- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper works on the problem of de novo protein binder design with a model explicitly modeling sequence, structure and side-chain information. This work can be seen as a direct extension of Proteina-Atomistics on the task of binder design. The authors adapt the same architecture with an additional target conditioning module and propose to use consistency-distilled dimers to improve data consistency similarly as Proteina-Atomistica. The authors further propose a consistency-aware joint resampling strategy that iteratively refines sequences and side-chains. The experimental results do show improvements over latent-base methods like Complexa on both protein and ligand binder design.
Critical strengths
- Though the idea is similar to Proteina-Atomistica, it is still very interesting to show that explicitly modeling sequences and structures can work well for binder design. The extension of the model from monomer generation to binder generation is non-trivial, as seen in different mechanisms introduced in this paper, like consistency-distilled dataset and consistency-aware joint resampling.
- The improvement over Complexa on ligand-conditioned protein binder design is significant, which clearly shows the advantages of the model on in-silico benchmarks.
Critical weaknesses
- The main weakness of the paper is the novelty against Proteina-Atomistica. The model architecture and data distillation idea closely follow Proteina-Atomistica. The main methodological contribution is only the consistency-aware joint resampling strategy. That said, this weakness alone shouldn't lead to the rejection of the paper.
- Another potential concern is the additional time overhead introduced by atom encoder/decoder. The authors only report timing for ligand-conditioned binder design, which is ~4x slower than Complexa. Though not reported, I assume that for proteins, the model will be even slower, given the larger number of atoms in protein targets. This might limit the performance with inference-time search with a fixed time budget.
Questions for authors
- For Figure 3b, why do the authors select the best 100 values independently for each metric on each target instead of plotting the whole distribution? This selection process should appear in the figure caption or main text, instead of in the appendix.
- p. 9, lines 460–462. “Physical plausibility of the interface and local structures” is not directly measured. The evidence consists of prediction confidence and Cα RMSD. These do not directly assess side-chain recovery, clashes, bond geometry, chirality, rotamers, or interface energetics. The reported results support improved predictor confidence and backbone consistency; the broader claim about atomic physical plausibility needs additional measurements.
- The mean improvements are concentrated in a few targets in Table 9. For protein Self sequences, CODesign wins against Complexa on 9 targets, loses on 8, and ties on 2. BHRF1 and DerF21 contribute more than the entire net improvement.
- Efficiency comparison in Table 2 lack sufficient configuration details, including GPU, precision and compilation. Also, Efficiency comparison in Table 1 is missing.
7 comments
Rebuttal by Authors (2/5)
2. Response to computational efficiency (W2 & Q4)
Thank you for pointing out the computational overhead introduced by explicit atom modeling. We additionally measured the per-sample generation time on protein targets and investigated the performance–efficiency trade-off under reduced sampling steps on both protein and small-molecule targets.
All methods were evaluated on a single NVIDIA GeForce RTX 4090. CODesign and Complexa were run using FP32 with TF32 enabled for matrix multiplications, without FP16/BF16 autocast or torch.compile. For other baselines, we followed the default precision and compilation settings in their respective official repositories.
The per-sample generation times on protein targets are summarized below:
| Method | Time (s) ↓ |
|---|---|
| RFDiffusion3 | 17.64 |
| PXDesign | 8.51 |
| Protpardelle-1c | 5.25 |
| Complexa | 8.52 |
| CODesign (1,000 global updates) | 28.41 |
| CODesign (400 global updates) | 11.89 |
The default CODesign sampling configuration uses 1,000 global updates, with 500 active updates for the backbone and sequence modalities and 1,000 updates for local atomic refinement. We further investigated reducing the number of global updates while maintaining the same modality schedules. In particular, using 400 global updates (200 backbone updates, 200 sequence updates, and 400 local atom updates), CODesign achieves 9.47 mean unique successes with a generation time of 11.89 seconds per sample.
Notably, this reduced-step configuration retains a higher mean number of unique successes than Complexa (9.47 vs. 8.54) under the Self sequence setting, representing a 10.9% improvement. Meanwhile, its inference time is substantially faster than RFDiffusion3 (11.89s vs. 17.64s). Although CODesign is not the fastest approach, these results demonstrate that reducing the sampling budget substantially improves its efficiency while preserving competitive binder design performance.
We further evaluated the same 400-update configuration on the four small-molecule targets. The per-target and mean unique successes are summarized below:
| Method | SAM ↑ | OQO ↑ | FAD ↑ | IAI ↑ | Mean ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Complexa | 3.20 | 3.00 | 5.80 | 8.40 | 5.10 |
| CODesign (1,000 global updates) | 5.80 | 37.20 | 21.40 | 18.60 | 20.80 |
| CODesign (400 global updates) | 5.00 | 30.00 | 17.67 | 16.00 | 17.17 |
On small-molecule targets, the 400-update configuration outperforms Complexa on all four targets, achieving 3.37× the mean unique successes (17.17 vs. 5.10) at only 1.41× the per-sample generation time (14.50s vs. 10.27s). Thus, the improvement in unique successes substantially exceeds the relative increase in generation time. Moreover, compared with our default 1,000-update configuration, reducing the sampling budget to 400 updates lowers generation time from 39.90 to 14.50 seconds (a 63.7% reduction), while retaining the highest mean unique successes among the evaluated baselines.
Rebuttal by Authors (3/5)
3. Response to the distribution plotting (Q1)
We apologize for any confusion. Our intention was to investigate how CODIMER improves the quality of generated designs with respect to the metrics relevant to our success criteria. Specifically, for each target and each metric, we plotted the 100 most favorable values independently (i.e., the lower 100 values for ipAE and scRMSD, and the higher 100 values for pLDDT). This visualization focuses on the higher-quality portion of the generated samples, making the differences between the two variants easier to inspect without the lower-quality tail dominating the displayed range. We agree that this selection should have been explicitly stated in the figure caption, and will clarify it in the revised manuscript.
To complement this visualization, we additionally calculated the mean values of all generated samples, without any truncation. The results are as follows:
| Variant | ipAE (Å) ↓ | pLDDT ↑ | Binder scRMSD (Å) ↓ | Complex scRMSD (Å) ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CODesign w/o CODIMER | 19.155 | 0.811 | 0.891 | 7.515 |
| CODesign | 17.684 | 0.826 | 0.754 | 6.322 |
The full-sample statistics consistently favor CODesign trained with CODIMER across all four metrics. Specifically, CODIMER reduces the mean ipAE by 1.471 Å, increases pLDDT by 0.015, reduces binder scRMSD by 0.137 Å, and reduces complex scRMSD by 1.193 Å. These results further demonstrate that CODIMER improves both predicted interface confidence and structural consistency across the generated samples, rather than merely improving the selected high-quality portion shown in Figure 3b.
Rebuttal by Authors (1/5)
We are grateful for your constructive feedback and thoughtful evaluation of our work. Below are our responses to your concerns.
1. Response to the novelty against Proteína-Atomística (W1)
Thank you for raising this important point. We acknowledge that CODesign builds upon the explicit multimodal flow-matching framework and the residue–atom architecture of Proteína-Atomística. However, our work goes beyond directly applying this architecture to a new task. We introduce several task-specific extensions to address the challenges of target-conditioned all-atom binder co-design:
New Task: Target-Conditioned All-Atom Binder Co-Design. Proteína-Atomística primarily focuses on unconditional de novo protein generation, whereas CODesign addresses the more challenging task of generating protein binders conditioned on either protein or small-molecule targets. This requires explicitly modeling binder–target interactions rather than only the internal distribution of a protein. Unlike Complexa, which models target latent representations, we directly let the designed binder and target interact within Euclidean space. Therefore, we incorporate binder–target geometric features into the joint pair representations and pair-biased attention. We further introduce a binder–target distance supervision objective to guide the global positioning of generated binders. These designs enable a unified framework for both protein- and ligand-conditioned binder generation.
New Dataset: CODIMER. While Proteína-Atomística introduces consistency distillation for monomeric protein generation, we extend this principle to protein complexes. Specifically, we construct CODIMER from 191,836 reference dimers collected from AFDB high-confidence heterodimers, HumanPPI, and PINDER. For each complex, we jointly redesign both chains using ProteinMPNN, co-fold the redesigned sequences using ESMFold2-Fast, and select confidence-qualified sequence–structure pairs based on complex-level structural consistency. This yields 104,528 consistency-distilled dimer pairs, providing sequence–structure supervision that explicitly captures intermolecular interfaces and complex-level consistency. We have also proved the effectiveness of CODIMER's complex-level consistency distillation (Reviewer qxm7|Response 1).
New Methodology: Consistency-Aware Joint Resampling (CAR). This is our main algorithmic contribution beyond Proteína-Atomística. Unlike standard stochastic remasking, CAR leverages the model's intrinsic inverse-folding capability to identify residue identities that are incompatible with the evolving predicted backbone. It selectively resamples these residues together with their local atomic states, while incorporating the revised sequence into self-conditioning so that subsequent backbone predictions can also adapt. Importantly, CAR obtains its correction signal directly from the generator, without requiring external folding or inverse-folding models or reward-guided search.
In summary, CODesign extends the explicit all-atom co-design paradigm from unconditional monomer generation to target-conditioned binder design, with consistency addressed at three complementary levels: target-aware joint modeling, complex-level data distillation, and trajectory-level correction. We believe these contributions constitute a meaningful extension beyond Proteína-Atomística.