- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates the traffic prediciton under road-closre. Because of the limited real-world data of road-closure is rare, the authors use normal traffic data to learn basic dynamics and use small number of closed data to calibrate model. Route parameters and wave are learned from normal traffic, while closed route only calibrate two operators. Experiments are conducted on SUMO with real data.
Critical strengths
- The problem is meaningful.
- The mechanisms have clear traffic meaning. And each mechanism is validated on SUMO.
Critical weaknesses
- Most mehanisms are hand-crafted, including traffic wave, queue, spillback, downstream depletion, merge competition. They are meaningful in traffic, but for general ML in ICLR, these domain knowledge are hard to generalize.
- Model needs normal traffic scneario as reference. However, this requirement is hard to satisfy. Road-closure happens in accident, and there usually have no normal traffic records.
Questions for authors
See Weaknesses
Thank you for your constructive comments and for recognizing the importance of the problem and the physical meaning of the mechanisms. We address your two concerns below.
W1. Machine-learning contribution and generalizability
Your concern raises the distinction between domain-specific equations and a transferable learning approach. The traffic equations are domain-specific. The broader ML contribution is how CSTP combines normal-traffic learning with an explicit intervention structure to predict closures for which few training examples are available. This matters because predicting an unseen closure requires more than extrapolating normal traffic. The model must represent how blocking a movement changes accumulation and propagates effects through connected roads. CSTP specifies these relationships through its physical state, while learning road profiles and state-dependent propagation from normal observations. Closure examples then calibrate a small shared response instead of having to teach the model the entire chain of effects. The resulting learning principle is to separate reusable system dynamics from intervention-specific calibration. This addresses a general problem in ML: learning to predict intervention outcomes when observations of normal operation are much more available than intervention examples. The matched-supervision experiment in Table 3 supports this claim by showing that the structured representation retains count accuracy at unseen closure locations with few training scenarios. We therefore see the contribution as a way to organize learning and support generalization under limited intervention data. Applying this principle elsewhere would require mechanisms appropriate to that domain, rather than directly transferring the traffic equations.
W2. Availability of the normal-traffic reference
We agree that the future traffic trajectory without an accident cannot be observed. However, the normal reference in CSTP is an estimate of that trajectory. It does not require a simultaneous no-accident record or a previous occurrence of the same closure. For example, when an accident occurs during the morning period, an expected normal trajectory can be constructed from comparable historical mornings or supplied by a normal-traffic forecasting model. The closure query then specifies the affected road and onset, and CSTP predicts the changes relative to that estimated scenario. This distinction also explains our evaluation design. Matched no-closure SUMO simulations provide a known reference to isolate closure-response accuracy. In PeMS, the reference is instead constructed from prior same-weekday speed and flow observations, with an inventory proxy derived from those profiles and road geometry. This demonstrates how the required inputs can be assembled without observing future normal traffic. Because an estimated reference can contain errors, Appendix C.1 tests timing and magnitude perturbations and finds that the local comparative advantages persist under the tested conditions. The practical requirement is therefore access to usable historical observations or a credible normal-traffic forecast. CSTP predicts the closure response conditional on that estimate.