- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces RESON, a watermarking method designed to preserve source information across multiple generations of an image, even when different generative models are involved. RESON embeds a keyed, message-bearing watermark into the initial diffusion noise using a combination of structured and white-noise carriers. A lightweight decoder then detects the watermark and recovers its payload without requiring diffusion inversion or modifications to downstream models.
Critical strengths
The problem setting is interesting and relevant to the audience. Basically, the paper goes beyond conventional single-step watermark robustness and investigates whether source information can survive multiple heterogeneous generative transformations. I find this setting meaningful, particularly since downstream models do not need to cooperate or reinsert the watermark.
RESON maintains strong detection performance across several regeneration steps and generally outperforms the evaluated baselines at later depths.
Critical weaknesses
However, the novelty seems limited compared to existing methods. The method is closely related to SERUM (ICLR 2026), which also modifies initial diffusion noise and uses a lightweight detector without inversion. RESON mainly changes the carrier construction and introduces a multi-hop evaluation setting. The improvement over it seems relatively small too; it would be better for the paper to have a stronger evidence that the proposed carrier provides a meaningful methodological advantage rather than an incremental modification.
Generative transformations are of limited diversity. The multi-hop experiments use the original prompt at every generation, a fixed image-to-image strength of 0.5, and a relatively small collection of model families. In practice, images may undergo prompt changes, inpainting, object replacement, or stronger regeneration. It is unclear whether the reported persistence would hold under these less controlled settings.
Also, moving to the multi-bit setting, the multi-bit performance is considerably weaker. While the paper emphasizes 92.5% detection at G4, this corresponds to the one-bit setting. For four-bit payloads, detection TPR drops to 54.0%, and for eight-bit payloads it drops to 36.4%. Exact-message recovery also falls to 78.4% and 34.2%, respectively. These results substantially limit practical source attribution. The paper should report end-to-end verification accuracy, requiring both successful detection and correct message recovery.
Another concern is incomplete security evaluation. The paper does not evaluate adaptive watermark removal, multi-image carrier estimation, or forgery attacks. Since the carrier is deterministically generated from a secret key, these are important threats, especially when many images share the same watermark. Robustness against watermark-unaware regeneration alone is insufficient to establish reliable source provenance.
Missing literature: Several works need discussion/comparison; e.g., MOLM (ICLR 2026), GROW (CVPR 2026), SPDMark (CVPR 2026), Semantic Watermarking Reinvented (ICCV 2025), SEAL (ICCV 2025), Guidance Watermarking (ICLR 2026).
Controlled experiments for fair analysis would benefit the paper; e.g., matched watermark strength, payload, and image quality.
Questions for authors
Please refer to the weaknesses above.
10 comments
W2 - Diversity of Generative Transformations
We agree that a broader range of transformations would make the evaluation more informative. Alongside the existing heterogeneous SD2.1 → FLUX.1-dev → RealVisXL → DreamShaperXL → FLUX.1-dev lineage and alternative generator orders, we evaluated prompt-modified FLUX regeneration, localized SDXL inpainting, and regeneration-strength variation.
Prompt modifications. Using 100 matched clean/watermarked pairs per condition, the frozen detector produced:
| FLUX prompt condition | TPR (%) | Realized FPR (%) |
|---|---|---|
| Original prompt | 96.0 | 0.0 |
| Style-modified prompt | 97.0 | 1.0 |
| Semantic-modified prompt | 95.0 | 1.0 |
Localized generative editing. SDXL inpainting yielded:
| Masked image region | TPR (%) | Realized FPR (%) |
|---|---|---|
| 10% | 99.0 | 0.0 |
| 25% | 96.0 | 2.0 |
| 40% | 87.0 | 2.0 |
Regeneration strength. In the separate regeneration-severity sweep, TPR@1% FPR was 98.8%, 98.6%, 98.0%, and 94.4% for strengths 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, and 0.8, respectively. This sweep uses condition-specific operating thresholds and should not be interpreted as a single frozen-threshold comparison.
These experiments directly test whether a downstream generator can alter the prompt or a localized image region while the source watermark remains detectable. Even with 40% inpainting, detection remains at 87.0% TPR, and with semantic prompt changes it remains at 95.0% TPR. They complement, rather than replace, the heterogeneous multi-hop evaluation. The new prompt-change and inpainting results appear in Section 4, “Robustness to perturbations and deliberate removal,” and Appendix A.4.3, “Prompt-Modified Regeneration and Localized Generative Editing” (Table 10; label tab:prompt_inpaint). The transformation-scope clarification appears in Section 5, “Discussion and Limitations.” These additions are marked in red in the revised manuscript. The regeneration-strength sweep appears in Appendix A.4.2 (the regeneration-severity table, label tab:regen_severity).
W3 - Multi-bit Payload and End-to-End Verification
We appreciate the reviewer’s request for a stricter operational measure of source verification. One-bit presence detection and multi-bit message verification measure different outcomes. The headline 92.50% G4 TPR refers to the one-bit configuration. To evaluate operational multi-bit verification, we additionally require both a positive presence decision and exact recovery of all payload bits, using the original validation-frozen detection thresholds and 1,000 watermarked plus 1,000 clean held-out images at each lineage depth.
| Depth | 4-bit joint success (%) | 4-bit presence FPR (%) | 8-bit joint success (%) | 8-bit presence FPR (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| G0 | 91.9 | 1.5 | 58.6 | 1.8 |
| G1 | 78.2 | 1.1 | 37.9 | 1.6 |
| G2 | 60.0 | 1.1 | 25.4 | 0.8 |
| G3 | 47.8 | 0.9 | 18.5 | 1.1 |
| G4 | 48.0 | 0.8 | 17.8 | 1.0 |
At G4, joint verification succeeds for 48.0% of four-bit and 17.8% of eight-bit watermarked images, compared with presence-detection rates of 54.0% and 36.4%, respectively. The table's FPR values concern presence detection on clean images, not message-specific false acceptance.
These end-to-end results are added in Section 4, “Payload Capacity and Persistent Information” (Table 6, joint verification), and Section 5, “Discussion and Limitations,” under “End-to-end verification and payload capacity.” The additions are marked in red. The joint criterion is more stringent than either detection or payload decoding alone and makes the capacity–robustness trade-off explicit: four-bit verification remains measurable at G4, while eight-bit verification is considerably weaker. This distinguishes evidence of persistent watermark presence from reliable recovery of a complete source identifier.
W1 - Novelty and Comparison with SERUM
We appreciate the reviewer’s concern about the distinction from SERUM. Both methods modify the initial diffusion noise and use inversion-free detection. RESON combines a keyed, bit-conditioned structured–stochastic carrier, joint presence-and-payload decoding, and an insert-once, detect-later evaluation of source-payload persistence through heterogeneous multi-hop regeneration, without downstream reinsertion or detector adaptation. Section 2 (Related Work, “Diffusion watermarking”) clarifies the methodological distinction (highlighted in blue in the revised manuscript), while Section 4.1 (“Multi-hop persistence and matched baselines,” Table 1) reports the cross-method lineage comparison. The Introduction additionally distinguishes the headline one-bit detection result from multi-bit verification (highlighted in red).
Descriptive comparison with SERUM. Table 1 of the manuscript compares RESON and SERUM under the heterogeneous G0–G4 lineage protocol. The results are reproduced below to make the comparison explicit.
At G4, the observed TPR is 92.50% for RESON and 89.33% for SERUM, with AUCs of 0.9963 and 0.9916. These are descriptive differences of 3.17 percentage points in TPR and 0.0047 in AUC; we do not infer statistical superiority without a paired analysis of these exact predictions. More importantly, the evaluation tests whether source-embedded information survives repeated regeneration by different model families, rather than only a single generation or a conventional image perturbation.
Carrier-mechanism evidence. At fixed injection strength α=0.155, we ablate the RESON carrier composition with separate detectors and validation-frozen operating thresholds. This experiment examines carrier structure within RESON; it is not a direct substitution of SERUM’s carrier.
The white-only carrier falls to 1.7% G4 TPR, compared with 64.3% for the mixed carrier and 81.7% for the structured-only carrier. The large gap between white-only and structured configurations indicates that the structured component is important for persistence. The structured-only variant achieves the strongest detection in this ablation; the mixed carrier is the canonical configuration; this ablation alone does not establish an optimal fidelity--robustness trade-off. These results appear in Table 5 (Controlled carrier-mechanism ablation), Section 4, “Carrier Design and Operating-Point Analysis.” The ablation isolates how structured and stochastic carrier components affect persistence within RESON.