- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a traffic scene simulation method named TraffusionGen. This method treats generation and completion as task-conditioned scene inference. In order to achieve better results, it combines the MCG and self attention operation independently on the same incoming tokens, using the learnable residual connections to model the scene-level context and token-level relationships. On the processed WOMD subset, this method improves the generation metrics and maintains lower ADE under vehicle masking. Component ablations support gains from both branches and their fusion.
Critical strengths
- Parallel MCG-Attention Blocks combine the MCG and self attention operations to get better results compared with other baseline methods. As shown in Table2, TraffusionGen obtains 0.31 m ADE and 0.40 m FDE, reducing TrafficGen baseline values by 46.6% and 46.7%. Position MMD decreases from 0.35 to 0.12, and collision rate from 0.38 to 0.18. These consistent improvements across multiple evaluation metrics demonstrate that combining MCG with self-attention enables TraffusionGen to achieve more accurate trajectory generation, better distribution matching, and fewer collisions in generated traffic scenes.
Critical weaknesses
- It would have been better to add explainations of the motivation to combine the MCG and self attention operation. These operations are common, and used by many previous works. This paper seems to add these two operations together simply.
- The paper don't provide the details of network architectures and training hyper parameters. For example, the architecture details of PolylineEncoder, EmbedSemantic, and the decoder. It's hard for other researchers to reproduce this results. Providing these details would make this work reproducible.
Questions for authors
- Provide more details of network architectures and training hyper parameters to help reproduce this work. Providing these details would enable other researchers to reproduce and verify the reported results.
- Motivation clarification of MCG and self attention combination. Why their combination is particularly suitable for traffic scene generation and completion, and what specific limitation of existing architectures this parallel design is intended to address.
- Add a comparision on other dataset to validate the robustness of proposal method. TraffusionGen was only tested on WOMD subset.
- Add some visualization comparison results to help reader understand. This paper don't provide any visualization results.