- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents SwiftRegen, an efficient watermark evasion attack that replaces the original iterative regeneration process with a single-pass operator. Based on two key insights, it proposes a bounded residual predictor and Watermark Carrier Desynchronization (WCD), which employs mild cropping and resizing to disrupt synchronization while largely preserving visual content. By combining these two techniques, SwiftRegen achieves strong performance across eleven watermarking schemes.
Critical strengths
1. Effective, Efficient, and Generalizable Watermark Evasion. The paper proposes an effective and efficient watermark evasion method that demonstrates strong generalization across different watermarking schemes. The authors also conduct extensive experiments and provide comprehensive evaluations to validate the effectiveness of the proposed approach.
2. Insights into Watermark Robustness. The value of this work lies not only in proposing an effective attack method but also in revealing potential vulnerabilities in existing watermark detection systems, providing useful insights into their robustness and limitations.
Critical weaknesses
1. Insufficiently Justified Motivation. The primary motivation of this work is to reduce the computational overhead of CtrlRegen's iterative regeneration process. However, the authors do not sufficiently explain why inference efficiency is a critical bottleneck in existing watermark removal attacks or what practical attack scenarios would require efficient, large-scale watermark removal. As a result, the connection between the need for improved efficiency and the underlying threat model remains underdeveloped.
2. Lack of Real Computational Cost Analysis. SwiftRegen requires running CtrlRegen in advance to generate a large number of training image pairs, followed by training an additional model. Although this approach improves inference efficiency, it essentially shifts the computational overhead to offline data generation and model training. When accounting for these additional costs, at what scale of watermark removal can the upfront computational overhead be amortized? Is this trade-off computationally worthwhile in practice?
3. Limited Novelty Beyond Combining Existing Attacks. SwiftRegen consists of two relatively independent components, and the strong results in Table 1 may largely stem from combining two existing attack mechanisms. Existing studies suggest that certain content-agnostic watermarks (e.g., Tree-Ring) are vulnerable to geometric perturbations, such as rotation [1][2] and translation [3], while content-dependent watermarks (e.g., Stable Signature) are susceptible to reconstruction-based attacks [4][5]. Therefore, it is not surprising that a method like SwiftRegen (small U-Net CtrlRegen + WCD), which combines two attack mechanisms, achieves better performance than methods targeting only a single type of watermark. It would be beneficial to include additional ablation results in Table 1, similar to those presented in Table 2, such as SwiftRegen( only) and SwiftRegen( + C).
4. Figure Quality and Readability. The figures in the paper could benefit from further refinement, particularly in terms of formatting and attention to detail. For example, in Figure 4, some numerical labels overlap with the bars, while in Figure 5, the legend overlaps with the plotted lines.
Questions for authors
- As discussed in Q3, SwiftRegen combines two attack mechanisms. It is therefore reasonable that SwiftRegen achieves attack performance similar to that of the better-performing variant between SwiftRegen w/o WCD and WCD only. However, the results for Tree-Ring suggest an additional synergistic effect. Could the authors provide further analysis, supporting experiments, or a more detailed explanation for this observation?
- SwiftRegen heavily relies on CtrlRegen as a core component, despite the existence of various regeneration-based watermark removal attacks. Could the authors clarify the rationale behind choosing CtrlRegen? Have they explored using alternative regeneration-based attacks or combining different watermark removal methods to generate more diverse training data?
[1] Dongjun Hwang, Sungwon Woo, Tom Gao, Raymond Luo, and Sunghwan Baek. Invisible watermarks: Attacks and robustness. arXiv preprint arXiv:2412.12511, 2024.
[2] Cheng-Han Yeh, Kuan-chun Yu, Cheng-Chang Tsai, and Chun-Shien Lu. On the intrinsic limited robustness of latent-based watermarking. arXiv preprint arXiv:2610.08178, 2026.
[3] Xiaoxi Kong, Jieyu Yuan, Pengdi Chen, Yuanlin Zhang, Chongyi Li, and Bin Li. MarkCleaner: High-fidelity watermark removal via imperceptible micro-geometric perturbation. arXiv preprint arXiv:2602.01513, 2026.
[4] Xuandong Zhao, Kexun Zhang, Zihao Su, Saastha Vasan, Ilya Grishchenko, Christopher Kruegel,Giovanni Vigna, Yu-Xiang Wang, and Lei Li. Invisible image watermarks are provably removable using generative ai. In Advances in neural information processing systems, 2024.
[5] Yepeng Liu, Yiren Song, Hai Ci, Yu Zhang, Haofan Wang, Mike Zheng Shou, and Yuheng Bu. Image watermarks are removable using controllable regeneration from clean noise. In International Conference on Learning Representations, 2025.