- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes PReVIEW, a framework for aerial–ground person re-identification that introduces bidirectional cross-view feature prediction during training. Given an image from one platform, a platform-conditioned predictor uses its global representation and learnable region queries to predict regional features of a same-identity image from the other platform. An exponential-moving-average target encoder provides the prediction targets. The prediction objective is jointly optimized with identity classification and triplet losses. At inference, only the online encoder and BNNeck are retained, so the auxiliary components introduce no additional inference cost relative to the backbone baseline. Experiments on multiple aerial–ground benchmarks demonstrate substantial improvements over the reported Swin-B baseline.
Critical strengths
1.The paper clearly motivates the difficulty of learning identity representations across the substantial appearance gap between aerial and ground views. Its cross-view prediction objective provides a concrete way to exploit same-identity observations from both platforms, and the connection between the problem and the proposed training task is easy to follow.
2.The paper presents an extensive experimental evaluation across multiple aerial–ground person re-identification benchmarks and diverse retrieval protocols. It also includes ablation studies on prediction direction, prediction loss weight, and the number of target regions, together with qualitative retrieval examples. This broad coverage allows readers to assess the method under different evaluation settings and understand the influence of its key design choices, providing a substantial empirical basis for the paper.
Critical weaknesses
1.Although PReVIEW improves its own baseline, its advantages over strong existing methods remain insufficiently characterized. In Table 1, its CARGO cross-view mAP is 61.25, compared with 69.00 for ViSA and 70.53 for HiHR; it also does not lead any metric on AG-ReID.v2 in Table 5. A clearer comparison of backbones, pretraining, auxiliary supervision, and computational costs would help establish when PReVIEW offers an advantage. Its potential complementarity with stronger existing methods also remains unexplored.
2.Table 3 compares the classification-and-triplet baseline with variants of predictive supervision, but it omits a straightforward control: adding a direct feature-alignment loss between same-identity aerial and ground images. Without this comparison, it remains unclear whether a simpler additional alignment loss could yield similar improvements. This is particularly relevant because the introduction explicitly motivates PReVIEW through the limitations of direct alignment.
3.Figure 1 motivates the method using concrete identity cues, such as aerial head–shoulder contours and ground-view clothing textures or shoe details. However, the experiments do not examine whether PReVIEW actually retains and uses these cues more effectively than direct alignment. Figure 4 only shows whether the final retrieval is correct; it does not identify which cues explain the improvement. Thus, the claimed preservation of view-specific identity information lacks a concrete experimental example.
Questions for authors
1.Could you clarify the comparison conditions and computational costs relative to strong existing methods, and evaluate whether the proposed predictive supervision provides complementary benefits when incorporated into a stronger baseline?
2.Could you add a “baseline + direct cross-view feature alignment” control, using the same backbone, paired samples, and training settings, with appropriate loss-weight tuning, and compare it with PReVIEW?
3.Could you select a concrete cue from Figure 1 and compare PReVIEW with a direct-alignment baseline when that cue is visible versus selectively masked, to test whether the claimed advantage is associated with using that cue?
If these concerns are satisfactorily addressed, I will raise my Rating.
2 comments
Thank you for the detailed response and additional experiments. I consider my first and second concerns addressed. For the first concern, please incorporate the clarified scope, computational costs, and comparison limitations into the manuscript so that the core contribution is stated clearly and the claims remain proportionate to the evidence. Regarding the third concern, I would appreciate either additional experiments directly examining the preservation of view-specific, identity-relevant cues, or an explicit commitment to revise the corresponding mechanistic claims throughout the paper. The current control experiments demonstrate differences between training objectives but do not directly establish cue preservation. At this stage, I will maintain my current rating.
W1+Q1: We thank the reviewer for recognizing the research motivation and experimental results of PReVIEW. We further clarify the advantages and applicable scope of the method relative to existing strong methods. First, under the CARGO AG cross-view protocol, PReVIEW achieves an mAP of 61.25%, which is lower than ViSA's 69.00% and HiHR's 70.53%. However, our main goal is not to comprehensively surpass existing methods by introducing a more complex retrieval architecture, but to explore whether cross-view latent prediction relationships can serve as complementary supervision to improve identity representation quality. Unlike some methods that adopt explicit view disentanglement, local relationship modeling, or generative feature completion, PReVIEW introduces an EMA target encoder and a prediction module only during training. At inference, it still uses the original identity encoder and BNNeck and does not add additional retrieval branches or feature dimensions.
Under the same Swin-B backbone and identity supervision setting, PReVIEW improves CARGO AG Rank-1/mAP from 56.88%/51.17% to 68.75%/61.25%, an increase of 11.87/10.08 percentage points, respectively. To examine applicability across different backbones, we apply PReVIEW to ViT-B/16, achieving 72.12%/65.30% and 63.13%/57.15% under the CARGO ALL and AG protocols, respectively. As a reference, the ViT baselines reported in existing literature are 61.54%/53.54% and 43.13%/40.11%, respectively. These results show that PReVIEW is not limited to the specific structure of Swin-B. Regarding computational overhead, we added training cost statistics under the same experimental environment (λ=0.2). Compared with the Swin-B baseline, PReVIEW increases total training time from 2 h 33 min 38 s to 3 h 15 min 40 s (+27.36%), average per-step time from 0.1889 s to 0.2404 s (+27.26%), and peak GPU memory from 9.48 GiB to 10.48 GiB (+10.53%).
These overheads occur only during training, and the inference structure and retrieval descriptor dimension remain unchanged. Therefore, we believe that the main advantage of PReVIEW is improving identity representation through predictive auxiliary supervision without adding inference modules. We also acknowledge that the additional benefit of combining with other stronger methods has not yet been directly verified and will be supplemented later.
W2+Q2: We thank the reviewer for suggesting a control experiment on direct cross-view feature alignment. We added a Direct Feature Alignment control experiment. Under the same Swin-B backbone, same-identity cross-platform pairing strategy, and training configuration, we retained the same EMA target encoder, stop-gradient mechanism, and bidirectional pairing as PReVIEW, but removed the learnable predictor and directly minimized the squared distance between the source-view online global representation and the target-view EMA global representation. Under the CARGO AG cross-view protocol, the standard Swin-B baseline achieves 56.88% Rank-1 and 51.17% mAP, Direct Alignment achieves 49.38%/43.28%, and PReVIEW achieves 68.75%/61.25%. Compared with direct alignment, PReVIEW improves Rank-1 by 19.37 percentage points and mAP by 17.97 percentage points, respectively. We additionally added a Global-to-Global Prediction control experiment. Under the AG protocol, it achieves 67.50%/60.65%. This result further indicates that under the current training configuration, learnable cross-view predictive supervision can obtain clear benefits, rather than achieving identity learning only by directly reducing the distance between the two view representations.
Based on the existing results, we believe that a preliminary conclusion can be drawn: under the current controlled experimental conditions, direct cross-view feature alignment cannot replace learnable latent predictive supervision, and learnable cross-view prediction provides significantly better performance than direct feature alignment.
W3+Q3: We thank the reviewer for this important suggestion. We agree that the retrieval examples in Figure 4 do not directly establish which identity cues contribute to the improvement. The view-specific cues illustrated in Figure 1 primarily motivate our predictive formulation rather than constitute direct evidence of cue preservation.
To further investigate this motivation, we conducted controlled comparisons under the same Swin-B backbone, training budget, random seed (42), and loss weight (λ=0.2). On the original CARGO AG protocol, Direct Alignment achieves 49.38% Rank-1 / 43.28% mAP, Global-to-Global Prediction achieves 67.50% / 60.65%, and PReVIEW achieves 68.75% / 61.25%. We acknowledge that these results do not isolate specific cues such as clothing textures, shoe details, or head-shoulder contours. However, we mainly learn a mapping and do not aim to delineate fine-grained specific cues.