- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes ProxyEraseAgent, a blind watermark-removal framework that removes invisible image watermarks without accessing the target decoder or knowing the underlying watermarking algorithm. The framework retrieves informative proxy decoders from a knowledge base of publicly available watermarking models and uses their responses to guide adaptive watermark-removal attacks through sequential search. Experiments across 11 watermarking systems report an overall constrained attack success rate (cASR) of 94.8%, outperforming existing baselines.
Critical strengths
-
Interesting and practical attack setting. The paper investigates blind watermark removal, where attackers have access only to watermarked images without querying the target decoder. This is a relevant security problem for real-world watermarking systems.
-
Interesting proxy-guided attack framework. ProxyEraseAgent combines response-guided proxy decoder retrieval with sequential attack planning, enabling adaptive composition of different watermark-removal operations without direct feedback from the target decoder.
Critical weaknesses
-
Insufficient validation of the proxy decoder selection assumption. The proposed response strength is derived from the prediction certainty of watermark bits. However, a decoder may produce highly confident bit predictions even for images watermarked by unrelated algorithms. Such confidence only reflects the decoder's own prediction certainty and does not necessarily indicate similar decision boundaries or transferable responses to perturbations. Although entropy-based selection outperforms random selection, the paper lacks a direct analysis of the correlation between calibrated response strength and actual attack transferability.
-
Insufficient comparison with strong watermark-removal baselines. The paper compares ProxyEraseAgent with several transformation-based and dedicated watermark-removal attacks, but omits relevant methods such as A Transfer Attack to Image Watermarks[1] and RAVEN[2], which are discussed in the related work. Comparisons with these methods under consistent threat models would help establish the effectiveness of the proposed approach.
-
Questionable attack success criterion. The paper defines a successful attack as achieving BER ≥ 0.1 under LPIPS ≤ 0.05. However, a 10% bit error rate does not necessarily indicate successful watermark removal, particularly for watermarking systems with error-correction capabilities or different detection thresholds. The authors should report actual watermark detection failure rates and verify that the original watermarks are correctly recoverable before applying attacks.
-
Potentially unfair optimization and search budgets. ProxyEraseAgent benefits from multi-step Pareto beam search, while the evaluated baselines do not necessarily receive comparable optimization budgets. The ablation study shows that increasing the search depth from one to four improves cASR from 83.91% to 94.82%. Comparisons under matched GPU time or optimization budgets are needed to determine whether the improvements arise from the proposed proxy guidance or additional computation.
-
Limited evaluation scale and image resolution. The experiments use only 100 MS-COCO images, with all images resized to 128×128. Some watermarking systems also require higher internal resolutions, with their outputs subsequently resized to 128×128, potentially affecting watermark integrity. Evaluations on larger datasets and higher-resolution images would strengthen the practical applicability claims.
[1] Hu, Yuepeng, et al. "A transfer attack to image watermarks." International Conference on Learning Representations. Vol. 2025. 2025.
[2] Shamshad, Fahad, Nils Lukas, and Karthik Nandakumar. "RAVEN: Erasing Invisible Watermarks via Novel View Synthesis." CVPR 2026.
Questions for authors
-
Proxy decoder selection. Could the authors evaluate the correlation between calibrated response strength and actual attack transferability to validate the assumption behind proxy decoder selection?
-
Baseline comparison. Could the authors include stronger watermark-removal baselines, particularly A Transfer Attack to Image Watermarks[1] and RAVEN[2], under comparable threat models?
-
Attack success criterion. Why is BER ≥ 0.1 considered sufficient for successful watermark removal? Could the authors report actual watermark detection failure rates and initial watermark recovery accuracy?
-
Optimization fairness. How does ProxyEraseAgent compare with existing baselines under identical GPU time or optimization budgets? Would additional optimization or multi-step search improve the performance of the baselines?
-
Evaluation scale and resolution. How does ProxyEraseAgent perform on larger datasets and higher-resolution images? Does resizing watermarked images to 128×128 affect their initial watermark integrity and the reported attack success rates?
[1] Hu, Yuepeng, et al. "A transfer attack to image watermarks." International Conference on Learning Representations. Vol. 2025. 2025.
[2] Shamshad, Fahad, Nils Lukas, and Karthik Nandakumar. "RAVEN: Erasing Invisible Watermarks via Novel View Synthesis." CVPR 2026.