- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies whether small errors in the energies and forces predicted by machine-learned interatomic potentials are sufficient for reliable molecular-dynamics simulations. The main analysis considers smooth potentials with forces derived from their energies, without imposing locality or invariance under translations, rotations, and permutations of identical atoms. The authors construct examples with small errors averaged over the reference equilibrium distribution, but whose simulations remain trapped for long times or approach an incorrect equilibrium. One example also reproduces every training energy and force exactly. Appendix H shows that, under the stated assumptions, local models invariant with respect to translations, rotations, and permutations of identical atoms can also produce an incorrect equilibrium distribution. The authors also give bounds on energy errors that guarantee an accurate equilibrium distribution and further conditions for convergence to it. Numerical examples use an Einstein crystal and a harmonic model of solid argon.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses an important question for atomistic simulations, i.e., how errors in predicted energies and forces affect simulation results. The authors work toward a formal understanding of this relationship through explicit mathematical examples. These examples show how small average prediction errors can coexist with simulations that remain trapped for long times or approach an incorrect equilibrium distribution. The examples also have clear physical interpretations, i.e., that artificial wells can trap trajectories, while underestimating the energy of a competing region can make the model favor the wrong equilibrium state.
Critical weaknesses
I appreciate the authors’ effort to formalize the relationship between prediction errors and simulation results. My assessment focuses mainly on the relevance of this work to atomistic simulations and the development of interatomic potentials. From this perspective, it remains unclear to me what new physical insight the results provide and how they could help us develop or assess these models.
W1. The mechanisms behind the presented results are well known, i.e., that errors in energy barriers can keep simulations trapped, while errors in relative free energies can make a model favor the wrong state. Although the authors show that these problems can occur even with very small average energy and force errors, it remains unclear to me what new physical insight this provides or how it could help us develop or assess interatomic potentials.
W2. I find it difficult to assess the physical significance of the reported differences between probability distributions. A total-variation distance approaching one does not necessarily mean that errors in quantities such as local structure or heat capacity per atom are large.
W3. Appendix H extends the analysis to local models, but the paper does not demonstrate this result for a concrete atomistic system. An example showing how a local potential incorrectly favors one atomic arrangement over another would make the physical meaning clearer.
W4. The discussion of electronic-structure failures needs clarification. The theorems do not address difficulties in generating reference data, and a calculation failing to converge does not mean that the underlying physical energy is undefined.
W5. It is unclear how the conditions in Theorem 4.6 could be used in practice. They require bounds on energy errors across all configurations, including those without reference data. The authors should explain how these conditions could guide the development or validation of interatomic potentials.
W6. Exponential convergence does not establish that equilibrium will be reached within a practical simulation time. Reaching equilibrium also does not guarantee accurate transition rates or transport coefficients. The authors should consider distinguishing these questions when discussing „dynamical accuracy“.
Questions for authors
My questions follow directly from the weaknesses presented above and would be answered by addressing them.
9 comments
W3. Appendix H extends the analysis to local models, but the paper does not demonstrate this result for a concrete atomistic system. An example showing how a local potential incorrectly favors one atomic arrangement over another would make the physical meaning clearer.
We have now added an atomistic example (Appendix A.4) using an fcc Lennard-Jones argon crystal with 108 atoms, following the construction of Theorem H.5. The constructed potential introduces a local energy correction that favors compressed nearest-neighbour bonds, configurations that are extremely rare under the true equilibrium distribution (mean descriptor value per site).
Despite this, the model achieves a per-atom energy MAE of only and a force RMSE of 4% of the reference force scale, with 79% of validation configurations reproduced exactly. Yet MD simulations produce a completely different atomic arrangement. 99–100% of atoms form short bonds, compared with none in the reference crystal, resulting in a dimerized solid with a new peak in the pair-distance distribution. This state is reached from two different initializations and persists in a larger 256-atom system.
We have also added a second example with a trained model in Appendix A.6. NequIP, an equivariant GNN trained on alanine dipeptide, develops an unphysical energy well outside the training data that drives the molecule into a collapsed arrangement absent from the reference, despite small validation errors. A correction enforcing condition (a) of Theorem 4.6(ii) outside the data removes this failure, with validation error unchanged.
W4. The discussion of electronic-structure failures needs clarification. The theorems do not address difficulties in generating reference data, and a calculation failing to converge does not mean that the underlying physical energy is undefined.
We believe there may be a slight misunderstanding of the point we are making. For a system of 'N' atoms, the configuration space is , and obtaining reliable reference data throughout this space is practically infeasible.
Consider even a simple molecule such as , with bond length as its only internal degree of freedom. Although the bond length can vary over , training data may cover only a limited range, say 1-2 . We cannot expect an unconstrained neural network trained on this data to predict accurate energies and forces uniformly over all possible bond lengths. Classical force fields address this partly through physical priors, such as harmonic bond potentials and short-range repulsion, which discourage excursions into poorly sampled configurations.
More importantly, we do not necessarily need accurate energy predictions everywhere. If we have approximate physical knowledge of configurations the dynamics should avoid, we can impose repulsive priors or sufficiently high energy barriers to strongly suppress visits to those regions, while maintaining accurate predictions where reliable training data are available. This is also the motivation behind the one-sided energy conditions in Theorem 4.6(ii). Physically, this can be understood as an energy-entropy competition. Poorly sampled regions have enormous configurational volume in high dimensions, and underestimating their energies can give them disproportionately large equilibrium probability. Appropriate physical priors can help prevent this by keeping these regions energetically unfavourable.
The difficulty becomes much greater in the 3N-dimensional configuration space of larger systems. Our point is that limited training-data coverage cannot guarantee uniformly accurate predictions, but appropriate constraints can help control behavior outside the sampled region. This argument concerns the availability and coverage of reference data, not whether the underlying physical energy is defined.
W5. It is unclear how the conditions in Theorem 4.6 could be used in practice. They require bounds on energy errors across all configurations, including those without reference data. The authors should explain how these conditions could guide the development or validation of interatomic potentials.
We have partly addressed this concern in our response to Reviewer 9dG2. While verifying global energy-error bounds is difficult in practice, Theorem 4.6 provides a theoretical guide for developing physical constraints that control the learned potential in poorly sampled regions, without requiring accurate predictions everywhere (see our new NequIP example on alanine dipeptide, Appendix A.6). It also suggests a simple practical check for validating MLIPs beyond RMSE and MAE. Because, by Theorem 4.6(ii), a model that is accurate where the system spends most of its time can shift the equilibrium only by underestimating the energy elsewhere, the sign of the energy error along the model’s own trajectories is a useful diagnostic (please see our response to Reviewer HjH2, Validation).
W6. Exponential convergence does not establish that equilibrium will be reached within a practical simulation time. Reaching equilibrium also does not guarantee accurate transition rates or transport coefficients. The authors should consider distinguishing these questions when discussing „dynamical accuracy“.
The main point here is that, even as the force RMSE approaches zero, the learned potential can take much longer to equilibrate than the true system, and this gap grows with the degrees of freedom. The reason exponential timescales come up is that, for the Einstein crystal, Langevin dynamics under the true potential is known to equilibrate in at most polynomial time in the number of degrees of freedom of the crystal (Cheng et al., 2018). Here, we show that the learned potential can instead remain trapped for exponentially long times, even with arbitrarily small force errors. This establishes a large separation between the equilibration times of the true and learned systems. In physical terms, an MLIP can predict forces almost perfectly yet take much longer to equilibrate than would normally be expected for that system. Moreover, this trapping can be difficult to detect, since standard observables may appear stable and converged even though the system has not reached the correct equilibrium distribution. Accurate transition rates and transport coefficients are a separate, stronger requirement that require a different analysis that we do not address here.
We look forward to further discussion, and to improving the manuscript and its accessibility to physical scientists based on your feedback.
References
Creed, I., Rein, T., et al. Six open questions in machine-learned interatomic potential foundation models. arXiv preprint arXiv:2606.07327, 2026.
Cheng, X., Chatterji, N. S., et al. Underdamped Langevin MCMC: A non-asymptotic analysis. Conference on Learning Theory (COLT), PMLR 75:300–323, 2018.
We thank the reviewer for taking the time to carefully evaluate our work and for providing a thoughtful review from a physical perspective. We particularly appreciate their engagement with the physical significance. We address their questions below
We would first like to clarify a point regarding the characterization of the mechanisms. Errors in energy barriers can either slow down or accelerate transitions, depending on their sign. We believe the reviewer is referring to the well-known physical principles that energy barriers govern metastability and relative free energies determine equilibrium populations. We agree that these principles are well understood in statistical mechanics. However, they do not directly establish anything about how energy and force RMSE affect the equilibrium distribution sampled or the dynamics through which it is reached.
Our contribution is to show that an unconstrained MLIP trained only through energy-and-force matching can admit potentials with arbitrarily small population errors yet fundamentally incorrect sampling behavior, and that these failures become exponentially more severe with the number of degrees of freedom. The physical insight is based on an energy-entropy effect (Remark 4.4), which makes energy and force errors an exponentially poor indicator of sampling accuracy in high dimensions. In a large system, the Boltzmann weight of a region depends exponentially on the number of atoms, through both its energy and its configurational volume. A model that is extremely accurate on the training data, but underestimates the energy by just a few kBT per atom in a large, rarely sampled region, can therefore shift almost all of the equilibrium probability into that region. Its energy and force errors on the training data stay tiny, and its forces remain physically reasonable, of order one per atom. Why such large regions are rarely sampled is discussed in our response to W4 below. Additionally, we examine which failure modes can be ruled out by explicitly incorporating common physical constraints, such as conservativity, locality, and symmetry, and which can still persist despite these constraints.
Regarding the significance for MLIP development, we believe understanding the role of physical inductive biases, the guarantees they provide, and their limitations is important for developing reliable MLIPs. In particular, whether future MLIPs should incorporate stronger architectural constraints or move towards more flexible, unconstrained potentials is an important open question in the MLIP community (Creed et al., 2026). Our results provide a theoretical perspective on this question by identifying the limitations of unconstrained energy-and-force matching and showing why conventional energy and force error metrics, even at the population level, can be misleading indicators of sampling reliability.
On the implications for assessing MLIPs, please see our response to Reviewer HjH2 (Practical interpretation) and the new Section 5 of the revised paper. In short, we suggest simple practical checks, beyond standard prediction metrics, to validate MLIPs and detect failures that affect physical property predictions.
We have addressed this concern in detail in our response above to Reviewer 9dG2. Our results not only show TV approaching one, but also demonstrate significant discrepancies in physically meaningful observables, including intensive structural quantities and displacement fluctuations.