- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces Co-DIRECT, a method that improves joint protein sequence–structure generation by actively controlling how the two modalities, backbone coordinates and sequence latents, influence each other during sampling. The approach combines anticipation with a residue-wise directional router to determine which channel leads and which follows. Benchmark results show that Co-DIRECT reduces local errors and improves benchmark metrics compared with Proteina-Complexa and the RFdiffusion+MPNN pipeline.
Critical strengths
- Residue-wise routing serves as a control mechanism across the sequence and structure modalities, guiding coordination between the two modalities in terms of their rates of progression and quality.
- The work highlights that enabling cross-modal interactions does not necessarily ensure beneficial guidance. Turning these interactions into an explicit control mechanism may therefore be a meaningful step.
Critical weaknesses
- The ablation experiments remain incomplete. In the inference-time evaluations of fixed and shuffled roles, the reported intervals often include 0, which makes the residue-wise router appear unnecessary. Furthermore, the “no router” ablation changes several settings simultaneously, including roles and self-conditioning weights, making it difficult to isolate and clearly interpret the effects of individual components.
- The evaluation omits many co-design baselines, such as PXDesign. The limited and relatively dated selection of baselines makes it difficult to assess the value of the work accurately.
- The presentation lacks clarity. Many important numerical results are embedded in the text rather than presented systematically in tables or figures.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors provide more informative ablation experiments, including ablations of the router’s individual components, and clarify why residue-wise routing is necessary?
- Do the components of Co-DIRECT introduce substantial computational overhead? Given that downstream tasks often require a large number of design inference runs, can Co-DIRECT produce strong results with low computational overhead?