- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes Text-Anchored Feature Deformation (TAFD) for aerial–ground person re-identification. It argues that forcing both viewpoints into a shared representation can weaken view-specific identity cues. TAFD therefore retains a native descriptor for each image while learning an additional descriptor for the opposite view. The framework consists of three components. Semantic View Anchoring (SVA) uses learnable prompts and a frozen CLIP text encoder to obtain aerial and ground anchors. Directional Feature Deformation (DFD) uses these anchors to guide spatial resampling and attention-based aggregation of multi-level visual features. Target-Space Identity Consistency (TIC) supervises transformed descriptors using target-view classifiers, instances, and identity prototypes. Experiments on CARGO and AGReIDv1 report competitive results, including 72.59% mAP on CARGO A→G and 80.79% average mAP on AGReIDv1. Although the explicit target-view supervision and preservation of native features offer a useful formulation, several issues remain unresolved. The baseline used in component ablations requires clearer justification and consistent training conditions. The semantic contribution of text anchors is not sufficiently distinguished from ordinary learnable conditioning, while the role of view-specific LoRA remains underexplored. A comparison with the closely related CVAF method would further strengthen the evaluation.
Critical strengths
- The explicit target-view identity supervision for cross-view feature transformation. Rather than relying solely on geometric correction or generic feature alignment, the proposed Target-Space Identity Consistency (TIC) supervises transformed descriptors using the destination-view classifier, native instances, and identity prototypes. This provides a concrete discriminative objective for each transformation direction and directly addresses the ambiguity of where deformed features should be mapped. The formulation establishes a meaningful connection between feature deformation and identity preservation, making it a valuable contribution to aerial–ground ReID.
- The design of separate native and transformed representations. By maintaining view-specific identity features while learning independent aerial-to-ground and ground-to-aerial transformations, TAFD offers a unified framework for both cross-view and within-view retrieval. The use of multi-level feature deformation further allows the model to capture spatial variations across viewpoints. The experimental results are also competitive, achieving 72.59% mAP and 76.60% Rank-1 on CARGO aerial-to-ground retrieval, and 80.79% average mAP on AGReIDv1. These results demonstrate the practical potential of the proposed formulation and provide meaningful empirical support for its effectiveness.
Critical weaknesses
- Table 3 describes its baseline as CLIP ViT-B/16 trained under the same framework, yet the reported results exactly match those of the ImageNet-pretrained ViT+Explainable model in the original AG-ReID paper. The paper does not establish whether the baseline and proposed variants use identical pretrained weights, LoRA configurations, and training protocols. This directly undermines the attribution of the reported 7.08-point mAP improvement to DFD.
- SVA generates two global, image-independent anchors, while the transformation directions are already determined by separate deformation networks and target-view supervision. The proposed conditioning could therefore be implemented using ordinary learnable vectors. Without comparing against such alternatives, the experiments do not establish whether CLIP's textual semantics contribute beyond additional learnable parameters and view-specific conditioning.
- DFD combines learnable spatial offsets, multi-level feature aggregation, and attention-based pooling. However, the ablations do not isolate these operations. In particular, a zero-offset variant retaining the same aggregation architecture would determine whether spatial deformation provides meaningful improvements beyond enhanced feature extraction and pooling. This distinction is central to the paper's motivation.
- Including the comparison with CVAF [DOI:10.1145/3785482] would provide a more relevant assessment of TAFD against recent approaches using vision-language representations.
Questions for authors
- In Table 3, was the baseline independently trained using CLIP ViT-B/16 under the same pretraining, LoRA configuration, and training protocol as the proposed variants, or were its results taken from the original AG-ReID paper?
- How does SVA compare with directly learnable view embeddings under identical training settings? What evidence shows that the improvement comes from CLIP's textual semantics rather than view-specific learnable conditioning?
- How does DFD perform when spatial offsets are fixed to zero while retaining the same multi-level features and attention aggregation? How much of the reported improvement can be attributed specifically to spatial deformation?
- How does TAFD compare with CVAF (DOI: 10.1145/3785482) on AGReIDv1? Can the authors include its reported results and clarify any differences in evaluation protocols and training settings?
2 comments
Q3: DFD without spatial offsets.
Thank you for your suggestion. To isolate the contribution of spatial deformation, we conduct an additional experiment where all spatial offsets are fixed to zero, while retaining the same multi-level features, attention aggregation, and training objectives. In this setting, DFD aggregates features from their original spatial locations without learning spatial rearrangement. As shown in Table 2, introducing learnable spatial offsets improves the average mAP from 76.11% to 80.08% and Rank-1 from 84.35% to 86.78%. Specifically, spatial deformation contributes improvements of 4.74% mAP and 2.05% Rank-1 for A→G, and 3.21% mAP and 2.80% Rank-1 for G→A. These results indicate that multi-level feature aggregation alone provides useful representations, but spatial deformation brings substantial additional gains by allowing the model to adaptively reorganize local features across different viewpoints.
Table 2. Contribution of spatial deformation on AGReIDv1.
| Setting | A→G mAP | A→G Rank-1 | G→A mAP | G→A Rank-1 | Avg. mAP | Avg. Rank-1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| DFD w/o spatial offsets | 74.73 | 83.57 | 77.48 | 85.14 | 76.11 | 84.35 |
| DFD | 79.47 | 85.62 | 80.69 | 87.94 | 80.08 | 86.78 |
Q4: Comparison between SVA and CVAF.
A: Thank you for bringing CVAF [1] to our attention. We apologize for overlooking this relevant work. After carefully reading the paper, we found that CVAF reports 79.45% mAP / 87.23% Rank-1 under A→G and 82.59% mAP / 90.12% Rank-1 under G→A on AGReIDv1. For comparison, LATex [2] reports 77.67% / 85.26% and 81.15% / 89.40%, while TAFD achieves 79.55% / 86.46% and 82.03% / 88.57%, respectively. The average mAP is therefore 79.41% for LATex†, 80.79% for TAFD, and 81.02% for CVAF. Although CVAF obtains higher Rank-1, TAFD achieves comparable average mAP and slightly higher A→G mAP.
The baseline comparison provides further context. Our baseline in Table 3 are 74.46% and 77.00% mAP under A→G and G→A, respectively, averaging 75.73%. LATex reports 72.36% and 74.78% mAP for its AIE-only CLIP baseline, averaging 73.57%. Both are largely below CVAF’s CLIP-ReID baseline, which achieves 78.84% and 81.00% mAP, averaging 79.92%. Within their respective settings, TAFD improves average mAP from 75.73% to 80.79%, whereas CVAF improves it from 79.92% to 81.02%. Thus, TAFD achieves competitive final performance from a lower baseline, with a substantial improvement attributable to its proposed components within our experimental setting. We could not locate a publicly available implementation of CVAF, so we have not been able to verify the remaining implementation differences or establish a matched reproduction. We have include CVAF in the related work in the revised manuscript, together with a clarification of these differences.
[1] CVAF: A CLIP-Based View-Consistent Alignment Framework for Aerial-Ground Person Re-Identification. ACM TOMM 2026.
[2] LATex: Leveraging Attribute-based Text Knowledge for Aerial-Ground Person Re-Identification. Arxiv 2025.
Finally, we hope our response has adequately addressed your concerns. If you have any further suggestions, please feel free to discuss them with us. We will provide the corresponding results as soon as possible.
Thanks a lot for identifying this inconsistency. The baseline results in the submitted Table 3 in this paper were taken from the original AG-ReID paper, not independently obtained using CLIP ViT-B/16. They correspond to its ImageNet-pretrained ViT+Explainable model. We initially used this method as our reference baseline, but subsequently failed to update the baseline. We apologize for this reporting error. We have now independently trained a conventional CLIP ViT-B/16 baseline using the same CLIP pretrained weights, view-specific LoRA configuration, and common training protocol as our method. This baseline uses identity classifiers shared across aerial and ground images, with ID and triplet losses, while excluding SVA, DFD, and TIC. We have replaced the original baseline entry in the revised manuscript. The corrected results are provided below.
Thank you for your constructive comments. We clarify that SVA learns identity-supervised, task-adaptive view anchors. Although the CLIP text encoder is frozen, the shared and view-private prompt tokens are trainable and receive gradients from identity-supervised retrieval objectives. The resulting anchors therefore adapt to the re-identification task rather than remaining fixed text embeddings. We agree that trainability and identity supervision alone do not distinguish SVA from ordinary learnable vectors. SVA’s distinction lies in its parameterization: the two anchors are generated through shared/private prompts and the frozen CLIP text encoder, rather than optimized directly as independent vectors.
To evaluate this distinction, we compared SVA with two directly learnable vectors in the Table 2 below. As shown in Table 2, SVA improves mAP and Rank-1 in both retrieval directions compared to learnable vectors. The improvements are 0.48% mAP and 1.18% Rank-1 for A→G, and 0.31% mAP and 0.80% Rank-1 for G→A. These results support the benefit of the SVA over learnable vectors .
Table 1. Comparison between SVA and Learnable Vectors on AGReIDv1 under the same training protocol.