- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The authors consider a new approach to trajectory inference utilizing AM, drawing inspiration from kinetic Langevin dynamics, but using the flow-matching formulation. The authors provide theory for flow matching with multiple marginals in this setting, which informs the training of a neural network to fit the acceleration field. Experiments are provided on low-dimensional data, along with real-world single-cell biology datasets.
Critical strengths
- The approach seems novel, and seems to be potentially useful if the population dynamics follow some kind of velocity field.
- The authors provide some theoretical grounding for their method, which may potentially be useful for other applications.
Critical weaknesses
- Often, the applications of trajectory inference in single-cell biology usually assume the model follows an overdamped SDE (see Eq. (1.1) in Lavenant et al. (2024)). This may mean the method is not as practically relevant for single-cell biology applications.
- In Lavenant et al. (2024), the goal is to recover the underlying distribution on path-space, and indeed their estimators, and some followup works consider consistent estimators in this sense (in some suitable limit). It is not clear to me whether AM can do this.
Questions for authors
- Concerning weakness 1, can the authors test the method on datasets where there is some kind of acceleration field involved in the model where data is drawn from? I would expect that AM would have better accuracy in this setting, compared to some of the baselines.
- Is it possible to show consistency of AM as an estimator (on path-space) under some kind of acceleration field model, as does Lavenant et al. (2024)? Additionally, as a case study, can the authors also test the experiment from Figure 4, [GCG25]? It would be nice to see whether AM can recover the ``correct’’ path-space distribution in this setting.
The first question is most relevant for my assessment in the rebuttal as it concerns the applicability of the method. The second question would help strengthen the paper.
[GCG25] Gu, Chien, Greenewald. Partially observed trajectory inference using optimal transport and a dynamics prior. ICLR 2025.
2 comments
Thanks for the responses; I will increase my score to a 3.
We thank the reviewer for the careful reading and constructive feedback. Below we address the comments individually.
We agree with the reviewer that a large body of the single-cell literature follows an overdamped SDE system. However, we believe our work develops algorithmic insights and explores the possibility that perhaps learning underdamped dynamics is more suitable (and scalable) for learning from physical systems, and that this was not possible with previous approaches.
We wholly agree with the reviewer, and we included a new experiment in the paper in Section 4.1. Specifically, we consider data generated by a nonlinear damped oscillator where the equations governing the dynamics are given by dXt=Vtdt,dVt=(−∇U(Xt)−Vt)dt+0.2dBt. We simulate these dynamics for T=10 seconds and use 41 equispaced times for training data and evaluate on 20 other held-out times, and report the resulting W1 hold-out error; see Appendix C.3 for more details. Table 1 now includes the following column
which shows that AM has the lowest mean held-out error among the methods we consider in our paper, and Figure 3 plots sample trajectories for the methods we consider.
We thank the reviewer for opening the discussion on this relevant theoretical aspect. Lavenant et al. (2024) consider the statistical problem of recovering an underlying path-space distribution from observations of its temporal marginals. Their consistency results rely on assumptions on the data-generating process, notably that the dynamics belong to a suitable class of potential-driven diffusion processes. In contrast, our objective is not to recover an assumed underlying stochastic process. Rather, we propose a model-free approach: a generative methodology for constructing stochastic dynamics that match a prescribed collection of J marginal distributions, without assuming that these marginals were generated by a particular class of SDEs. We therefore consider path-space statistical consistency to be an interesting but distinct and orthogonal research direction. Our approach is similar in spirit to Chen et al. (2023) and Theodoropoulos et al. (2025), which also employ underdamped reference dynamics to construct generative models satisfying multiple marginal constraints, with applications to single-cell trajectory inference. Nevertheless, regarding the possibility of establishing a consistency result for AM, we believe that such a result could be obtained under suitable well-specified model assumptions, for instance, by assuming that the observations are generated by dynamics belonging to the class of acceleration-field models considered in our framework. However, establishing such a result would require additional identifiability assumptions, as well as a careful analysis of the statistical and approximation errors associated with the learned acceleration field. We believe that these questions are beyond the scope of the present work and leave them for future work.