places ρ\rho close to ss, which the revision now states:

Your pointWhat we didResult
W1/Q1: realistic branching methodsEPTree (TreeRL) with its random control, a confidence trigger, Fork-Think; two models, every token chargedno main configuration covers significantly more than independent sampling; independent sampling leads all 12 main comparisons, significantly in 3
W3: half the 8K traces do not finishthe same Qwen3.5-2B on the same questions at 32K (3.1% truncated); Qwen3-8B at 32K (5.2% truncated)at 32K the excess of ρ\rho over ss falls to 0.02–0.06, within error at every position; no significant sharing gain at any position
W2: stronger reasoning modelsQwen3-8B at 32K; three non-Qwen thinking models released in 2026 by Google, Zhipu AI and NVIDIAearly tokens explain success variance in proportion to their share of generation, within error; at the same share, a failed prefix recovers, relative to a restart, about twice as often as in the 8K model, and restarting still wins

W1 / Q1. "Reusing naturally shared prefixes in tree decoding is quite different from forcing multiple trajectories to share the same randomly sampled prefix … comparisons with more realistic branching methods."

Random-prefix sharing measures the cost of sharing itself, and the rules practical systems use did not offset it: in their main configurations, EPTree, Fork-Think and a confidence trigger never covered significantly more problems than independent sampling. Every fork in tree decoding continues a prefix the model generated; a rule decides where to fork and which prefixes to keep. For a single fork, Corollary 1 splits the rule's coverage into the cost of sharing the chosen prefix and the gain from choosing it; random-prefix sharing measures that cost for prefixes the policy samples, and TreeRL uses random fork positions as its own control. Section 7 measures the rest, including two-level trees, which lie outside Corollary 1.

We reimplemented the branch rules of TreeRL's EPTree and Fork-Think (both fork rules) and a confidence-triggered fork under one decoding policy, every generated token charged, against independent sampling at the same expected tokens:

Independent − rule coverage (pp)Qwen3-8B, 32K, competitionQwen3.5-35B-A3B-Base, GSM8K
EPTree, forking tokens, (4,2,1,2) / (4,1,1,8)+0.6 / +2.6+1.4 / +1.4
EPTree, random positions (TreeRL's control)+0.3 / +2.6+1.6 / +0.7
EPTree, tree by tree, (4,2,1,2) / (4,1,1,8)+0.7 / +4.2+9.2 [6.6, 11.9] / +13.6 [10.4, 16.8]
EPTree, second iteration (4,2,2,2), tree by tree+3.3† [0.1, 7.2]+11.0 [8.3, 13.9]
Confidence trigger, 1×8+3.2+12.0
Fork-Think, log-prob / entropy (n=32)+4.2 / +1.1+16.9 / +6.1
Fork-Think, majority vote−0.0 to +2.2 (both rules, n=16 and 32)+12.7 (main rule)

Positive favors independent sampling; bold: 95% interval excludes zero; †: not significant after Holm's adjustment. Intervals: General Response 1/3 and Appendix Table 18. Tree by tree, independent coverage is 85–95%.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 8cu4 (2/4)

Summary, and realistic branching methods (W1, Q1) (continued)

  • Where early tokens decide the outcome (35B on GSM8K), independent sampling leads every main rule comparison; in long reasoning (32K), every main rule comparison and every allocation at the expected budget lies within error of independent sampling. Our criterion and Corollary 1 account for both.
  • Choosing the point by uncertainty barely changes what the branches inherit. Continuations from the first forking token of each path succeed about as often as independent samples (+0.8 pp on Qwen3-8B, −1.5 pp on Qwen3.5-35B-A3B, both within error); tree by tree, forking tokens cover 2.2–3.1 pp more than random positions on Qwen3.5-35B-A3B (one of four estimates significant before adjustment) and 0.6–2.2 pp less on Qwen3-8B. A rule that decides from the tokens generated so far, such as the trigger, branches at a stopping time, where Theorem 2 applies directly.
  • When a rule changes the prefix, the branches inherit it. Fork-Think's greedy seed leaves 24 of 128 questions with none of 32 continuations succeeding, where independent sampling with the same tokens is expected to solve 22.6 of them. Without seeds that reached the allowance, independent sampling still leads by 17.9 and 6.9 pp.

What each comparison tests. TreeRL is a training method; its training configuration (6,2,1,2) forks once, as our (4,2,1,2) does, and we test the inference-time coverage of that rule; Appendix M relates it to training. Fork-Think claims token savings at equal majority-vote accuracy; its seed is cut at 2,048 tokens as in its own Table 1 on Qwen3-8B, with continuations in the seed's assistant turn where its released code opens a new one (Appendix E.2), and the majority-vote row is that comparison: within error on Qwen3-8B, 12.7 pp for independent sampling on Qwen3.5-35B-A3B. All of this is in Section 7, Figure 6 and Appendix E.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 8cu4 (3/4)

The 8K limit of the thinking model (W3)

W3. "Around half of the reasoning traces do not finish within [8K] … This makes it difficult to tell whether the observed early prediction of success actually reflects reasoning quality."

At 8K the outcome is largely whether a trace concludes in time, as Section 4 states, and the criterion needs nothing more: whatever decides success, prefixes that fix it faster than they consume generation make sharing lose. We measured it directly, on the same model and questions at 32K: the excess of ρ\rho over ss falls from 0.07–0.11 to 0.02–0.06, within error at every position, and sharing gains significantly at no position.

Qwen3.5-2B thinking, 64 GSM8K questions, same prefixes8K: ρ\rho / ss8K: Indep. − shared 1×8 (pp)32K: ρ\rho / ss32K: Indep. − shared 1×8 (pp)
5% of the 8K median length0.17 / 0.06+11.6 [7.7, 15.9]0.05 / 0.03+2.1 [−2.7, 6.9]
20%0.33 / 0.22+14.3 [9.1, 19.5]0.16 / 0.13+4.0 [−1.5, 9.6]
40%0.48 / 0.41+15.4 [9.7, 21.2]0.31 / 0.25+6.3 [−0.3, 13.0]
Samples reaching the allowance48.7%3.1%

Same model, prompts, sampling and prefix lengths in tokens; the allowance changes, and the 32K run draws 8 continuations per prefix (32 at 8K) and 16 independent samples per question (80). ss is lower at 32K because the same prefixes are a smaller share of longer samples (9,800 tokens on average at 32K against 5,980 at 8K). pass@1 rises from 0.51 to 0.69; traces concluding after 8K tokens are correct in 39% of cases, and 51 of the 64 questions remain at 10–90% success. Bold: interval excludes zero.

  • ρ−s\rho - s is 0.11, 0.11, 0.07 at 8K and 0.02, 0.03, 0.06 at 32K, where every interval of ρ\rho contains ss: once the allowance no longer binds, this model's profile lies on the line, as in the other 32K runs.
  • The remaining differences still point toward independent sampling (2.1–6.3 pp, within error).

A stronger model on harder problems shows the same. Qwen3-8B with a 32,768-token allowance on 63 competition problems (screened to have at most one of eight screening samples truncated; Appendix E.1): samples average 18,900 tokens, and only 5.2% reach the allowance. The planned Qwen3.5-9B could not serve: 48% of its screening samples reached even 32K tokens (Appendix D).

Branch positionρ\rhossIndep. − shared 1×8 (pp)
5% of median length0.07 [0.01, 0.14]0.05+1.3 [−2.4, 6.0]
20%0.19 [0.08, 0.30]0.19+2.4 [−2.3, 7.4]
40%0.44 [0.30, 0.62]0.38+5.7 [−0.2, 12.2]
  • No significant gain and no significant loss at the expected budget; the rules' intervals, majority voting included, likewise exclude a gain above 5.8 pp. All nine allocations (1×8, 2×4, 4×2) favor independent sampling, none significantly; the intervals exclude a sharing gain above 2.4, 3.5 and 4.2 pp; the two-candidate estimates, which favor sharing by 0.6–2.6 pp, lie within error, as ρ\rho close to ss predicts. Under a hard per-question budget, 1×8 at 40% favors independent sampling by +5.7 [0.2, 11.7] (unadjusted).
  • Real cost then favors independent sampling further: measured on vLLM, a shared token saves only 0.30–0.89 of an average generated token's GPU time (General Response 3/3).

Section 4 now reports the 32K run next to the 8K one (Appendix E.1, Table 17); Appendix E.8 compares the same model at 8K and 32K, and the Introduction, Section 2, Figure 2 and Table 1 now mark the 8K results as allowance-bound.

Reviewer_FBroOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies whether sharing a sampled reasoning prefix can improve the efficiency of LLM reasoning under the same token budget. The authors propose a theoretical criterion based on two factors: the saved generation cost and the explained success variance. The paper shows that sharing a prefix is beneficial for two candidates when the saved cost is larger than the lost diversity. The authors also extend the analysis to more candidates and conduct experiments on several language models and mathematical reasoning tasks. The results show that independent sampling usually achieves better coverage than shared-prefix sampling under the same token budget.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper studies an interesting and important problem in LLM reasoning. The trade-off between computation cost and reasoning diversity is worth investigating.

  2. The theoretical analysis is relatively complete. The proposed criterion provides a clear explanation of when prefix sharing is useful.

  3. The experiments cover different model sizes and several mathematical reasoning datasets. The results are consistent with the theoretical analysis.

  4. The paper is generally well organized, and the main findings are clearly presented.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited evaluation tasks. Most experiments focus on mathematical reasoning, especially GSM8K. It is unclear whether the conclusions can generalize to other reasoning tasks, such as code generation, planning, and agent-based tasks. More experiments on different tasks would make the conclusions stronger.

  2. Limited consideration of practical inference cost. The paper mainly uses the number of generated tokens to measure computation cost. However, the actual inference efficiency also depends on KV-cache reuse, memory consumption, and hardware execution. Sharing a prefix may provide additional efficiency benefits in real inference systems. Therefore, the conclusion based on token budget may not fully reflect the practical trade-off.

  3. Limited comparison with adaptive methods. The theoretical analysis mainly considers sampled prefixes and predefined branching strategies. However, many existing reasoning methods use adaptive branching, prefix selection, or verification mechanisms. It would be useful to investigate whether the conclusions still hold in these practical settings.

  4. Limited practical guidance. Although the proposed criterion is theoretically interesting, estimating the success variance requires multiple continuations. The paper does not fully demonstrate how this criterion can be efficiently used to guide reasoning during inference. A practical strategy based on the proposed criterion would further improve the contribution.

Questions for authors
  1. Can the authors provide more experiments on non-mathematical reasoning tasks, such as code generation or planning?

  2. How would the conclusions change if actual inference latency or GPU memory cost is considered instead of only generated tokens?

  3. Can the proposed criterion be used to dynamically select the branching position without requiring many additional samples?

5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer FBro (1/4)

Summary, and tasks beyond mathematics (Q1, W1)

Thank you for the positive assessment and for three concrete questions. Each led to a new measurement that makes the paper more useful to practitioners, and each supports the criterion: from 16 tokens on, code follows the same pattern as mathematics; measured GPU time favors independent sampling more than token counts do; and a 32-problem pilot reproduces the full-data decision in 87.5% of draws:

Your questionWhat we didResult
Q1/W1: non-mathematical tasksMBPP code generation, 202 problems, graded by unit testsfrom 16 tokens on, code follows the same pattern as mathematics
Q2/W2: real latency and memoryGPU time and KV cache on vLLM with prefix caching, 32K-token reasoning, eight problemsa shared token saves only 0.30–0.89 of an average generated token's GPU time, so real cost strengthens the conclusion; sharing saves 21–49% of peak KV cache
Q3/W4: choosing where to branch cheaplypilot-size analysis; a positive control where sharing should paya 32-problem pilot reproduces the full-data decision in 87.5% of draws and detects the positive control in 64–100%
W3: adaptive methodsEPTree, a confidence trigger, Fork-Think at an equal budgetno main configuration covers significantly more than independent sampling
Presentationrewrote the passages with nested comparisons; Table 2 maps every measurement to its resultslisted under W3 below

Q1. "Can the authors provide more experiments on non-mathematical reasoning tasks, such as code generation or planning?"

We ran code generation; from 16 tokens on, code follows the same pattern as mathematics. Qwen3.5-35B-A3B-Base writes MBPP programs from the standard three-shot prompt; 202 of 500 test problems have 2–6 correct of 8 screening samples and enter, each with 48 independent samples and four source paths continued 16 times.

Position (tokens)48163264
ρ\rho0.050.130.410.760.96
ss0.080.150.300.570.86
Indep. − shared, 1×8 (pp)+1.0+2.8+12.0+17.3+8.0
Indep. − shared, two candidates (pp)−2.1†−2.3†+2.0+1.7−0.5

Bold: 95% interval excludes zero; †: not significant after Holm's adjustment over the five positions.

  • From 16 tokens on, ρ\rho lies significantly above ss, and independent sampling covers 8.0–17.3 pp more than one prefix with eight continuations.
  • At four tokens, which import modules or name the function the tests call, ρ\rho lies significantly below ss, so the criterion allows sharing there, and two shared candidates lead by 2.1 pp [0.6, 3.7], not significant after Holm's adjustment. Proposition 1 predicts 0.5 pp at equal pass@1; here the source paths drew 1.7 pp above the independent bank, within error, and continuations, which track them, succeed 0.9 pp more often than independent samples; this accounts for 1.2 pp of the difference (Appendix E.5). Programs average 62 tokens, and by 64 tokens 69% of source paths have ended.
  • Planning tasks need only a verifier of the final plan, so the estimators of ρ\rho and ss carry over directly to plans checked by a validator; agent tasks also need the environment restored at the branch point.

Within reasoning, the revision also adds competition problems with up to 32K-token reasoning (Section 4, Appendix E.1), where sharing again gave no significant gain at an equal budget. Appendix E.5 reports the code run.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer FBro (2/4)

Real inference cost (Q2, W2)

Q2. "How would the conclusions change if actual inference latency or GPU memory cost is considered instead of only generated tokens?"

We measured it in three serving settings, and in each, real cost strengthens the conclusion: pooled over eight problems, a shared token saves only 0.30–0.89 of the GPU time of an average generated token, so sharing is further from paying in GPU time than in tokens. Sharing does cut peak KV-cache memory, by 21–49%.

Setup (Appendix E.6): Qwen3-8B with 32K-token reasoning on vLLM with prefix caching, prefixes at 20% and 40% of the median length. One prefix with eight continuations runs against eight independent sequences of matched lengths, so the arms differ only by seven copies of the prefix (ss = 0.17 and 0.37 on these eight problems); both alternate in one engine, shared–matched–matched–shared.

SettingGPU time saved by sharing (σ\sigma)σ/s\sigma/sPeak KV cache saved
8 sequences, one A8000.06 / 0.110.36 / 0.3021% / 40%
64 sequences, two A800s, no preemption0.11 / 0.230.62 / 0.6424% / 49%
64 sequences, one A800, KV cache full0.12 / 0.330.72 / 0.89(preempted 123 and 111 times in the independent arm, 101 and 0 in the shared arm)

20% / 40% position. σ/s\sigma/s: GPU time a shared token saves relative to an average generated token.

  • Every ratio lies below one, also when memory is short. With GPU time as the cost, the criterion becomes ρ<σ\rho < \sigma with σ<s\sigma < s, stricter than with tokens, so our token-based comparisons, if anything, understate the lead of independent sampling.
  • The two-candidate criterion holds for any additive cost (Section 3): sharing pays only if a shared token saves at least ρ/s\rho/s times the cost of a generated token, a factor of 1.8–3.5 at eight tokens in our four-prefix GSM8K measurements.
  • Latency. A shared candidate's prefix must be generated before its continuation starts, so its sequential length equals that of a complete sample; with the same tokens, independent samples need no more sequential decoding steps.

The cost argument is in Section 3 of the revision, and the GPU measurements in Appendix E.6.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer FBro (3/4)

Choosing the branch position cheaply (Q3, W4)

Q3. "Can the proposed criterion be used to dynamically select the branching position without requiring many additional samples?"

Per problem and on the fly, no: estimating ρq\rho_q for one problem needs many continuations of it, so the criterion is estimated over problems, once per task, from a small pilot. Within a path, locating a branch point needs no samples.

  • Locating a branch point: the confidence trigger of Section 7 forks at the first low-confidence token of the path being generated. The criterion says what to expect from it: at the trigger, ρ(τ)/s(τ)\rho(\tau)/s(\tau) is 1.22 [0.97, 1.49] on Qwen3.5-35B-A3B and 0.84 [0.51, 1.22] on Qwen3-8B, and independent sampling covers 12.0 and 3.2 pp more at an equal budget.
  • Deciding whether to share, from subsampled pilots (Appendix E.3):
Pilot of 32 problemsResult
Reproduces the full-data decision (our positions, all "do not share")87.5% of pilots (94.3% with 64)
Expected coverage cost of the decision1.5 pp, against 11.4 pp for always sharing
Decides to share when ρ=0\rho = 0 / ρ=s/2\rho = s/2 (Beta model, s=0.2s = 0.2)99.9% / 90.7% of draws
Decides to share in the measured positive control (restatement), five positions74–100% (OLMo-3-7B: 64–100%); 100% of 2,000 at the end of the restatement

Each pilot problem costs about 22.5 complete samples at one position, mostly 16 independent samples that also serve as candidates. Pilot errors fall near the line, where the two-candidate stakes are below 1 pp. In the positive control, two shared candidates do cover 5.1 [4.2, 6.2] pp more, against 5.3 predicted by Proposition 1 (General Response 2/3).

W4. "The paper does not fully demonstrate how this criterion can be efficiently used to guide reasoning during inference."

With the standard prompts of our mathematical runs, the procedure says to sample independently; it says to share only where a pilot finds ρ<s\rho < s, as in the restatement control. The procedure (Appendices E.3 and E.4):

  1. On 32–64 pilot problems, draw 16 independent samples and continue one stored prefix eight times at each candidate position; estimate ρ(m)\rho(m) and s(m)s(m).
  2. Share only where ρ(m)<s(m)\rho(m) < s(m) (on each problem, Theorem 2 makes this necessary). Proposition 1 prices pairs, so give one prefix more continuations only where the pilot's eight continuations show that this covers more than independent sampling at the same tokens.
  3. Assess any rule that selects prefixes with fresh continuations, and charge the cost of selection (Corollary 1, Section 7).

In MBPP it allows pairs at four and eight tokens, and there two shared candidates cover 2.1 and 2.3 pp more (95% intervals excluding zero, not significant after Holm's adjustment), above the Proposition 1 prediction mostly because the source draws ran 1.7 pp above the bank (Appendix E.5). The two places where the criterion allows sharing read alike: the shared tokens are ones the task largely fixes (the restated question; the imports and function name of an MBPP program), so they explain little of the success variance while still counting as generation.

Comments on the paper

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General Response (1/3): summary, and the branch rules of practical systems

We thank all three reviewers for careful and constructive reviews, whose requests led to new measurements that make the paper stronger. No new comparison contradicts the criterion of the submission: sharing a sampled prefix under a preset allocation gained significantly only where ρ≤s\rho \le s: in a positive control, by the margin Proposition 1 predicts, and, before Holm's adjustment, in the opening tokens of MBPP programs. In mathematical reasoning under standard prompts, no sampled prefix and no main configuration of the branch rules of Section 7 gained significantly. Harder problems with long reasoning, the test the submission named as next, behave as the criterion implies: ρ\rho matches ss within error and no allocation of shared candidates gains significantly.

Request (reviewers)New measurementResultRevision
Do the branch rules of practical systems gain? (4MoD Q1, 8cu4 W1/Q1, FBro W3)EPTree (TreeRL) with its random control, a confidence trigger, Fork-Think; two modelsNo main configuration covers significantly more than independent sampling, which leads all 12 main comparisons, significantly in 3Sec. 7, App. E.2
Long reasoning where the allowance barely binds (4MoD W2, 8cu4 W2/W3)Qwen3-8B, 32K tokens, 63 competition problems, 5.2% truncatedρ\rho matches ss within error; no difference significant at the expected budget; for eight candidates a sharing gain above 2.4–4.2 pp is excludedSecs. 2, 4, App. E.1
Non-Qwen models (4MoD W2, 8cu4 W2)three 2026 thinking models (Google, Zhipu AI, NVIDIA), 32Kas for Qwen3-8B, in all threeSec. 4, App. E.7
Does the criterion ever say "share"?positive control: prompts whose first tokens restate the questiontwo shared candidates +5.1 [4.2, 6.2] pp, Proposition 1 predicts +5.3Sec. 4, App. E.4
Tasks beyond mathematics (FBro Q1)MBPP code, 202 problemssame pattern as mathematics from 16 tokens onSec. 4, App. E.5
Real inference cost (FBro Q2)GPU time and memory on vLLM with prefix caching, eight problemsa shared token saves only 0.30–0.89 of a generated token's GPU time; 21–49% less peak KV cacheSec. 3, App. E.6
Lower pass@1 of shared continuations (4MoD Q2/W3)decomposition and three boundswithin error in each setting; in the base models it sits mostly in the source draws; far too small for the coverage gapsSec. 2, App. C

Branch rules at an equal budget. One decoding policy; every generated token charged, seeds included; same expected tokens for both arms.

Independent − rule coverage (pp)Qwen3-8B, 32K, competitionQwen3.5-35B-A3B-Base, GSM8K
EPTree (4,2,1,2)+0.6 [−4.2, 5.8]+1.4 [−0.1, 3.5]
EPTree (4,1,1,8)+2.6 [−3.2, 8.6]+1.4 [−0.2, 3.8]
Confidence trigger, 1×8+3.2 [−1.4, 8.0]+12.0 [8.8, 15.4]
Fork-Think, log-prob, n=32+4.2 [−0.0, 9.5]+16.9 [10.7, 23.4]
Fork-Think, entropy, n=32+1.1 [−4.2, 6.4]+6.1 [2.3, 10.7]
Control: random positions (4,2,1,2) / (4,1,1,8)+0.3 / +2.6+1.6 / +0.7

Positive favors independent sampling; 95% paired bootstrap intervals; bold: 95% interval excludes zero and Holm-adjusted p < 0.05. Fork-Think's greedy seed is cut at 2,048 tokens on Qwen3-8B, as in its Table 1; n=16 there: +3.9 and +2.1.

  • No main configuration gains significantly. Independent sampling led all 12 main comparisons (the table and the two n=16 rows) and all 4 random controls; with 32K-token reasoning every main interval contains zero. In majority vote, Fork-Think's own metric, independent sampling matches it within error on Qwen3-8B and leads its main rule by 12.7 pp on Qwen3.5-35B-A3B.
  • Choosing the point by uncertainty gained little over a random point. Continuations from the first forking token of each path succeed as often as independent samples, within error (+0.8, −1.5 pp). Tree by tree, forking tokens cover 2.2–3.1 pp more than random positions on Qwen3.5-35B-A3B (one of four significant before adjustment) and 0.6–2.2 pp less on Qwen3-8B, while independent sampling leads EPTree by 9.2 [6.6, 11.9] and 13.6 pp on Qwen3.5-35B-A3B. Tree by tree, a second iteration (4,2,2,2), which TreeRL's code supports, does not help EPTree: independent sampling leads by 11.0 [8.3, 13.9] pp there and 3.3 [0.1, 7.2] pp on Qwen3-8B (Holm-adjusted p = 0.13).
  • A greedy seed passes one path to all branches. On Qwen3.5-35B-A3B, on 24 of 128 questions none of Fork-Think's 32 continuations succeeds, where independent sampling at equal cost is expected to solve 22.6. This base model lacks Fork-Think's reasoning mode and 44% of its greedy seeds reach the allowance; on the 72 questions whose seed ended earlier, independent sampling still leads by 17.9 [8.8, 27.5] and 6.9 [1.3, 13.8] pp.
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General Response (2/3): long reasoning, and where sharing pays

Long reasoning (4MoD W2, 8cu4 W2/W3). Qwen3-8B in its reasoning mode, 32,768-token allowance, 63 integer-answer competition problems (MathArena). Samples average 18,900 tokens and only 5.2% reach the allowance.

Branch position (mean tokens)ρ\rhossIndep. − shared, 1×8 (pp)
5% (912)0.07 [0.01, 0.14]0.05+1.3 [−2.4, 6.0]
20% (3,647)0.19 [0.08, 0.30]0.19+2.4 [−2.3, 7.4]
40% (7,294)0.44 [0.30, 0.62]0.38+5.7 [−0.2, 12.2]

Here ρ\rho matches ss within error, and sharing gained no significant coverage at the expected budget. All nine allocations (1×8, 2×4, 4×2 at three positions) favor independent sampling, none significantly; the intervals exclude a sharing gain larger than 2.4, 3.5 and 4.2 pp for 1×8, 2×4 and 4×2. Under a hard per-question budget, 1×8 at 40% favors independent sampling by +5.7 [0.2, 11.7] before adjustment. After four failed continuations at 20%, a restart succeeds in 21.8% of attempts and a further continuation in 10.6% (+11.3 [3.3, 21.2] pp), as in Section 5 (Appendix E.1).

The same holds outside the Qwen family (Appendix E.7). Same protocol, three thinking models released in 2026 by Google, Zhipu AI and NVIDIA:

Modelρ\rho at 5 / 20 / 40%ssIndep. − shared, 1×8 (pp)Sharing gain excluded above
Gemma-4-26B-A4B-it (Google)0.04 / 0.18 / 0.400.05 / 0.20 / 0.39+0.3 / +1.4 / +1.94.3 pp
GLM-4.7-Flash (Zhipu AI)0.06 / 0.23 / 0.380.04 / 0.19 / 0.41+0.9 / +2.3 / +0.75.3 pp
Nemotron-3.5-Lightning-30B-A3B (NVIDIA)0.08 / 0.21 / 0.430.05 / 0.18 / 0.37+1.7 / +0.8 / +3.44.3 pp

Every interval of ρ\rho contains ss; none of the 27 allocation comparisons is significant after Holm's adjustment. Last column: largest over the three positions; pooled by problem over Qwen3-8B and the three new models, as planned, sharing gains above 0.9 pp are excluded at every position. Branch rules on all three (per model: EPTree in two configurations, the confidence trigger, Fork-Think's two rules): independent sampling leads 13 of 15 main comparisons, none significantly, and EPTree's random-position controls agree; after four failed continuations a restart succeeds more often than a further continuation in every model.

Same model at 8K and 32K (Appendix E.8). The Qwen3.5-2B thinking model on 64 of its GSM8K questions with 32,768 tokens: truncation falls from 48.7% to 3.1%, ρ−s\rho - s from 0.11, 0.11 and 0.07 to 0.02, 0.03 and 0.06, and independent sampling's 1×8 lead from 11.6–15.4 pp to 2.1–6.3 pp, within error; every interval of ρ\rho then contains ss (table in our reply to 8cu4).

The criterion also finds where sharing pays. Sharing a sampled prefix never gained significantly in the settings of the submission, so a rule that never shares would also have passed. We therefore built a positive control: the same Qwen3.5-35B-A3B and 128 GSM8K questions, with worked examples whose answers first restate the question (copied in 99.9% of samples), so these tokens resolve almost no success variance.

PositionOriginal prompt: ρ\rho / ssTwo shared − independent at equal tokens (pp)Restating prompt: ρ\rho / ssTwo shared − independent at equal tokens (pp), predicted by Prop. 1
16 tokens0.24 / 0.11−3.30.00 / 0.08+1.7, predicted +1.4
48 tokens0.48 / 0.33−4.50.02 / 0.23+3.8, predicted +3.6
end of restatement (68 tokens on average)0.00 / 0.31+5.1 [4.2, 6.2], predicted +5.3

Bold: 95% interval excludes zero (restating prompt: after Holm's adjustment over its five positions).

  • One change of prompt reverses the sign at the same positions, and Proposition 1 predicts the size of the gain. OLMo-3-7B agrees: at the end of its restatement ρ\rho is 0.00 against ss of 0.39, and two shared candidates gain 7.5 [6.4, 8.7] pp, against 7.5 predicted.
  • Proposition 1 prices pairs. One prefix with eight continuations gains 1.5 [0.7, 2.5] pp at the end of the restatement; 48 tokens later, where ρ\rho (0.44) is still below ss (0.54), four prefixes with two continuations each still gain 1.5 pp but one prefix with eight loses 6.5 pp, so larger groups are checked on the pilot's continuations.
  • A 32-problem pilot detects it, deciding to share in 74–100% of draws at the five positions and in all 2,000 at the end of the restatement. The control is built to test the criterion's prediction (Appendix E.4).
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General Response (3/3): real inference cost, and the changes in the revision

Real inference cost (FBro Q2/W2). Proposition 1 holds for any additive cost: sharing pays only if a shared token saves at least ρ/s\rho/s times the cost of a generated token. We measured that saving on vLLM with prefix caching (Qwen3-8B, 32K-token reasoning, eight problems, Appendix E.6):

SettingGPU time a shared token saves, relative to an average generated tokenPeak KV cache saved by sharing
8 sequences, one A8000.30–0.3621–40%
64 sequences, two A800s0.62–0.6424–49%
64 sequences, one A800, KV cache full (preempted 111–123 times in the independent arm, 0–101 in the shared arm)0.72–0.89

Every ratio is below one, so token accounting credits sharing with more than it saves, and in this long-reasoning setting the measured leads of independent sampling are, if anything, understated. Sharing does lower peak memory.

Changes in the revision (main text within 10 pages):

  • Section 7 (new), Figure 6: branch rules of tree search and parallel reasoning at an equal budget.
  • Sections 2 and 4: long reasoning on competition problems; the decomposition of the pass@1 of shared continuations (with Appendix C); the positive control; MBPP code; three non-Qwen thinking models from 2026.
  • Section 3: the cost condition, with the GPU measurements.
  • Abstract, Introduction, Conclusion: the abstract now states the three regimes the criterion predicts (ρ>s\rho>s with worked examples on GSM8K, ρ≈s\rho\approx s with 32K-token reasoning with the equivalence bounds, ρ<s\rho<s under restating prompts); the Introduction's second finding now states the resolution result for both regimes (in the base models' four-prefix GSM8K measurements the first eight tokens resolve success variance 1.8 to 3.5 times as fast as they consume generation; with 32K-token reasoning ρ\rho stays at ss within error), and the Conclusion states how a 32-problem pilot applies the criterion.
  • Appendix E (new): setups, estimates with intervals and adjusted p-values (Tables 17, 18), rule costs, tree-by-tree comparisons and a second EPTree iteration (E.1, E.2), pilot size (E.3), restatement controls (E.4), MBPP (E.5), GPU time and memory (E.6), non-Qwen thinking models (E.7), the 2B thinking model at 8K and 32K (E.8). Table 2 maps every measurement to the results it supports and marks which ones an analysis plan fixed before sampling covers.

We answer each reviewer's points individually below.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.