- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper focus on cross-domain human activity recognition using accelerometer sensors, which is a reasonable and realistic problem. To address the domain gap between training and testing data, the paper presents WearableBridge. This framework learns a feature mapping from free-living wrist data to the reference feature space with calibration data. The paper investigates three mapping approaches, including Mapper, Distillation, and MeanFlow, and reports that MeanFlow achieves the strongest performance. Experiments on PAAWS, SELFback, and CAPTURE-24 shows that the proposed framework improves cross-domain human activity recognition performance over the unadapted-reference baseline.
Critical strengths
[+] The paper studies a realistic and important cross-domain human activity recognition problem.
[+] The writing is overall clear, and the paper is easy to follow.
Critical weaknesses
[-] There is a noticeable gap between the paper’s motivation and its implementation setting. A major motivation of this work is the limited availability of high-quality reference data due to high data collection cost (sec 1, para 2). However, the main PAAWS experiments rely on a relatively large calibration dataset of 170 training participants and 43 validation participants. The bridge is trained using 200K+ paired samples (that's hundreds of hours of calibration data!). Given that these calibration dataset requires concurrent thigh recordings or laboratory reference recordings, collecting calibration data at this scale is very difficult in practical free-living deployments.
[-] There are critical concerns regarding the experimental evaluation. The most evident issue is the lack of comparisons with representative external baselines and prior SOTA methods. The evaluation mainly compares WearableBridge against internal or relatively simple training baselines. As a result, it does not establish whether WearableBridge provides a meaningful advantage over existing methods that address similar cross-domain HAR settings.
Questions for authors
-
Please clarify the reasons for limited baselines selection. The paper discusses domain adaptation, cross-position HAR, cross-modal distillation, and privileged-information learning as closely related directions, but the evaluation does not include representative external baselines from these areas. Are there technical reasons why these methods cannot be fairly adapted to the proposed setting? If not, how does WearableBridge compare against them under matched data and backbone settings?
-
Please clarify the “limited reference data” setting. A key motivation of the paper is that high-quality reference data are limited and expensive to collect. However, the main PAAWS experiments use 170 training participants and 43 validation participants, with 224,697 Thigh2Wrist training pairs or 137,299 Lab2Freeliving training pairs. Could the authors clarify what regime they consider to be “limited reference data,” and provide evidence that the method remains effective when the number of calibration participants or reference pairs is substantially reduced?
4 comments
Response to Reviewer CNjc (2/2)
2. Does the method remain effective with substantially less calibration data? (Weakness 1, Question 2)
Yes. With 40 calibration participants in total, about one fifth of the original pairs, both bridge versions beat the direct wrist classifier in all three runs of both designs.
“Limited reference data” means that reference recordings exist for a calibration subset of participants, and a calibration cohort of about 200 participants is realistic for clinical studies in our experience. The full PAAWS calibration set has 170 training and 43 validation participants, with 224,697 Thigh2Wrist or 137,299 Lab2Freeliving training pairs. The Thigh2Wrist pairs come from 113,091 ten-second thigh windows, nearly all paired with both wrists, which is about 314 hours in total and under two hours of concurrent recording per training participant. To test smaller cohorts, we ran two budgets that count validation participants and retrained every component learned from PAAWS within each. Each budget reduces the reference recordings and the wrist labels together, as a smaller calibration study would. With 32 training and 8 validation participants, each run trains on 41,662 to 43,670 Thigh2Wrist pairs or 25,868 to 26,838 Lab2Freeliving pairs. With 8 training and 2 validation participants, the counts fall to 10,192 to 11,722 and 6,018 to 7,174.
| Design | Train + validation | Direct wrist classifier | MeanFlow, classifier fixed | MeanFlow, classifier trainable |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thigh2Wrist | 8 + 2 | 52.14 ± 2.10 | 52.63 ± 3.36 | 51.73 ± 3.80 |
| Thigh2Wrist | 32 + 8 | 53.81 ± 0.76 | 56.34 ± 1.52 | 56.47 ± 1.46 |
| Lab2Freeliving | 8 + 2 | 53.64 ± 1.58 | 55.90 ± 2.98 | 56.60 ± 2.64 |
| Lab2Freeliving | 32 + 8 | 57.68 ± 0.58 | 60.37 ± 0.77 | 60.99 ± 0.83 |
With 40 participants and a trainable classifier, the gains over the direct wrist classifier are 2.66 pp [1.00, 3.67] in Thigh2Wrist and 3.30 pp [0.39, 4.39] in Lab2Freeliving, and with the classifier fixed, the Thigh2Wrist mean (56.34%) is close to the full-cohort mean (55.98%). With only 10 participants, Lab2Freeliving keeps a gain of 2.96 pp [0.58, 4.27], and in Thigh2Wrist the three methods score within one point of each other. The bridge therefore keeps its advantage with one fifth of the calibration data, and in Lab2Freeliving with one twentieth.
Metrics. Macro-F1 (%) is the mean ± SD over three runs, evaluated on the 40 held-out free-living PAAWS participants of each design with the encoder frozen. In the smaller-cohort experiments, each run also draws its own calibration participants. Gains are in percentage points (pp). The 95% CIs use 5,000 paired bootstrap resamples of the test participants, with the fitted models held fixed.
Thank you for your rebuttal. The additional results address some of my concerns, but my overall assessment remains largely unchanged. In my view, appropriate comparisons with external baselines are fundamental for an ICLR-level paper and should ideally have been included in the original submission. Meanwhile, I find the technical contribution and presentation to be below the expected standard for an ICLR paper. Overall, I will still maintain my rating.
Thank you for your thoughtful discussion
Thank you for reviewing the additional results. We agree that appropriate external comparisons are essential. Your comments motivated the additional matched experiments (results pasted below for convenience), which provide direct evidence for the method’s benefit. We will promptly incorporate the matched comparisons and clarify the method’s contribution in the revised manuscript.
| Full MeanFlow minus comparator, macro-F1 pp [95% CI] | Thigh2Wrist | Lab2Freeliving |
|---|---|---|
| Generalized distillation | +2.46 [1.62, 3.98] | +1.11 [0.25, 2.33] |
| Deep CORAL | +2.60 [1.81, 3.91] | +6.38 [0.87, 8.80] |
| Activity-only bridge | +2.768 [1.777, 4.486] | +1.694 [0.769, 3.043] |
Our technical contribution is a task-guided latent transport formulation that learns from richer reference recordings. Reference features provide useful activity cues alongside sensor-specific details that the wrist may not capture. We therefore combine reference guidance with an activity-prediction loss, training the wrist-feature map both to use the reference and to recognize activities. Once trained, the bridge requires wrist data alone. Full MeanFlow achieves higher macro-F1 than the activity-only bridge, generalized distillation, and Deep CORAL in both designs.
Our experience with public and clinical datasets has repeatedly shown us how difficult wrist-only free-living recognition remains. This difficulty, along with the intuition above, motivated our effort to use this novel approach to explain the problem through representations and develop methods with measurable benefits. Together, our results establish a concrete contribution: using thigh or lab recordings during calibration to improve free-living recognition for new participants monitored only at the wrist.
We also believe this opens a promising direction for further research: learning more effectively from complementary reference recordings during training while keeping deployment simple and wrist-only.
Response to Reviewer CNjc (1/2)
We thank the reviewer for the careful review. We aim to provide a useful method for practical applications, motivated by our own work in wearable health monitoring. The reviewer's comments prompted new experiments, and their results answer each concern directly. We would be grateful if the reviewer would consider raising the score in light of these results, which we will add to the manuscript.
1. Does WearableBridge remain strongest against external methods under matched settings? (Weakness 2, Question 1)
Yes. Under the same frozen encoder and adapter architecture, Full MeanFlow outperforms generalized distillation and Deep CORAL, representative methods from distillation, privileged-information learning, and domain adaptation, in both designs, with all four CIs above zero.
Following the reviewer's suggestion, we adapted both methods to our setting with the same data and backbone. Generalized distillation unifies knowledge distillation and privileged-information learning, and Deep CORAL is a domain adaptation method. Both follow their published objectives (generalized distillation, Deep CORAL) with trainable classifiers and loss weights selected on development data, and each has a control without its extra loss. Cross-position HAR methods adapt across body positions by aligning feature distributions (Chang et al., 2020, and Chen et al., 2019), so Deep CORAL represents this direction as well.
Against generalized distillation, Full MeanFlow improves 40 of 40 participants in Thigh2Wrist and 36 of 40 in Lab2Freeliving. The Lab2Freeliving gain over Deep CORAL comes mainly from cycling (47.21% versus 20.59% F1). Per participant, Full MeanFlow improves 17 of 40 with a mean gain of 0.025 pp, and we will report this alongside the pooled result in the revised manuscript.
WearableBridge also works on top of any frozen encoder and its classifier, foundation models included, and improves recognition with every encoder we tested. With HARNet10, self-supervised on UK Biobank wrist data, MeanFlow fitted on PAAWS raises CAPTURE-24 macro-F1 from 42.75% to 54.73% without target labels. With DeepConvLSTM, InceptionTime, and HART encoders, every bridge improves mean macro-F1 by 9.62 to 20.15 pp in Thigh2Wrist and 8.13 to 12.76 pp in Lab2Freeliving. WearableBridge therefore remains the strongest method under matched settings and adds value on top of the field's established encoders.