- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3(+1)
- Presentation
- 3(+1)
- Soundness
- 3(+1)
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents RAPR, a Transformer-based framework for aerial–ground person re-identification that uses identity- and view-conditioned local evidence to guide prompt adaptation and feature aggregation. The encoder constructs a view-reduced identity anchor from global and view tokens. RAPR dynamically initializes prompts, selects local tokens using relative identity–view similarity, and adaptively routes complementary contexts to refine the prompts. A subsequent local refinement module learns identity-relevance and view-bias gates to calibrate patch features and guide bidirectional prompt–local interaction. Global and refined local descriptors are concatenated for retrieval.
Critical strengths
1.The paper is clearly presented and well motivated by a meaningful challenge in aerial–ground person re-identification: local cues vary substantially in visibility and usefulness across viewpoints. It clearly explains how unreliable local evidence can affect prompt adaptation and feature aggregation, providing a coherent rationale for the proposed two-stage design.
2.The framework learns local selection and refinement using image-level identity labels and coarse view labels, without requiring patch-level reliability annotations or explicit cross-view correspondences. Each image is also processed independently at inference. These requirements make the approach applicable to existing aerial–ground ReID datasets and avoid additional annotation and input-pairing burdens, supporting its practical usefulness.
Critical weaknesses
1.Sections 4.1 and A.2 state that baseline results are taken from the cited papers unless explicitly marked as reproduced, and SeCap has no reproduction marker in Table 8. However, its reported LAGPeR results differ from the cited publication. For A→G, Table 8 lists SeCap as 40.51/29.59 in Rank-1/mAP, whereas SeCap’s original paper, Table 3, reports 41.79/30.37, exceeding RAPR’s 41.33/29.93. The original SeCap also reports 24.39/19.24 for G→(A+G), above RAPR’s 23.54/18.96. These discrepancies change the rankings and undermine the claim that RAPR leads every metric on LAGPeR. The authors should clarify the source and evaluation settings of these numbers and provide reconciled comparisons.
2.The paper states that it follows the official dataset splits, but the partitioning and validation procedure could be described more explicitly. In particular, Appendix A.3.3 notes that the benchmarks lack official validation splits without specifying whether an independent validation subset was constructed. Please clarify the training, validation, and test partitions, including the numbers of identities and images where applicable, their identity-level separation, and the data used for hyperparameter selection. These details would improve the clarity and reproducibility of the experimental protocol.
3.Table 9 attributes successive improvements to adding the reliable local context (c_2), adding (c_3), and learning the routing weights. However, its first row is explicitly the VDIA-only configuration, which excludes DPI, RAR, and VSLR in Table 4, rather than the complete architecture using only (c_1). The comparison therefore does not establish that the remaining prompt and local processing components are held fixed when (c_2) is introduced. Consequently, the increase in CARGO ALL mAP from 61.20 to 65.23 cannot be uniquely attributed to (c_2). A clearer comparison should retain the same architecture, losses, and descriptor construction while varying only the available contexts.
Questions for authors
1.Could you clarify the source and evaluation settings of the SeCap results in Table 8 and explain their differences from the original publication?
2.Could you specify the training, validation, and test splits, including identity/image counts, identity-level separation, and the data used for hyperparameter selection?
3.Could you add a (c_1)-only baseline within the complete architecture and vary only the contexts, keeping all other components, losses, and descriptor construction fixed?
Response to Reviewer y48o
Thank you for your careful review and Weak Accept assessment. We appreciate your recognition of our design and overall experimental results. Below, we address your concerns about novelty, view-correlated cues, and anchor dependence through revised explanations and additional analyses.
Response to Weakness 1: Novelty relative to SeCap and ViSA
We agree that view decoupling, adaptive prompts, and bidirectional local interaction have precedents. RAPR builds on these ingredients and introduces explicit decisions about which local evidence updates the prompt and how local memory is calibrated before descriptor aggregation.
In particular, ViSA already includes sparse local selection. The distinction is the selection criterion and its role in the computation. RAR ranks patches by r_i = cos(l_i, zI) − cos(l_i, zV). The selected set determines both the local summary and the local keys prioritized during prompt refinement. The context router combines the identity anchor, selected-local summary, and stronger view-suppressed context. VSLR subsequently retains all local tokens and calibrates them through learned identity-conditioned and view-conditioned gates before bidirectional aggregation.
We assess these decisions through controlled comparisons. In Table 5, DPI, context routing, the view-affinity bias, and VSLR are fixed. Replacing identity-only dense scoring with relative dense scoring increases CARGO ALL/A↔G mAP from 65.04/69.18 to 65.57/69.87; adding Top-25% admission further increases it to 66.36/70.74. In revised Table 11, VDIA-only serves as an architectural reference. The other four variants keep the full architecture, losses, and descriptor construction fixed, varying only candidate contexts and fusion. Replacing three-context equal fusion with learned routing improves ALL/A↔G mAP by 0.58/0.58 points on CARGO and A→G/G→A mAP by 0.41/0.43 points on LAGPeR.
These comparisons isolate scoring, admission, and routing decisions within a shared architecture; they do not attribute the entire performance gap over SeCap or ViSA to a single component.
Response to Weakness 2: View affinity and useful identity evidence
We agree that view-correlated clothing and body cues can remain discriminative. At a fixed identity affinity, increasing view affinity does lower the score. This is a preference built into the selection rule, not a claim that every view-correlated cue lacks identity information. A token with high affinity to both references can still be selected if its relative score ranks sufficiently high.
This criterion is reasonable when the identity anchor provides a useful matching reference and the view representation captures variation that may distract prompt adaptation. It favors identity affinity relative to view affinity, without assuming perfect separation. Useful identity cues that are strongly view-correlated may therefore receive lower priority.
RAR restricts the local summary and prioritizes selected keys during prompt refinement, while VSLR receives the full original patch set. Calibration adds learned residual corrections to each original token. The gates depend on the token and both references, rather than view affinity alone, and are optimized through the image-level training objective. A patch excluded by RAR can therefore still contribute to local aggregation, although calibration does not guarantee that every useful cue is preserved without attenuation.
Table 5 tests the scoring preference directly: under dense admission, relative scoring improves CARGO ALL/A↔G mAP over identity-only scoring by 0.53/0.69 points; sparse admission adds another 0.79/0.87 points. Table 6 further compares separately trained selection strategies at the same token budget. Highest-score selection leads Rank-1 in all four protocols and mAP in three, with LAGPeR A→G mAP 0.05 points below random selection. The revised Sections 3.2.2 and 3.3 accordingly describe relative evidence priority and learned token calibration, without treating view affinity as a universal measure of identity irrelevance.