- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes PGET-Net that incorporates event-text information for traffic forecasting. Historical traffic states are represented through a latent traffic potential, whose evolution is motivated by diffusion and advection mechanisms. DiffGCN propagates on static route network, while AdvGCN is built on the graph generated by BERT encoded text and learnable node embeddings. The experiments are conducted on BjTT dataset.
Critical strengths
- The problem itself is well-motivated. Incorporating text event-information into traffic forecasting is challenging, especially for capturing traffic disturbances that are not reflected with historical measurement.
- The reported improvement during peak hour is significant.
Critical weaknesses
-
The physical interpretation of the diffusion and advection mechanism is not convincing. Diffusion is described as the transport of traffic potential from higher-potential to lower-potential nodes. However, DiffGCN adopts a conventional GCN without establishing its relation to a diffusion operator or imposing constraints that enforce gradient-driven transport. In addition, it is unclear how this graph represents physical advection or directed traffic propagation with AdvGCN. In particular, the graph learned from textual information does not necessarily reflect road connectivity and traffic wave propagation. Therefore, the physical interpretation of the proposed framework is seriously questionable.
-
The experiment comparison are insufficient to support the claimed contribution. The uniqueness of the BjTT dataset is ackonwledged. However, the selected baselines are relatively outdated, and none of them incorporate textual event information. Therefore, it is unclear whether the reported improvements arise from the proposed physics-guided design or simply from the additional information provided by event text.
-
It is unclear how Eq. 6 connects to real traffic potential evolution and how the proposed equation relates to traffic flow propagation on road and network. A physically meaningful dynamical equation has to be considered. The proposed method is not technically sound.
Questions for authors
See weaknesses.