- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
Author propose an exit-time OSC approach for transition-path sampling with Koopman eigenfunctons and Gibbs measure.
Critical strengths
The exit-time formulation accommodates variable transition durations without prescribing a terminal time in the control objective.
Critical weaknesses
- Scalability beyond synthetic systems and alanine dipeptides remains unestablished.
- High target-hit rates alone do not establish accurate pathway probabilities or kinetics. Quantitative validation of the reweighted path ensembles for the physical interpretation.
Questions for authors
- How rare are the benchmark transitions under unbiased dynamics? Could you report mean first-passage times or transition rates, rather than only target-hit percentages at the selected ?
- The TPS-DPS release includes larger systems such as Trp-cage and chignolin. Consider expanding the evaluation systems beyond alanine dipeptide.
- How sensitive are the estimated committor and controller to the kernel? Have you compared other smooth kernels?
- What quantitative criterion selects in Section 4.1, especially when theres no clear spectral gap? How sensitive are the identified metastable cores and sampling results to this choice?
- How rare are the benchmark transitions under unbiased dynamics? the equation penalizes residence time according to the committor, not state rarity. High target-hit rates do not establish coverage of rare intermediates, and alanine-dipeptide experiments do not address this.
4 comments
Response to Reviewer B7bc, continued
Response to Q1: We now report, for each benchmark, the mean first-passage time (MFPT) from the source to the target core, estimated from long unbiased simulations, together with the relaxation time of the slowest Koopman mode. For the two-channel double well at 1200 K, MFPT and , against . For M"uller--Brown at 200 K, MFPT ps and ps, against ps. For the four-well system at 200 K, MFPT ps and ps, against ps. For alanine dipeptide at 300 K, no transition was observed in 100 unbiased runs of 5 ns each (500 ns in total), so the MFPT exceeds 5 ns, and ns, compared with ps. In all cases, the MFPT exceeds by one to four orders of magnitude, so transitions within are rare under the unbiased dynamics. We added these values to Appendix G.1–G.4.
Response to Q2: Please see our response to W1.
Response to Q3: The kernel must be twice continuously differentiable, since acts on it through (71). Kernel estimates of the leading Koopman eigenfunctions, on which our metastable sets and committor are built, are known to be accurate over a range of bandwidths, including for alanine dipeptide (Nüske & Klus, 2023). A more accurate kernel approximation yields a more effective controller, while the statistics of the original dynamics are recovered exactly by Theorem 2 in either case.
Response to Q4: We select at the spectral gap separating the slow eigenvalues from the rest, i.e., at the largest ratio of consecutive implied timescales , . Since we consider metastable systems, such a separation is expected. Regarding sensitivity, in all our benchmarks, the spectral gap is clear, so is determined by the spectrum; a missing gap would indicate an inadequate estimate of the eigenpairs, and we increase the number of samples or adjust the kernel bandwidth until the leading eigenvalues stabilize.
Response to Q5: We have added new results in Section 4.3 and Appendix F, which show that no intermediate is lost. Specifically, by our new results (Theorem 2 and Corollary 2-3), any intermediate visited with positive probability by the original dynamics is visited with positive probability by the controlled dynamics, and its frequency is recovered exactly via Corollary 3.
Appreciate the acknowledgement of the scale of the system. The authors addressed my concerns. I will raise my score accordingly. However, next time, try not to post the rebuttal so close to the ddl.
Thank you very much for your helpful feedback and for raising your score. We apologize again for the late submission, and thank you for your patience.
Response to Reviewer B7bc
We thank the reviewer for your time and comments. Changes in the revised manuscript are highlighted in blue.
Response to Critical Weakness 1: We sincerely agree with the reviewer that applying transition path sampling (TPS) to large biomolecules is an important problem, and most certainly a long-term goal of ours. At the same time, we want to stress that our work is mainly theoretical and meant to lay a new foundation for studying TPS through the use of Koopman operators. Our numerical experiments are there to check these results on systems where the ground truth is known and where many other methods have already reported solutions. We did not want to rush the simulations for chignolin, for example, since it would require a much more in-depth examination of folding/hairpin formation/competing folding results, and we mostly focused on deriving new theoretical claims as suggested in your W2 below.
Response to Critical Weakness 2: We have added new results: Theorem 2 in Section 4.3 shows that, for the approximate controller actually used, the weight (23) recovers the expectation under the original dynamics of every path statistic. Corollary 2 gives the transition probability by time t (kinetics) and Corollary 3 the fraction of transitions through a channel or intermediate channel (pathway probabilities).