- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4(+2)
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a ligand conditioned diffusion language model for co-designing the protein sequence and structure. This motivation is too natural (transferred from the continuous diffusion model), to the point where it feels lacking in novelty. But the experiment seem to show strong performance compared to previous work.
Critical strengths
- The experiments in this paper are somewhat rich and the claimed improvement is somewhat significant.
- The proposed innovation is very natural.
Critical weaknesses
- The writing of this paper is very poor: Abbreviations without any explanation exist in the abstract; the content of the introduction is like Related Work and the Related Work is like Preliminaries. I understand that ligand-conditioning is important for DISCRETE DIFFUSION IN PROTEIN DESIGN and there is a gap in this community, but it is hard for me to extract from the introduction what innovation or changes this paper has made for it. The summary of contributions is very abrupt and difficult to connect with the previous paragraphs.
- Technological innovation seems to be limited, and the most important thing is to contribute new datasets. I can hardly tell from the introduction what specific innovation this paper has made to fill the gap.
Questions for authors
- Please explain the abbreviation in abstract: MDLM.
- Can you explain in detail your algorithm or innovation details?
- Why is your standard deviation larger than the mean in Tables 1 and 3? Does this make sense?
10 comments
Request for substantive follow-up and justification of the clear-rejection rating
Dear Reviewer C8bG,
We are following up on our response posted on 8 November, which remains unanswered two days later. We provided explanations addressing your questions about MDLM, the conditioning mechanism, and the reported standard deviations. We request a substantive response identifying which concerns remain unresolved.
Please address the following points directly:
-
What specifically supports your novelty assessment? Please identify the relevant prior work or explain which methodological additions you consider insufficient. Describing the motivation as “too natural” does not explain why the proposed extension and its empirical findings constitute an inadequate contribution.
-
Which parts of our response are insufficient? If our explanations do not address your questions, please identify the remaining issues precisely. Without this clarification, we cannot determine what further explanation or evidence you consider necessary.
-
What are the decisive grounds for the rating of 1 (“clear rejection”)? Your review acknowledges the capability gap and empirical improvements and describes the soundness concerns as “minor or fixable.” Novelty and presentation can independently affect the overall assessment, but please explain which specific weaknesses you consider decisive and how our response affects or fails to affect that judgment.
Our request for the technical basis of your assessment remains unanswered. If you maintain the clear-rejection recommendation, please explain why the methodological details, experimental evidence, ablation studies and our response are insufficient to address the concerns underlying that recommendation.
We request a prompt, point-by-point reply during the discussion period so that we have an opportunity to address any remaining substantive concerns. We also ask the Area Chair to help facilitate this follow-up, ensuring that both the authors’ response and the reviewer’s reasoning are available for assessment.
Dear Authors,
The decisive reason for my rating of 1 is the poor presentation. I did not criticize the novelty of this paper; on the contrary, I praised the naturalness of the idea in the Strengths section. I fully recognize the effort every author put into this work, and I am generally tolerant in my reviews—including this one. I sincerely offer the following writing suggestions. If any come across as offensive, please take them as well-intentioned advice.
First, avoid using bold emphasis in large blocks of text. Overuse of emphasis dilutes its effect and obscures your intended message.
Second, in lines 67–76 of the manuscript, you should briefly inform readers of the specific methodological choices you made to introduce ligand conditioning. It does not need to be overly detailed, but leaving it blank forces readers to guess based solely on the phrase “ligand condition.”
Third, please draw clearer boundaries between the Introduction, Related Work, and Preliminaries. Their roles currently overlap, which confuses the narrative.
Finally, while I personally know what MDLM stands for, you cannot assume all readers do. Introducing abbreviations without definition violates standard writing conventions.
If the presentation had been adequate from the outset, I would have assigned a rating of 3 with a confidence of 3. As it stands, however, the necessary revisions are too extensive for the manuscript to be considered publishable in its present form.
Clarifying methodological contributions and statistical reporting, and requesting concrete technical support for the novelty assessment
We disagree with the basis of your assessment of novelty and informativeness. You acknowledge an important capability gap and strong experimental results, yet characterize the contribution as limited because the motivation is “too natural.” That characterization does not explain which methodological additions are already established or why the demonstrated extension lacks scientific value. We address your concerns directly below.
1. The novelty criticism requires a concrete technical comparison. Our paper addresses ligand-conditioned joint sequence–structure generation within discrete diffusion protein modeling. Assessing this contribution requires examining the capabilities of prior discrete models, the conditioning mechanism we introduce, and the resulting experimental evidence.
Your review does not identify the prior methods underlying your novelty judgment or explain which specific additions you consider insufficient. A research objective can be intuitive while its implementation and empirical investigation remain meaningful contributions. The naturalness of the motivation does not, by itself, establish that the contribution is limited.
Please specify the relevant prior work and explain how it supports your assessment of our methodological contribution.
2. The contribution extends beyond dataset construction. Your characterization of the dataset as the principal contribution does not address the conditioning mechanism described in Section 3.2 and Appendix B.
ProtLiD² jointly denoises amino-acid and structure tokens under explicit ligand conditioning. Ligand chemical representations and coordinate embeddings enter the denoising network through geometry-aware cross-attention. Protein-token hidden states produce learned proxy coordinates; distances between those proxies and ligand atoms are transformed into radial-basis-function features and head-specific attention biases. This mechanism allows ligand geometry to influence both sequence and structure predictions throughout denoising.
The dataset supports learning this conditional model. The model formulation, conditioning mechanism, and empirical investigation are additional contributions. For example, active-site backbone self-consistency RMSD is 1.97 Å for ProtLiD², compared with 3.46 Å for FAIR and 3.40 Å for PocketGen. These are computational self-consistency results, and we interpret them within that scope.
We explicitly acknowledge the existing tokenizer, ligand encoder, and diffusion formulation on which we build. Assessing the contribution requires evaluating what our extension enables and demonstrates; identifying its existing components is not sufficient.
3. Presentation concerns and methodological novelty require separate assessments. MDLM denotes a masked diffusion language model. Its formulation appears in Section 2.2. We agree that the abbreviation should also be expanded at its first occurrence in the abstract, and we will make that correction.
We will also streamline the introduction and separate mathematical preliminaries from related work. These changes will make the connection between the gap, the conditioning mechanism, and the experimental evidence more explicit.
However, difficulty extracting a contribution from the introduction does not establish that the contribution is technically limited. Your review repeatedly makes the former observation without providing the technical comparison needed to substantiate the latter. The method section and appendix describe the proposed mechanisms; please identify which of those mechanisms you consider insufficient and explain why.
4. A standard deviation larger than the mean is mathematically valid. In response to your statistical question: yes, this can occur for nonnegative measurements. There is no requirement that their standard deviation be smaller than their mean. For example, 1,1,1,1,11 have a mean of 3 and a population standard deviation of 4.
The reported pattern occurs across the compared methods. Table 1 reports global backbone RMSD of 12.07±13.16 Å for ProtLiD² and 10.35±11.24 Å for Complexa. In Table 3, global backbone RMSD has a standard deviation exceeding the mean for all three methods.
The large dispersion warrants attention to performance variability, and we will clarify the aggregation procedure. SD exceeding the mean does not, by itself, indicate an invalid calculation or invalidate the comparison.
We welcome specific criticism of the formulation, evaluation, and interpretation. However, we find the clear-rejection recommendation insufficiently substantiated by the reasoning currently provided. Please explain which methodological additions you consider inadequate, which prior comparisons support that judgment, and which experimental conclusions you dispute. These concrete technical points are necessary to make the basis of your assessment assessable.