- Rating
- 4
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents CryoSD, a score-based framework for heterogeneous ab initio cryo-EM reconstruction. It first learns a diffusion model from raw particle images and uses it for joint denoising and approximate CTF correction. A second diffusion model is trained on the restored images. For each selected particle, a 3D volume is then optimized by matching a fixed-view projection to that particle as an anchor, while encouraging projections from other directions to agree with the learned image distribution. Experiments include synthetic conformational heterogeneity datasets and real clathrin-cage data from EMPIAR-10295, with comparisons against cryoDRGN-AI and RELION.
Critical strengths
-
A novel and intuitive reconstruction framework. Combining a particle-specific conformational anchor with a diffusion prior over other projection directions provides a substantially different approach to heterogeneous reconstruction without explicit rotation estimation. The method offers an interesting alternative to conventional pose-search-based pipelines. The paper is also clearly written and easy to follow, with a coherent introduction that provides useful tutorial-style explanations.
-
Meaningful evidence from real experimental data. The EMPIAR-10295 experiment provides the strongest evidence for the method’s effectiveness. The recovered volumes show recognizable cage architectures, supporting the practical feasibility of the framework beyond synthetic data. These results make the approach worth further investigation despite the remaining limitations.
Critical weaknesses
-
A key ab initio baseline is missing. cryoSPARC is a widely used and particularly strong baseline for reference-free initial model generation and multi-class ab initio reconstruction. Comparison with RELION does not replace this evaluation on EMPIAR-10295. This omission is especially important because cryoSPARC provides a high-symmetry preset addressing failure modes directly relevant to cage-like structures without requiring a specified symmetry group. Consequently, the current comparisons do not sufficiently establish an advantage over strong conventional ab initio workflows.
-
Generality and downstream utility remain insufficiently validated. EMPIAR-10295 contains unusually large cage-like assemblies whose characteristic architectures can be distinguished at relatively coarse resolution. This reduces the dependence on accurately recovering high-frequency information, where CTF oscillations are denser and signal attenuation makes recovery more difficult. This is nevertheless a challenging dataset: its symmetry and pseudosymmetry create substantial ambiguity for ab initio pose search and can lead to collapsed viewing-direction assignments and distorted reconstructions. However, this combination of large particle size and pronounced symmetry represents a specialized setting. Evaluation on EMPIAR-10180 for conformational variability and EMPIAR-10076 for compositional variability in a more compact, asymmetric assembly would provide more convincing evidence of broader applicability.
Limited resolution is not inherently a weakness for an ab initio method; however, whether the recovered volumes are sufficiently accurate to support subsequent classification and high-resolution refinement has not been demonstrated. Using these volumes as initial references in cryoSPARC or RELION, and successfully recovering the corresponding heterogeneous states at higher resolution, would provide strong evidence of their structural accuracy and practical utility.
Questions for authors
-
Can the authors compare against cryoSPARC multi-class ab initio reconstruction on EMPIAR-10295, including its high-symmetry preset, using the same particle set without providing known structures or symmetry groups? This is particularly relevant because the paper attributes its advantage partly to difficulties faced by pose-search-based methods on symmetric or pseudosymmetric structures.
-
Can the authors provide real-data evaluation beyond large cage-like assemblies whose architectures are distinguishable at coarse resolution? EMPIAR-10180 and EMPIAR-10076 would be informative benchmarks for conformational and compositional variability, respectively. These experiments would help establish whether the method generalizes beyond the specialized combination of large particle size and pronounced symmetry in EMPIAR-10295.
-
Can the recovered volumes serve as initial references for downstream classification and refinement in cryoSPARC or RELION? High resolution is not essential at the ab initio stage, but successful separation and high-resolution refinement of the corresponding heterogeneous states would provide strong evidence that the initial reconstructions are sufficiently accurate and practically useful.
My current recommendation is clear acceptance, based on the novelty of the framework and the evidence of its effectiveness on real data. However, the missing cryoSPARC comparison remains a substantive concern, particularly given the paper’s claims about advantages over pose-search-based methods. If this concern is not adequately addressed through additional experiments, a convincing explanation, or appropriately narrowed claims, I may revise my recommendation to weak acceptance. The other suggested experiments would strengthen the paper, but I do not consider them prerequisites for acceptance.
2 comments
Thank you for your efforts in addressing my concerns. After carefully reading the revised version and considering other reviewers' comments, I have decided to maintain my current rating.
The results on EMPIAR-10180 largely address my concerns. Although they are somewhat low-resolution, I believe the reconstructed models can be used as initial models for downstream refinement. That is why I highly recommend that the authors compare downstream refinement or 3D classification results using the initial models generated by the proposed method and other baselines. This would provide direct evidence that the initial models are good enough for downstream applications, which I believe could also address other reviewers' concerns.
In my experience, limited resolution or potential generative artifacts are not necessarily fatal issues for ab initio reconstruction results. In downstream RELION-like Bayesian EM refinement, the density is re-estimated directly from experimental particle images rather than inherited from the generated initial models. Therefore, generative artifacts are not directly preserved in the reconstructed density. Although inaccurate initial models may lead to incorrect convergence, I would expect the refinement to either converge toward the correct structures or produce obviously incorrect reconstructions that are unlikely to be mistaken for valid protein structures.
In cryoSPARC, downstream refinement typically takes only a couple of minutes. That means the authors still have a chance to complete these experiments by the end of the rebuttal phase.
We thank the reviewer for carefully reading our paper and for preparing this thoughtful review. We regard the reviewer's critical comments and questions as highly valuable guidance for our continued work on this project.
We agree with the substantive concern regarding the missing comparison with CryoSPARC. We have revised the Results section to include CryoSPARC (see Figure 5 in the revised manuscript). This concern was clearly justified: CryoSPARC’s multi-class ab initio reconstruction outperformed RELION and CryoDRGN-AI. CryoSPARC recovered the mini coat architecture and most of the D6 barrel, but did not recover the remaining three architectures. Further details are provided in Appendix E.2 of the revised manuscript.
We sincerely thank the reviewer for identifying this important missing part and for helping us improve the paper.
We also include preliminary qualitative results on the experimental EMPIAR-10180 spliceosome dataset in Appendix E.3 of the revised manuscript.