- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces a new method based on diffusion to model and query the traffic state. A central idea is to train a single unconditional-with-respect-to-sensors traffic prior and introduce sensor information only at inference through diffusion posterior sampling. The authors evaluate whether the model has learned traffic mechanics through several probes. It gives some interesting on this two-lane signalized link scenario.
Critical strengths
- The paper asks a clear and scientifically interesting question. Rather than reporting only generative reconstruction metrics, the paper asks whether a data-driven generative model has actually learned traffic dynamics.
- The experiment is extensive. The evaluation goes substantially beyond summary-statistic matching.
- The code is provided.
Critical weaknesses
- The experiment scenario is too simple. Consider experimenting on a lot of real world large scale maps.
- The idea to apply diffusion on traffic state estimation is not novel. The PMA-Diffusion has explored this direction.
- The paper argues that the generative model can replace a physics-based traffic model, but does not compare against a strong physics-based model
Questions for authors
- How much performance is retained with substantially fewer DDIM steps?
- Can you compare against a calibrated CTM or kinematic-wave state estimator under the same detector configurations?
- How does counterfactual performance change when demand is provided explicitly rather than inferred from detector guidance?
3 comments
Thank the authors for the detailed rebuttal. The single experiment on the simple NGSIM dataset is still not convincing. I therefore keep my original score of 2: weak rejection.
Follow-up on the real-world test: choice of dataset
Thank you for reading our response. We would like to explain why the test uses NGSIM, because the dataset was not chosen for convenience.
The test needs five things from a dataset:
- trajectories of every vehicle on the link, to build the true time-space diagram
- the recorded signal timing, which is the model's action
- a field of view that reaches the queue tail, not only the intersection area
- at least 15 minutes of continuous recording, to cover several signal cycles
- public access
We screened ten datasets against these criteria: FLUID, CitySim, CityArtery, SIT-PET, DRIFT, the Utah LiDAR dataset, pNEUMA, SinD, HDI and NGSIM Peachtree. Nine of them fail at least one. DRIFT, pNEUMA, HDI and the Utah LiDAR dataset have no signal data. FLUID, SIT-PET and SinD do not cover the queue tail. CityArtery is shorter than 15 minutes, and CitySim is not public. NGSIM Peachtree is the only one that supports the test, although its trajectories carry known tracking noise.
Peachtree Street is also not a simple site. It is an urban arterial with turn bays, driveways, and platoons from upstream signals, none of which are in the training simulations. The test covers eight approaches in two periods, and nothing is retrained or tuned on it.
We agree that one corridor does not settle how far the prior transfers, and Sec. 5 says so. Within the public data that exist today, this is the test that can be run.
New experiments (CTM baseline, fewer steps, explicit demand, real-world test) and novelty vs. PMA-Diffusion
Thank you for the review. We have revised the paper to address your comments, which we believe made it a better paper.
Q2 / W3. Calibrated CTM baseline. Added (Sec. 4.4, Table 3, App. M). The model has a triangular fundamental diagram on the 32 cells of the link, with the signal at the downstream boundary. Its four parameters are fitted on held-out windows (14 m/s, 1.2 veh/s, 0.30 veh/m, 1.0 veh/s). It takes the demand that deterministic queuing derives from each sensor, and it inserts detector densities where that helps on the held-out windows. Queue correlation on the 256 test windows, CTM vs DiffLink (median of 8 samples):
DiffLink is ahead with every layout within 56 m of the stop bar, and the two are close on the mid-link rows and counts. The CTM is ahead only with the arrival rate alone. Given the true inflow and initial state it reaches 0.92, so most of its error comes from the unknown timing of arrivals. It runs all 256 windows in 0.1 s on one CPU core. It has no natural way to use probe trajectories, while DiffLink adds them as a second loss (stop bar 0.75 to 0.88, Sec. 4.5).
Q1. Fewer DDIM steps. App. L plots every sensor's estimate against the number of steps. With the guidance step scaled as 0.5 × 1000 / n, 100 steps stay within 0.06 of 1000 for every sensor, at 83 ms against 827 ms per window on one H100.
Q3. Counterfactual with explicit demand. We give DiffLink each window's arrival rate as a number, with no detector row, over four shifts of green. Its queue grows by 0.75 m per second of green removed, against 0.87 m in the simulator and 0.83 m with upstream detectors (Sec. 4.3, App. J). The CTM given the same arrival rate grows by 0.65 m.
W2. Novelty against PMA-Diffusion. PMA-Diffusion is the closest work, and we cite it. Our paper differs in two ways. It models density and flow on a signalized link, where the signal enters as an action, so the model answers counterfactual questions about signal timing and gives queue and delay. It also tests what the prior has learned, with physics probes, a lookup-table control, and cycle lengths outside training.
W1. Simple scenario. We agree, and we added a zero-shot test on a real-world dataset (App. N, Table 15). The SUMO-trained prior runs without retraining on 160 windows from NGSIM Peachtree Street in Atlanta, a real arterial with turn bays, driveways and platoons from upstream signals. With stop-bar detectors, DiffLink's queue correlation is 0.64, against 0.31 for deterministic queuing, 0.46 for the calibrated CTM, and 0.81 in simulation. During a 30 s outage it is 0.69, against 0.34 for the CTM. With probes added it reaches 0.87. So the prior transfers to real-world data without retraining. Networks of links remain future work (Sec. 5).