- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents CryoGaussian, a Gaussian-splatting framework for homogeneous and heterogeneous cryo-EM reconstruction with fixed input poses. It models structural variability through particle-image and per-Gaussian latent variables, followed by per-state reconstruction. The method is evaluated on synthetic benchmarks and experimental datasets.
Critical strengths
- The framework supports both compositional and conformational heterogeneity within an explicit Gaussian representation.
- The spatially localized Gaussian parameters offer potential interpretability advantages over implicit neural representations, with positions, scales, and amplitudes that can be directly inspected.
Critical weaknesses
- The claimed resolution gains require stronger validation on experimental data. In Figure 3, the GSFSC remains unusually high near the Nyquist limit, while the displayed maps do not clearly demonstrate corresponding improvements in interpretable structural detail. Although the paper includes masking controls and synthetic validation, the elevated high-frequency agreement remains insufficiently explained, raising concerns about potentially inflated resolution estimates.
- The practical advantage for heterogeneous reconstruction remains unclear. The experimental results mainly recover previously reported assembly states and conformational motions. Despite the synthetic benchmark scores, the paper does not demonstrate substantially better recovery or interpretation of heterogeneity on experimental data than established methods.
Questions for authors
- What explains the persistently high GSFSC near the Nyquist limit in Figures 3 and 26? Beyond half-map agreement and the synthetic validation in Figure 7, can the authors provide evidence that this high-frequency signal corresponds to accurate structural detail in the experimental reconstructions?
- Under matched experimental conditions, which structural states or conformational variations does CryoGaussian recover more reliably than established methods such as CryoDRGN or RECOVAR? Can this advantage be demonstrated through quantitative comparisons and specific structural examples?
Response to Reviewer meVz
We thank the reviewer for their time and comments. The points raised were carefully considered in a substantial revision of the manuscript, which refocuses its scope, restructures its experimental evaluation, and strengthens the validation of results on both synthetic benchmarks and experimental data.