- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
BridgeRouter presents a clear and computationally attractive instance-level routing framework over cross-modal bridge portfolios. The paper is well written and provides strong diagnostics, with substantial gains over the validation-selected SBS on FOG and smaller gains on ISRUC. However, the practical motivation remains unclear because supervised routing requires target labels, while a simpler target-only MLP outperforms BridgeRouter on FOG. Concerns about gain supervision, cross-subject generalization, and collapsed routes further weaken the evidence. Overall, the method is promising but not yet sufficiently validated for acceptance.
Critical strengths
- The routing formulation is simple and well motivated at the algorithmic level.
2.The FOG improvement over the predefined SBS is substantial.
3.The paper is unusually transparent about negative and ambiguous results.
Critical weaknesses
-
Practical motivation limited. BridgeRouter requires target-task labels for gain supervision, weakening the original label-scarce cross-modal transfer motivation. Once such labels are available, direct target-side supervision becomes a natural alternative; indeed, the target-only MLP outperforms BridgeRouter on FOG. The corresponding ISRUC baseline is missing.
-
Training protocol and generalization. The same paired data are used for bridge fitting and router supervision, so routing targets reflect in-sample bridge behavior. Moreover, the strongest gain is obtained under the same-subject FOG split, while the subject-disjoint ISRUC setting shows smaller and less stable improvements.
-
Role of collapsed routes. Several FOG routes are nearly single-class predictors, which can inflate oracle complementarity and potentially allow the supervised router to behave partly as a classifier. Although the compact-four oracle remains strong, supervised BridgeRouter performance using only non-collapsed routes is not reported.
Questions for authors
see limitations
3 comments
Thank you for the response and additional experiments. I appreciate the Compact-4 results, which provide useful evidence that the routing gains are not entirely driven by collapsed pathways.
Regarding the FOG evaluation protocol, I accept the argument that the sample-wise split follows the established BioX-Bridge benchmark for now. However, given the overlapping windows across partitions, I still encourage evaluation under a recording-disjoint or subject-disjoint split to better assess generalization.
My main concern remains the necessity and practical value of bridge-based routing when target-task supervision is already available. Since the router uses target-task labels to learn pathway-specific gains, why not directly train a lightweight supervised MLP on the same target-modality representations? Such a classifier could be integrated into the existing architecture without requiring multiple cross-modal bridges. Indeed, the target-only MLP outperforms BridgeRouter on FOG (83.40% vs. 81.38% BAcc). The authors' reframing of the contribution as supervised pathway selection does not fully explain what unique advantage the bridge-based approach provides.
The ISRUC results further raise concerns about generalization. While I agree that the SBS should be selected using validation data, BridgeRouter (62.92%) still underperforms three fixed pathways: EEGPT (65.17%), BENDR (64.45%), and BIOT (64.05%). This makes the practical benefit of instance-level routing less convincing under the subject-disjoint setting.
Finally, I appreciate the authors' acknowledgment that supervised routing may partly learn a target-task classifier. This reinforces my concern about the distinction between the proposed routing mechanism and direct supervised classification.
Overall, the rebuttal addresses some concerns, but the core motivation and practical advantages of bridge-based routing remain insufficiently justified. I maintain my original rating for now, but remain open to further clarification or evidence addressing these concerns.
We thank the reviewer for the thoughtful follow-up. We would like to clarify that our goal is not to outperform direct supervised classifiers, but to investigate a fundamental limitation of fixed-pathway cross-modal transfer in BioX-Bridge.
The target-only MLP serves as a reference rather than the primary baseline our method seeks to replace. Its strong performance is valuable, but it addresses a different question: whether direct target-task supervision can achieve higher classification accuracy. Our work instead asks whether relying on a single fixed bridge is sufficient when different foundation-model pathways exhibit complementary strengths across instances.
BioX-Bridge establishes the feasibility of cross-modal transfer, but its performance depends heavily on the underlying foundation models and bridge compatibility. Since no individual pathway is necessarily optimal for every instance, we investigate instance-level routing as a natural extension of BioX-Bridge, rather than treating fixed-pathway selection as the final solution.
We deliberately retain the original pathways to isolate the contribution of routing. Fine-tuning bridges, replacing foundation models, or optimizing classifiers could improve absolute performance, but these are separate directions beyond our present scope.
We acknowledge that the ISRUC results demonstrate limitations in routing generalization. Nevertheless, our contribution is not a claim of universal superiority, but the introduction and evaluation of instance-adaptive pathway selection within the BioX-Bridge framework. We believe this opens a meaningful direction for improving cross-modal transfer beyond fixed-pathway designs.
Weakness 1:
The central contribution of BridgeRouter is not to eliminate target-task supervision, but to investigate how that supervision can be used to adaptively select among pretrained cross-modal prediction pathways. Rather than training a new target-task predictor from scratch, the supervised Gain Router learns relative pathway performance and uses a threshold-protected decision rule to select one candidate pathway per instance.
This formulation allows us to isolate the value of instance-level selection while keeping the underlying cross-modal predictors fixed. As shown in our response to RA6J (Weakness 4), direct target-only classifiers remain strong alternatives and can outperform routing. We will distinguish these two approaches more explicitly and position BridgeRouter as a pathway-selection mechanism rather than a universally superior target-task classifier.
Weakness 2:
Our FOG experiments follow the original BioX-Bridge (ICLR 2026 Oral) sample-wise benchmark protocol to enable a controlled comparison between instance-level routing and the validation-selected fixed pathway using identical frozen predictors. This isolates the contribution of adaptive pathway selection within the established evaluation setting.
We acknowledge that the original FOG split contains overlapping windows from the same recordings across partitions. Consequently, these results demonstrate improvements under the original benchmark protocol but should not be interpreted as evidence of generalization to unseen subjects.
Importantly, ISRUC provides a complementary subject-disjoint evaluation, where the corrected router outperforms the validation-selected SBS by 3.83 percentage points on the test set, with positive gains across all five seeds. We will explicitly clarify these evaluation differences and their implications in the revised manuscript.
Weakness 3:
Thank you for identifying this missing experiment. We have now evaluated the supervised Gain Router on a compact four-pathway portfolio. Specifically, we excluded pathways whose dominant predicted class accounted for at least 95% of their predictions on the training split. This criterion uses no ground-truth labels and removes LaBraM, EEGPT, and REVE, retaining BIOT, CBraMod, CSBrain, and BENDR.
We retained the original FOG data split, training configuration, and five seeds (42-46). BIOT remains the validation-selected single best solver (SBS); router checkpoints and switching thresholds are selected exclusively on the internal development split.
¹ Ties are resolved in favor of BIOT. Router results are reported as mean ± sample standard deviation across five training seeds.
The Compact-4 router outperforms BIOT in all five seeds and exceeds majority voting by 4.19 percentage points on average. Thus, the routing improvement is not entirely attributable to near-single-class pathways.
Nevertheless, removing these pathways reduces mean balanced accuracy by 5.61 percentage points, demonstrating that they contribute substantially to the full-portfolio result. We will explicitly acknowledge this dependence and include the compact-portfolio results in the revision. We also agree that oracle performance alone is insufficient evidence of useful complementarity since two complementary constant predictors already yield a perfect oracle.
This experiment addresses the contribution of near-single-class pathways under the original same-subject FOG protocol. It does not establish cross-subject generalization or rule out the possibility that supervised routing partly learns a target-task classifier.