- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The authors uncover a widespread failure mode in PPG-to-ABP models that they term "normality bias", which is driven by training data imbalances that skew predictions towards normotensive values. To evaluate this phenomenon, the authors develop NBI and TailBias as robust scalar diagnostics. Their proposed solution, OPLR, imposes an ordered geometric structure on the latent space (Low < Normal < High) to decouple rare regimes from the dominant normal mode before decoding. Experimental results confirm that OPLR surpasses standard fixes and delivers impressive performance.
Critical strengths
- Mean tracking is a rampant issue in noninvasive blood pressure monitoring work, so it is good to see the authors addressing this issue head-on. I especially like the proposed metrics (Normality Bias Index and TailBias); I would consider using them in my own research.
- The construction of the objective function is clear and intuitive
- The appendix is almost entirely comprehensive, covering deeper ablations and the sensitivity of various hyperparameters in the method. The appendix also provides further evidence demonstrating the benefit of the proposed approach (e.g., Figures 4 and 5)
Critical weaknesses
- As the authors already note, their external validation sets are modest in comparison to their training sets: 30 subjects from MIMIC-IV and 4 subjects from the Queensland dataset after preprocessing. However, this supplements the subject-wise calibration-free cross-validation they performed on PulseDB, which itself is a mixture of MIMIC-III and VitalDB.
- Close inspection of Figure 4 reveals that OPLR slightly prioritizes the Low prototype when the true SBP is just above the hypotensive boundary (90-93 mmHg). Although the difference in routing probabilities is slight and the smoothness of the routing probabilities is ideal for regression, this could hint at a bias towards false alarms for hypotension. One could argue that smoothness actually complicates predictions at the boundaries, whereas stronger routing could pull samples towards the correct prototype for the sake of improved alarm delivery. Therefore, while I agree that regression is the right approach to noninvasive blood pressure monitoring, I would like to see some classification metrics as well (i.e., thresholding the continuous outputs, not retraining a classification head).
Questions for authors
- In Table 11, the width of the Medium regime always remains 50 mmHg. Thus, it is always ~4x the size of the other two classes combined. Is there a reason not to try a configuration with closer boundaries (e.g., 40 mmHg apart)? As far as I understand, OPLR is not beholden to a specific degree of class imbalance, and the boundaries could be adjusted slightly while preserving clinical utility. I would just be curious to see how increasing the representation of Low and High cases relative to the Medium regime changes performance.
- Section A.4 states, "The requirements for OPLR are an ordered target variable, a heavy-tailed distribution whose extremes are the cases that matter, and a sequence output whose local morphology must be preserved. Other physiological waveform tasks meet all three." I’m trying to think of when this is actually true. For blood chemistry quantities like glucose, detecting that they fall within a range is important, but the morphology of the signal is not. For physiological waveforms like ECG, morphology matters, but extreme values do not hold special meaning. Could the authors offer some examples in the Appendix?
3 comments
Thank you for the responses to my queries. I remain positive in my assessment of this paper
Dear Reviewer FZvH,
Thank you for your time and your constructive suggestions; they made the paper stronger. We appreciate your support.
Best regards, The authors
Thank you for the careful reading. Page numbers refer to the revised PDF.
W1. External cohorts. Revision: Section 8, "External evidence" (p. 10).
Agreed. Limitations keeps the cohort-size and external-validation qualifications and now states that evaluation in additional independent cohorts remains necessary.
W2. Boundary alarms and classification metrics. Revision: new Appendix L and Table 14 (pp. 29–30); Section 8, "Residual hypotensive bias" (p. 10); Figure 4 caption (p. 21).
As you suggested, we thresholded the continuous outputs, with no classifier retrained and no threshold tuned: SBP from each reconstructed waveform and the reference SBP are both thresholded at 90 mmHg (91,834 PulseDB test segments with a valid SBP for all models).
For reference SBP in [90, 93) mmHg, the interval you raised, OPLR produces 10 false Low alarms among 1,915 segments (0.52%); the lowest count among the baselines is 11. The slight Low-prototype preference in Figure 4 therefore does not produce more false alarms, and the Figure 4 caption now notes that routing probabilities are latent preferences that do not themselves define alarms. OPLR has the highest sensitivity, F1, and AUROC, but sensitivity at the fixed threshold is at most 3.3% for all six models, which Limitations now states. For hypertension (>140 mmHg), AUROC is 0.782 for OPLR against 0.756 for the best baseline.
On stronger routing: routing is soft by design. The routing log-prior is clamped from below and the token update is residual, so a misrouted segment receives an additive correction instead of having its content replaced (Section 4, "Prototypes → Tokens", p. 6). Sharper routing would raise the cost of a wrong route where the regime is most uncertain, near 90 and 140 mmHg. We did not train a sharper-routing variant, so this is a design rationale, not an empirical comparison.
Q1. A 40-mmHg Normal interval. Revision: Table 11, blocks "40-mmHg normotensive interval" and "Retrained with 95/135 mmHg anchors" (p. 27); Appendix I, last two paragraphs (p. 26).
The default boundaries are clinical anchors for hypotension and hypertension. We added three 40-mmHg intervals and a model retrained with narrower anchors.
The first four rows re-partition fixed predictions: moving a boundary inward lowers that regime's error, as the group admits more near-normal segments. The last row is OPLR retrained with 95 and 135 mmHg as the training anchors (training proportions 6.4% / 70.4% / 23.2% for Low / Normal / High) and evaluated at those boundaries. At the same >135 / <95 boundaries, retraining lowers Low RMSE from 12.07 to 8.89 and High RMSE from 13.69 to 13.23, so OPLR benefits when the tails are better represented in training.
Q2. Other tasks. Revision: Appendix A.4 (p. 16).
We agree that the original statement was too broad and have narrowed it. As usually formulated, glucose and ECG tasks do not meet all three requirements, for the reasons you give. A task that plausibly does is intracranial-pressure waveform reconstruction from paired physiological signals (Megjhani et al., 2023): pressure is ordered, elevated pressure is the clinically decisive range, and pulse morphology is informative. Whether its extremes are underrepresented depends on the cohort; we validate only PPG-to-ABP.