- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes VESPER, which learns a neural free energy while using it to bias the MD that generates its training data. A single variational objective is defined per tempering level, where the gradient balances two populations: physical walkers on biased MD and auxiliary walkers in CV space. VESPER is evaluated on the Muller-Brown surface, alanine dipeptide, alanine tetrapeptide, catalytic surface, and chignolin.
Critical strengths
1. A single principled objective for online free-energy learning without data
VESPER learns from samples it collects by itself, so it needs neither a pre-existing dataset nor the unknown CV density, biasing its own simulation to cross the barrier.
Critical weaknesses
1. Role of ladder and replica exchange not separated
The paper presents the ladder and the exchange together, but their effects differ. The ladder adds robustness without tuning, though it is rarely the best option and shows no gain on alanine dipeptide. Exchange, meanwhile, seems to be similar or harmful in most cases; it may help by rescuing a trapped level. I think the experiment in C.1 supports this, but other main experiments do not show a similar effect without a level that would be trapped.
2. Chignolin experiments lacking control
For chignolin, the hardest case, the experiments are only done with the exchange ladder, without single-level or no-exchange controls, so they cannot show what contributes here.
Questions for authors
1. Chignolin - folded definition and event asymmetry
For the folded and unfolded definition of chignolin, is the reference the native structure, and what is the "mean" in the mean RMSD taken over? Also, the results show 48 unfolding and 9 refolding events. I think the unfolding and refolding should alternate; could this asymmetry indicate that the run has not converged yet?
4 comments
Follow-up before the discussion deadline
Dear Reviewer ww2N, as the discussion period closes on Nov 18, we wanted to check whether our reply and the revised PDF address your concerns, in particular the separate treatment of pooling and exchange, the new no-exchange and single-level chignolin controls, and the extended chignolin runs addressing the folding-event asymmetry (revised Secs. 2–4, Appendices B.16, C.4). We would be glad to clarify anything further before then. Thank you again for your review.
Dear authors,
Thank you for the detailed response and additional experiments, which have mostly resolved my main concerns, and I apologize for the delayed response. The new experiments show the separate roles of pooling and exchange; Chignolin control experiments show that the learned bias drives the transition; and other minor configuration details have been resolved.
One small note for R2: small values are described as colder and as the hottest. From the definition , I understood that a smaller corresponds to a higher temperature, so the labels seem to be reversed. Please let me know if I have misunderstood something.
The colder levels unfold sooner inside the ladder than alone (α = 0.0556: 2.2–2.7 vs 5.1 ns; α = 0.207: 3.3–4.2 vs 4.9 ns), the hottest does not (> 7.4 vs 6.7–8.7 ns). The ladder uses 12× the MD, so this compares learning per replica, not per unit of MD.
Besides this, overall, I remain positive about the paper and keep my rating.
Thank you and clarification on the tempering convention
Dear Reviewer ww2N, thank you for your thoughtful review, for reading the revision so closely, and for your continued support of the paper. Your questions helped us design the chignolin controls and run extended simulations to clarify the separate roles of gradient pooling and replica exchange, thereby strengthening the paper.
Your reading of the manuscript’s convention is correct. We reversed the temperature labels in R2. With , the effective CV temperature is , so a smaller corresponds to stronger tempering and a higher effective CV temperature. The levels at and are therefore hotter than the level at . The reported values and unfolding times are correct, and Appendix B.16 gives this comparison directly by . We have edited the initial rebuttal to reflect the manuscript’s convention. Thank you for identifying this and for your careful engagement throughout the discussion.
Response to Reviewer ww2N
We thank the reviewer for their thorough reading. We agree with both weaknesses, ran the missing controls, and now present pooling and exchange separately (revised Secs. 2–4, Appendices B.16 and C.4). We also edited the text throughout for clarity and brevity; the method and theory are unchanged, and all text changes are marked in the supplementary comparison.
R1 – Ladder vs exchange. Agreed. Pooling defines the learning objective and gives robustness without tuning; exchange is an optional sampling move, recommended when the coldest level cannot cross the barriers. Four-well landscapes, full-space NRMSE (three runs, one ladder for all d, equal walkers and updates):
R2 – Chignolin controls. We ran the twelve-level ladder without exchange and single levels at α=0.591, 0.207 and 0.0556, with the same model, walkers and MD protocol (28.8 ns aggregate MD each).
R3 – Definitions and event asymmetry. The reference is the native NMR structure of CLN025 (PDB 2RVD, model 1); “mean” was imprecise. For each configuration we compute the Cα RMSD (ten atoms) after superposition: folded below 0.20 nm, unfolded above 0.40 nm, a transition counted after 20 ps in the new state. Each physical configuration is followed through the exchanges, so events alternate along it.
The reviewer’s reading is right: all 48 configurations start folded and the bias is learned during the first ~25 ns, so unfoldings dominate (48 unfoldings, 9 refoldings). We extended the four runs to 54–66 ns per replica (2.73 µs in total): after 25 ns they record 20 unfoldings and 20 refoldings. The folded fraction falls from 0.59 in the first 5 ns to 0.15 at 20–25 ns, then stays at 0.13–0.15 in every 5 ns window to 50 ns. All four independent runs show refolding: 22 of 48 configurations return (5, 4, 5 and 8 per run), and with 5AWL as reference the counts are 60 unfoldings and 23 refoldings. The learned (ψ₃, ψ₄) surface changes by 0.8–1.1 kJ/mol between 40 and 50 ns and differs by 1.0 kJ/mol between independent runs (Appendix B.16).