- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper identifies the loss of spatial detail and the inadequate representation of class composition and valid coverage in categorical geographic information as problems in the use of auxiliary information for cloud removal. To address these problems, the authors propose native-resolution readout and support-centered geographic conditioning to improve the use of auxiliary information in diffusion-based reconstruction. The proposed methods achieve competitive reconstruction results on SEN12MS-CR and CloudRGB.
Critical strengths
The paper focuses on how auxiliary information is represented and used in cloud removal reconstruction, identifying two problems: the loss of spatial detail and the conflation of class composition with missing coverage. These problems are directly related to differences in the spatial structure and coverage of multisource remote sensing data, and the research motivation merits recognition.
Critical weaknesses
-
The proposed native-resolution readout and support-centered geographic conditioning are two independent methods developed for different settings. The two methods lack methodological coherence, and the authors’ attempt to unify them under “conditioning-representation mismatch” is somewhat unconvincing. Specifically, the authors investigate the loss of fine spatial detail caused by spatial coarsening of continuous optical–SAR conditioning features on SEN12MS-CR, while studying the representation of class composition and valid coverage in categorical geographic conditions on CloudRGB. Developing a separate method for each specific dataset provides insufficient evidence of applicability to broader real-world settings.
-
The paper lacks technical details related to diffusion. Are these updates performed within each sampling step or after sampling is completed? Section 3.1 mentions reconstructing RGB through a codec and a dense readout, but Figures 1 and 3 do not separately show the codec or explain its specific connections to the latent DiT, the readout embedding, and the final RGB output. The main text does not specify the configuration of the base restoration model. Although Figures 1 and 3 indicate SAR inputs, they do not specifically explain how SAR is encoded and fused in the base latent-space restorer. These omissions limit the reproducibility of the work.
Questions for authors
Please address the concerns raised in the Critical Weaknesses section.