- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes cryoSplat2, a Gaussian-based framework for particle-level ab initio reconstruction. Specifically, it jointly optimizes particle poses and anisotropic Gaussian representations from random initialization. Experiments include four real cryo-EM datasets, evaluating ab initio reconstruction quality, downstream refinement, and computational efficiency.
Critical strengths
-
This work successfully demonstrates that a Gaussian-based method can also achieve ab initio cryo-EM reconstruction, which can bring significant efficiency advances over cryoDRGN.
-
Experiments show that the proposed method can produce reliable reconstruction across diverse structures, including challenging cases.
Critical weaknesses
-
The method's key designs such as the scheduler and Gaussian densification are not separately ablated to show their individual effects.
-
Robustness and reliability need more justification. In the experiments, this paper reports some failures of prior works and some successful runs. It would be more clear to report the number of runs and success rates of all methods to have a clear robustness and reliability evaluation.
Questions for authors
Is it possible to have controlled comparisons of adaptive versus predetermined scheduling and adaptive versus fixed Gaussian capacity?
Some related work on Gaussian-based cryo-EM methods is missing, such as GEM [1].
[1] Gem: 3d gaussian splatting for efficient and accurate cryo-em reconstruction, Qu, et al., 2025
5 comments
W2: Success rate
We have evaluated cryoSplat2, cryoSPARC, and cryoDRGN-AI using five random seeds across all four datasets, with the results added to Appendix C (Figs. 10 and 11). cryoSplat2 succeeds in all 20 runs (Fig. 10). Both baselines succeed in all five runs on EMPIAR-10028 and EMPIAR-11910. However, cryoSPARC fails in all five runs on EMPIAR-10180 (0/5) and succeeds in only two out of five runs on EMPIAR-11762 (2/5), while cryoDRGN-AI fails in all five runs on EMPIAR-11762 (0/5) (Fig. 11). These results demonstrate the greater robustness of cryoSplat2 to random initialization across the evaluated datasets.
W1, Q1: Adaptive versus predetermined scheduling
Thank you for suggesting this comparison. We added a controlled ablation that uses a predetermined schedule to emulate an ad hoc fixed frequency-marching workflow. Specifically, we record the stage transitions from a successful EMPIAR-10028 reconstruction using our adaptive frequency-marching scheduler, freeze them, and apply the resulting schedule to EMPIAR-11762, EMPIAR-11910, and EMPIAR-10180 without dataset-specific retuning. The fixed schedule uses the same joint-iteration counts for increasing the HEALPix order and reconstruction bandwidth, switching from global to local pose search, and inserting fixed-pose epochs. Because the datasets have different image sizes and pixel sizes, the Fourier crop side lengths are accordingly converted to preserve the corresponding nominal physical resolutions of the source schedule.
The fixed schedule does not generalize reliably to the other datasets: EMPIAR-11910 exhibits pronounced structural distortion, EMPIAR-11762 misses part of the structure, and EMPIAR-10180 also shows clear degradation. In contrast, our adaptive frequency-marching scheduler consistently produces complete and well-formed reconstructions across all four datasets.
These results show that a fixed coarse-to-fine schedule tuned for one dataset is insufficient for robust cross-dataset reconstruction, further demonstrating the effectiveness and robustness of our adaptive scheduler. We added this experiment and the corresponding fixed schedule to Appendix C under “Necessity of adaptive frequency marching.”
We thank the reviewer for the constructive comments. We conducted the requested additional experiments, incorporated the new results into the revised manuscript, and added the missing related work. We address each point below.