- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces WForge, a no-box and query-free image watermark forgery attack. WForge treats forgery as the inverse of watermark removal, using removal residuals as supervision to train a network that predicts watermark-like perturbations for clean images. Experiments across multiple watermarking schemes and datasets show that WForge significantly outperforms existing forgery baselines. The paper also studies the relationship between watermark removal and forgery from a residual-based perspective.
Critical strengths
- This paper studies an important and relatively under-explored attack scenario. Most existing studies focus on watermark removal, while watermark forgery can also cause serious problems for traceability and the source system. WForge considers a strict non-black-box environment where the attacker cannot access the watermark detector or its API, making this attack scenario practically significant.
- The proposed method is simple and has good experimental results. The experimental results show that this method is indeed effective under the evaluated conditions, and it strongly supports the idea presented in the paper of extracting supervision from the residual information of the watermark removal. Extensive ablation studies have also verified the effectiveness of the proposed method.
Critical weaknesses
1.The assumptions underlying the WForge method have not been fully proven. This method assumes that the residuals generated after watermark removal can serve as an alternative indicator of the actual watermark signal. However, experiments have shown that different removal methods produce completely different residuals, leading to significantly different forgery performance. Therefore, it is unclear under what circumstances the removal residuals mainly capture information related to the watermark rather than the reconstruction artifacts caused by a specific removal algorithm. 2.Compared with the recent watermark forgery methods, the research scope is limited. This paper mainly compares WForge with Watermark Faker and Watermark Steganalysis. A closely related recent work, "WMCopier: Forging Invisible Watermarks on Arbitrary Images" (Dong et al., NeurIPS 2025), studies similar out-of-box forgery scenarios and evaluates overlapping watermark methods such as RivaGAN and Stable Signature. A comparison with WMCopier would help to more fully demonstrate the experimental advantages of WForge.
Questions for authors
The proposed method relies on the assumption that the residual produced by a watermark remover can serve as a good surrogate for the actual watermark residual. Could the authors provide a more principled justification for this assumption? In particular, why should R'(Iw)-Iw) mainly capture watermark-related information rather than remover-specific reconstruction artifacts, and how can one determine whether a given removal method will produce residuals suitable for forgery?