- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduce MSMA-PPG, a framework that learns from synchronized multi-wavelength recordings and predicts from one selected PPG stream and acceleration. It combines wavelength-specific adapters, full-to-subset alignment, and availability-masked expert routing. Experiments show competitive optical representation transfer and predictor-dependent wavelength selection, yet cross-view alignment does not improve adapted heart-rate prediction over reconstruction-only training.
Critical strengths
- The paper studies a practical scenario. It uses abundant multi-wavelength data for training, while only limited input signals are available during inference.
- The proposed MSMA-PPG learns optical representations. It obtains competitive results on heart rate, blood pressure and atrial fibrillation prediction tasks.
- The paper uses matched time window diagnostics. These help separate predictor-dependent wavelength selection effects from impacts of the trained expert configuration.
Critical weaknesses
- The methodological and empirical advances need clearer positioning. The framework integrates existing techniques, including channel-specific adaptation, cross-view alignment, and sparse expert routing. The experiments are informative. However, the paper fails to clearly state its new methodological insights, beyond the observed model-dependent wavelength preferences and expert dependencies.
- The source of the optical representation gains remains unclear. The paper does not include proper ablation studies to separate the effects of paired alignment and wavelength-specific processing under the same PPG-only evaluation setup. Without such ablations, we cannot verify whether these core designs bring advantages over a simpler reconstruction-pretrained encoder.
- The architectural value of the complete routed predictor is insufficiently established. Most external baselines test representations with routing turned off, under the PPG-only setting. The full system using selected PPG and ACC only compares against its reconstruction-only version. Controlled comparisons against fully trained simple fusion methods are required to show the benefit of CA-MoE. Without these experiments, the architectural contribution is hard to justify.
Questions for authors
- To evaluate whether CA-MoE is necessary, can you include comparisons with simple fusion baselines? All compared models take selected PPG and ACC as input. They should be trained independently, with consistent initialization, data splits and comparable training resources, instead of relying only on interventions applied to the pre-trained model. If such results are already available, please provide them.
- Can you run ablation studies under the same PPG-only evaluation setup from Table 1? Maintain consistent training data and other settings. These ablations should examine whether paired alignment and wavelength-specific processing bring independent gains to the reported representation transfer performance.
- Please provide participant‑level and sample counts for the train, validation, and test splits of each prediction task. It would help to explicitly distinguish between the full original dataset, the cohorts used for Table 1, and those used in the paired HR experiments. Please also clarify how data was partitioned at participant level.
6 comments
Matched Fusion Comparison, Optical Ablation Scope, and Data Splits
Our design uses synchronized optical views to supervise the structure that is predictable from one supplied waveform, while keeping wavelength identity available to the prediction module. The full view is used during training; at inference, experts are eligible only when supported by the supplied PPG and optional ACC. With green PPG + ACC fixed on EarSet and the backbone frozen, switching from the affine head to CA-MoE moves the alignment contrast from −0.758 to +0.057 bpm (Table 17). This shows why frozen affine-probe gains should be checked with the intended prediction module.
1. Independently trained fusion baseline. Table 3 adds a concatenation MLP trained independently of CA-MoE. Both receive the same available features, use the same participant split and task loss, and run for 5,000 EarSet adaptation updates. Within each alignment setting, they start from the same backbone initialization. With green PPG and ACC, CA-MoE and MLP yield participant-macro HR MAEs of 4.664 and 4.909 bpm with alignment and 4.733 and 4.714 bpm without it. Aligned CA-MoE is 0.245 bpm below the aligned MLP and 0.050 bpm below the best MLP setting; without alignment, MLP has the lower MAE. All other Table 3 settings use PPG alone, where CA-MoE weights both available experts. Overall, CA-MoE shows a modest advantage when paired with alignment.
2. Alignment versus wavelength-specific processing in the frozen benchmark. In the PPG-only comparison (Table 3), we hold wavelength-specific processing fixed and toggle alignment in the adapted models. Because wavelength-specific information was already integrated during training, this experiment cannot isolate the effect of wavelength-specific processing. On EarSet with green PPG, alignment lowers CA-MoE MAE from 4.806 to 4.613 bpm, whereas it raises MLP MAE from 4.680 to 4.927 bpm. These results suggest that alignment works particularly well in combination with CA-MoE in these adapted runs, rather than providing a consistent benefit across fusion modules; Revised Table 1 compares the full routed predictor with ACC masked against pretrained baselines with frozen encoders and affine heads, alongside end-to-end ResNet1D.
3. Participant and sample counts. Within each task, every model in Table 1 uses the same participant-level training and validation split, which Table 3 also reuses. For each model and metric, we score each of three training seeds on that fixed validation split and report the mean. We split participants (patients for MIMIC) before indexing windows, and each window is 30s. The counts are in Table 15:
| Setting | Train: people / windows | Validation: people / windows |
|---|---|---|
| EarSet HR | 12 / 6,192 | 4 / 2,187 |
| WildPPG HR | 11 / 261,484 | 2 / 44,223 |
| PPG-DaLiA HR | 10 / 43,707 | 2 / 8,136 |
| MIMIC BP | 397 / 4,726,832 | 103 / 295,123 |
| MIMIC AF | 1,020 / 11,861,141 | 210 / 636,569 |
For AF, we aggregate window logits within each record before computing AUPRC and AUROC. The AF counts above are windows.
Table 14 distinguishes the source datasets from the analysis cohorts. WildPPG contains 16 participants (216 h), EarSet 30 (about 17 h), and PPG-DaLiA 15 (about 36 h). The MIMIC-III-Ext-PPG v1.1.0 release contains 6,189 patients and 6,399,754 30-second segments. Separately, the historical paired HR validation analysis in Table 2 uses 2/4/2 participants and 44,223/2,187/8,136 windows for WildPPG/EarSet/PPG-DaLiA, respectively.
My concerns have not been resolved. I still have some questions:
-
The improvement is only 0.05 bpm, which is too small. This improvement may be from the random seed you chose or the hyperparameter settings.
-
The experiments still do not separate the contribution of wavelength-specific processing.
-
Is there a test set? You only report the sample counts of the training and validation sets.
I maintain my current score.
Hi authors, I'm looking forward to discussing the paper. If my concerns are addressed, I will reconsider my score.