- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes InertialBridge, which using complete one-second IMU widow information to predict velocity and angular-rate sequences. And the method uses boundary-weighted scheduler and a Mamba3 state-space network. The evaluation on different datasets demonstrates its competitive position accuracy with fewer parameters.
Critical strengths
This paper proposes a novelty method, which using a bridge-matching framework and Mamba3 network to reconstruct dense velocity and angular-rate reconstruction. In addition, it provides a good theoretical analysis and sufficient experiments.
Critical weaknesses
- The experiment is not sufficient, which show bridge-interior training over direct regression. Because, the direct-regression base in table 2 disables source stacking, which weaken the persuasion for isolating the effect of bridge-interior training.
- In Table 1, although IB has lower parameter count and memory usage comparing with EqNIO. However, its FLOPs and Lat.(EqNIO: 3.88, IB: 5.92) are higher. The author can analyze and explain this phenomenon.
Questions for authors
- Before identifying the specific methodological gap, the authors should state the problem being addressed more explicitly in the abstract.
- The introduction and method section should give a more clearer explanation of this paper's motivation.
- The first paragraph of the methodology section should provide a clearer overview of IB to help readers understand the subsequent technical details.
- The authors could consider moving selected experiments and the associated discussion from the appendix into the main text. Typos and Minor Issues:
- Please define FLOPs as “floating-point operations” at its first occurrence.
- Table 3 lists six OxIOD(T) test sequences, whereas Appendix A.1.8 refers to two. Please reconcile these counts and explain any filtering.
Thank you for the detailed response and additional experiments. I appreciate the authors' efforts to address my concerns.
However, I will maintain my original rating. The new experiments show that bridge-interior training does not significantly improve trajectory accuracy compared with direct regression. The gains are mainly limited to small improvements in dense velocity estimation. Regarding efficiency, IB still has higher FLOPs and latency per window than EqNIO. While the authors have clarified the advantage of dense outputs, this benefit is limited to specific offline reconstruction settings.