- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2(+1)
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a Gaussian-based reconstruction method with a wave-optical forward model for electron tomography. Starting from the thick-phase-grating approximation (TPGA), the authors approximate each Gaussian primitive as sufficiently thin and incorporate its depth-dependent Fresnel propagation into a complex projected covariance. The resulting renderer is integrated with microscope image formation and joint refinement of the reconstruction and nuisance parameters. Evaluation includes forward-model comparisons against independent multislice simulations, experimental cryo-ET reconstructions, and an atomic-resolution Co3O4 tilt series.
Critical strengths
-
Clear exposition and physically motivated method design. The paper explains the scientific background accessibly and connects the limitations of the projection model to the proposed operator. The main derivation is coherent, and the resulting depth-dependent complex covariance provides a compact formulation that fits naturally into Gaussian rasterization.
-
A promising operator supported by controlled forward-model validation. Figure 3 compares different renderers on the same fixed potential against an independent multislice implementation, isolating forward-model accuracy from reconstruction and optimization. This supports the accuracy of the proposed approximation under the tested high-frequency conditions. The matched wave/ray comparisons are also useful for distinguishing benefits from the reconstruction framework and those from the physical correction.
Critical weaknesses
-
The experimental settings provide limited evidence for the practical reconstruction benefit of the central physical contribution. The motivation is to improve image formation where specimen depth makes the projection approximation inaccurate. However, the reconstructions of EMPIAR-10164 and EMPIAR-10643 mostly remain at resolutions of tens to over one hundred angstroms, where the relevant propagation effect is small under the reported conditions.
This mismatch can be quantified using the Fresnel phase expression and parameters in §5.2. At 300 kV, with an electron wavelength of approximately 0.0197 Å and a propagation distance of 81 nm, the depth-dependent Fresnel phase is . At spatial periods of 50 Å and 100 Å, this gives approximately 0.020 rad (1.15°) and 0.005 rad (0.29°), respectively. The corresponding complex propagation factors differ from unity by only about 2% and 0.5%. For comparison, the phase reaches approximately 2 rad at a spatial period of 5 Å under the same conditions. These are frequency-specific propagation-factor differences, rather than relative image errors, but they illustrate the mismatch between the physical motivation and the tested reconstruction regime.
Consistently, the matched wave and ray reconstructions are essentially identical on these datasets. The authors explicitly state in §5.2 that the gains arise from the representation and joint refinement rather than wave optics. These experiments therefore do not establish an additional reconstruction benefit from the proposed physical correction.
Figure 3 provides useful forward-model validation on a fixed simulated potential, and the Co3O4 experiment offers additional evidence at high spatial frequencies. However, the practical benefit for recovering macromolecular structures from experimental cryo-EM images remains insufficiently demonstrated. A high-resolution single particle cryo-EM experiment would provide a more direct test of whether the improved forward model enables recovery of additional reliable structure.
-
The structural claims should be narrowed to match the available evidence. The higher half-map FSC demonstrates stronger agreement between the reconstructed halves under the reported evaluation protocol. However, this does not by itself establish a corresponding improvement in structural resolution or the recovery of additional fine detail. The cryo-ET visualizations primarily show reduced background noise and improved contrast, without clearly identifiable additional structural features commensurate with the reported FSC gains. In Figure 13, some shell regions appear broader or smoother than in WBP, rather than more distinctly resolved.
My concern is therefore with the interpretation of the results, rather than the correctness of the reported FSC measurements. The evidence supports improved half-map consistency and visual contrast, but claims of “finer detail” or higher structural resolution require additional corroboration. Unless such evidence is provided, these claims should be narrowed accordingly.
Questions for authors
-
Evaluation in a more suitable resolution regime. Could you evaluate your operator either on a high-resolution single particle cryo-EM dataset, such as EMPIAR-10202 in the CryoSPARC tutorial, or through high-resolution subtomogram averaging within cryo-ET? Since you already use EMPIAR-10164, the NovaCTF study provides a relevant precedent for demonstrating the benefit of depth-dependent correction using this data source.
-
Structural evidence and claim scope. Can the authors identify specific structural features that become newly distinguishable in their cryo-ET reconstructions, supported by matched local views or density profiles, particularly in the shell regions of Figure 13? Comparison with appropriately filtered or denoised WBP would also help distinguish improved visibility from improved structural resolvability. If the principal observable improvements are background suppression and contrast enhancement, would the authors revise the claims of finer structural detail and higher resolution to reflect the evidence more precisely?
-
Initialization and computational implementation. Please specify how the Gaussians are initialized for the cryo-ET experiments, including positions, masses, initial widths, and width limits at each binning stage. How are primitives smaller than the coarse sampling interval handled? Does every projection process all approximately 12 million Gaussians, and what fraction survives any culling? Are the multiple views per update rendered concurrently or processed sequentially with gradient accumulation? Please also clarify the modifications made to the original 3DGS rasterizer.
-
Minor presentation issue. Could you adjust the layout of the pipeline diagram? Several text labels overlap with graphical elements.
The proposed operator is promising, but the current experimental settings do not sufficiently establish its practical benefit for macromolecular reconstruction, and the claims of finer structural detail exceed the evidence presented. A convincing high-resolution evaluation through either single particle cryo-EM or subtomogram averaging, demonstrating an advantage over the matched ray operator with corresponding structural evidence, would address my main concern and lead me to raise my score.
3 comments
I appreciate the authors' clarifications and additional experiments. In particular, the experiments on AAV2 largely address my main concerns. The visual results support the improvements achieved by TPGA, which are also consistent with the results from cryoSPARC. I have therefore raised my rating.
Additionally, as SPA cryo-EM experiments have now been included in the paper and are crucial to supporting its central claim, I believe it is necessary to include relevant cryo-EM literature in the related work, such as conventional reconstruction methods like cryoSPARC[1] and RELION[2], as well as Gaussian-based methods like cryoSplat[3].
The following are merely recommendations, not critical weaknesses:
-
As I understand it, the central claim of this paper is to demonstrate the necessity and practical benefits of TPGA for Gaussian-based high-resolution reconstruction. To support this claim, I believe the AAV2 experiment should serve as the primary evidence and be given greater prominence, since it directly compares TPGA with WPOA and validates the proposed formulation.
-
Figure 1 could be further improved. I recommend rendering the equations using LaTeX for better visual quality.
References: [1] Punjani, A., Rubinstein, J. L., Fleet, D. J., & Brubaker, M. A. (2017). cryoSPARC: Algorithms for rapid unsupervised cryo-EM structure determination. Nature Methods, 14, 290–296. https://doi.org/10.1038/nmeth.4169
[2] Scheres, S. H. W. (2012). RELION: Implementation of a Bayesian approach to cryo-EM structure determination. Journal of Structural Biology, 180(3), 519–530. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsb.2012.09.006
[3] Chen, S., & Ling, H. (2026). CryoSplat: Gaussian Splatting for Cryo-EM Homogeneous Reconstruction. International Conference on Learning Representations (ICLR). https://openreview.net/forum?id=dLaUZKBzta
We thank the reviewer for raising the score and for the helpful suggestions.
Cryo-EM related work. Related Work (Section 3) now includes a paragraph on single-particle reconstruction: cryoSPARC [1] and RELION [2] as conventional voxel-based methods, and CryoSplat [3] as a Gaussian-based method. It also states that our AAV2 experiment uses cryoSPARC poses and CTFs, and that the TPGA and WPOA fits differ only in the projection operator.
Figure 1. All labels and equations in Figure 1 are now typeset in LaTeX.
Once again, thanks for the follow up and great insights!
Common Response
1. Testing the relevant regime [CW1, CW2, Q1, Q2]
Following the reviewer’s suggestion, we tested EMPIAR-10202, the AAV2 capsid dataset, at 0.788 Å/pixel and 300 kV (Section 5.3, Appendix I). This sampling allows testing at 2.1 Å, where the 250 Å capsid gives a half-depth Fresnel phase of about 1.75 rad, unlike the small phases in the cryo-ET tests. Wave/ray pairs share initialization and fitting settings with fixed CryoSPARC J2 poses and halves, giving four paired tests from two starts within one acquisition.
Model FSC improves by 0.0330 (SD 0.0020), but 6E9D is a same-data reference, not independent truth. All four high-frequency prediction intervals exclude zero, conditional on calibration using 48 test particles, and the 42% gain is relative correlation, not error reduction. Rendering as ray without refitting removes 90.6% of that gain (Table 25), while Q-scores use fixed coordinates without per-map fitting or sharpening, with residues not independent replicates (Figure 23). These results support a matched wave/ray benefit.
2. Cryo-ET structural claims [CW2, Q2]
Following the reviewer’s request, we compared matched regions with filtered/Topaz-denoised WBP and SIRT/SART, finding the same shells and broader submitted profiles, so we now claim improved contrast and background suppression rather than new structure (Figure 2). Views share a 1300 Å window, 80 Å slab and common 40 Å low-pass, with contrast scaled per panel.
Table 1 shows agreement gains on 10643 but not 10164, not structural resolution or missing-wedge recovery. The datasets use alternating-tilt and frame halves, respectively, and the 10164 visualization uses a separate 12M zero-mass fit, not the submitted WBP-initialized fit or the 3M baseline.
3. Initialization and subpixel Gaussians [Q3]
The submitted fits started from 12M WBP-based centers, sampled 90% by WBP weights and 10% uniformly, with equal masses totaling the WBP integral and σ=12 Å, then inherited bin 4, split to 10M at bin 2 and depth-cropped at bin 1.
The new baseline instead starts from 2.4M zero-mass lattice sites with small random displacements, aligned axes and σ=0.8 spacing, growing mass-conservingly to 3M at passes 20/40/60 with alignment/defocus fixed (Table 4 gives stage counts and bounds).
Gaussians remain continuous and are sampled at pixel centers, with physical width floors of 5.4/13.5 Å per axis/geometric mean, whereas the submitted p²/12 covariance addition approximated pixel-area integration.
4. Projection and rasterizer [Q3]
As requested, we checked culling: every projection processes all Gaussians, with none culled at bins 8/4/2 and at most 0.39% at bin 1 across five sampled views, versus 0 to 0.52% in submitted fits (Appendix A). Pixels evaluate only their 16 × 16 tile's list, with footprints extending about 5.7σ.
To clarify the view batching, each update processes eight views sequentially, averages their gradients and takes one optimizer step. Our renderer keeps the tiled design of 3DGS but replaces RGB compositing with additive complex splatting before transmission and microscope modeling, with batching and implementation details given in Appendix A.
5. Diagram [Q4]
Following the reviewer's suggestion, we corrected Figure 1 to separate labels from graphical elements and arrows.
Thank you for pointing us to EMPIAR-10202 (AAV2), which gave us the experimental macromolecular test missing from the submission and let us assess reconstruction benefits beyond forward-model accuracy. References are to the revised manuscript unless mentioned as submitted.